Maybe.
None of us here, as far as I am aware, knows you in real life. We only know you as you have presented and revealed yourself on the forum.
It is apparent that you are, and have been, on a self journey for a long time. What exactly that journey is, and where it might lead I cannot say...
If you are implying that @rosends is ill informed about traditional Jewish understandings, I would simply point out, if you are unaware of the fact, that rosends is an Orthodox rabbi.
In the interest of fostering the civil environment that is one of the aims of the forum, why don’t we just acknowledge that this is an area of disagreement and let it go at that?
There is certainly nothing improper in recommending that someone who is, or is interested in becoming, an adherent of a particular faith, read the scriptures of that faith. However, in your remark, so matter how inadvertent, you crossed a line.
I would ask you to consider what your response...
Well, here is one for @metis. (It’s been awhile since I’ve ribbed the man who babysat me.)
I’m surprised your wife fell for you since her Neanderthal DNA is only 1/25th of yours!
(Yes, I know there will be a rejoinder. metis and I have honed this act for a very long time.)
@Seeker of White Light -
There is a small coterie of forum members who are, and will be, more than happy to criticize Baha’i as often as possible and they will do so without needing an invitation from you.
I don’t happen to be among them.
To each and all, a good new year, a sweet new year.
May we continue to learn together, to grow together.
May our joys be abundant, our difficulties and disappointments be few.
May we know the wholeness of peace, the peace of wholeness.
And….. may we each have an easy fast.