Dear siti, I see the circle expanding and collapsing in your chimp avatar, so you are online, though might not be at your computer.
I will be back in three hours time.
So, let us work as to concur on what is the meaning of the word beginning.
I am waiting.
There was a guy here who asked for my concept of beginning, I gave it and he ran away.
Another guy talked about the the problem of induction, he ran away also.
So, you also ran away, and then returned, this is the second time you have come back.
So, let you present your...
You say: "And I have repeatedly shown that none of these are evidence of a universe without a beginning."
You see, dear siti, we have got to concur on what is the concept of beginning.
Dear everyone here, this thread is about Is it possible to talk with an atheist, of course I also welcome anyone else to join up, on condition that you are a functioning human and not crazy.
So, what have I learned in this thread?
I have learned that it is impossible to talk with people who do...
@ALL who have the skill and habit to think on reason grounding themselves on observation as to come to intelligent conclusion.
Quick message to all you guys who read this thread.
Recall that science is into discovering and/or inventing new things or ways and means to doing things: better...
@leibowde84
Dear leibowde84, you are taking to flight, like creatures of darkness that cannot stand the light - though you can run still you cannot hide.
So, when you if ever you return, let you just present one objection per post against my proof of God existing [see Annex below], from the...
Wait, that list of six steps, I missed one step, the No. 6 step.
Here, the whole argument again, in all six steps, see where is the circular reasoning you guys are looking for.
1. Enunciate the concept of God, namely, in concept God is the creator of everything with a beginning...
Where am I before I go out to look for evidence of God existing, in concept as the creator of everything with a beginning?
I am in my home thinking over my thoughts in my mind, on the concept of God as the creator of everything with a beginning.
Then I go from thinking in my mind to observing...
@leibowde84
Dear leibowde84
You say this statement from me is circular reasoninng.
b 1. Enunciate the concept of God, namely, in concept God is the creator of everything with a beginning. e
I don't see any reasoning there, much less circular reasoning.
______________________
quote From...
Dear readers here old and new, let us sit back and await with bated breath to witness how Shad is going to react to my post addressed to him, he seems like a sensible person.
I am just inviting him to present, when he writes to reply to my earlier post here, the concept of God, if he has any of...
@Shad
Dear stranger Shad, welcome to my thread.
First, can you tell me what is that number after my name, it is now 73, thanks.
Now, will you just simply tell me what is your concept of God, if you have any information at all of a concept of God inside your brain; there, we can get started...
Dear stranger, when you give links for me to go to, please just reproduce what is the most important texts there that you want me to read, and of course don't neglect to put their links as well, together with the texts.
That is my request all the time, and when posters don't do that, I don't...
Welcome, stranger.
Now, as you came just now, suppose you just tell everyone here what is your concept of God; you see this thread from yours truly is on "Is it possible to talk with an atheist?"
Of course I welcome anyone even not atheist.
The talk is about the existence of God, and I always...
Thanks everyone for your presence and participation.
Now, here is again my explanation for why the universe has a beginning, see Annex below but I will reproduce the text of concern right away as follows:
All right, dear readers, let us now as per routine sit back and await with bated breath...
@siti
@leibowde84
@columbus
Dear siti, you say:
“Here is my evidence for the universe not having a beginning...(drum roll)...my arse...ta dahh!!!! Yes I win! Hooray! Three cheers for me.”
Now, I tell you, You are not going to seek escape with bringing in matters that you find in my latest...
@siti
@leibowde84
@columbus
Dear readers here, things are getting very exciting, and I hope that siti and company my corresponding posters here, they don't get flippant, that is not being academic.
Now, dear siti, I tell you time and again, not to dwell inside your brain with manipulation...
Part 2
And I am glad that he agrees with me that the determination of the unversed having a beginning or not, it must be decided on evidence, not with manipulation of words all inside his brain, though the brain of siti, he can also show to us that it has no beginning, thus adding to the...
@siti
@leibowde84
@columbus
[Part 1 of two parts]
Dear siti, you say:
“Here is my evidence for the universe not having a beginning...(drum roll)...my arse...ta dahh!!!! Yes I win! Hooray! Three cheers for me.”
That is very good because you have come to your senses, with presenting as we...