dyanaprajna2011
Dharmapala
In his book, Beyond Belief, AL De Silva, in the chapter titled 'Buddhism-The Logical Alternative', states:
Christianity is based solely on metaphysical speculation, the results of which cannot be verified, and only benefited from after death. Buddhism, on the other hand, is based on a logical approach to the reality of existence, the practice of which can be experienced and benefited from in the here and now. Buddhism is more pragmatic, while Christianity is more speculative. The reason why, if it was proven the Buddha never existed, or if there are mistakes in our scriptures, Buddhism would still go on, and has for the last 2500 years, is simply that the teaching and practices in Buddhism work. Millions of people throughout the ages have experienced the bliss and joy of having relieved their suffering. Millions have gained the wisdom that comes from enlightenment. And it still goes on today. Does Christianity have any immediate, non-speculative and non-metaphysical, pragmatic and practical benefits like this? Any thoughts on the quote?Christianity is based upon certain supposed historical events (the virgin birth, the resurrection, etc.), the only record of which is an allegedly reliable document called the Bible. If these events can be shown to have never occurred or if the documents recording these events can be shown to be unreliable, the Christianity will collapse. In this book we have shown that Christian claims are at best highly doubtful and at worst demonstrably wrong. When we examine the teachings of the Buddha we find an entirely different situation. Even if we were able to prove that the Buddha never existed or that there are mistakes in the Buddhist scriptures this would not necessarily undermine Buddhism. Why is this? Because Buddhism is not primarily about the historical Buddha or about events which happened in the past; rather, it is about human suffering, what causes that suffering, and how it can be overcome so that humans can be free, happy, and radiant. If we wish to understand or verify Buddhism we would not have to flip through scriptures squabbling about the meaning of various words or phrases. Rather, we become sensitive to our own experiences.