We Never Know
No Slack
Why should she?
Why would she lie?
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Why should she?
There's many possibilities, and that she's lying isn't necessarily one of them.Why would she lie?
I doubt she would lie. But I wonder what you believe about her visitations. Do you think it could be real or do you think it's a production of her brain as far as something gone wrong or not for real. There was a story in the news about a 10-year old boy who said he heard voices in his head for a while and took a gun from his mother's gun cabinet and shot and killed her. So yes, I'm asking you if you think she hears voices, or sees and hears things because her brain isn't wired correctly. Or imagines it and it has become like a reality for her now. Let me try to clarify, if possible. Do you think your friend is really in contact with spirit persons you are not in contact with, and if so, do you think these spirit persons are real? Not just for her reality, but for real in all realities where you are possibly not privy to these manifestations. I hope you understand my question better now. No, I'm not saying she's lying.Why would she lie?
OK, checking, I see you said you don't believe what she does. (What does that mean? That you don't believe her, or what she does? Do you believe she is in contact with spirits claiming to be dead people?)I know you wouldn't try to convince me and I had many years of spiritual experiences after Christianity and before non belief. My best friend is a person who also communicates with spirits. She knows I don't believe what she does but I never judge her or say I don't believe her. What is important is she helps others who do believe in spirits and communicating with people who have passed. It helps her and her clients and it is done in a loving and compassionate manner. Much different than the proselytizing, fear mongering, judgemental and destructive belief systems.
Thanks for sharing your journeys.
I believe that my friend @Sgt. Pepper is really in contact with spirit persons and I believe these spirit persons are real. She has psychic abilities and she is a psychic medium. Not everyone has these abilities, few people do.Let me try to clarify, if possible. Do you think your friend is really in contact with spirit persons you are not in contact with, and if so, do you think these spirit persons are real? Not just for her reality, but for real in all realities where you are possibly not privy to these manifestations. I hope you understand my question better now. No, I'm not saying she's lying.
I believe that my friend @Sgt. Pepper is really in contact with spirit persons and I believe these spirit persons are real. She has psychic abilities and she is a psychic medium. Not everyone has these abilities, few people do.
I’m usually accused of being an atheist but I remain a theist.
It means that I don't believe she can actually communicate with spirits. Why? Because I just don't happen to believe in spirits anymore. Spirits meaning some type of immeasurable, energy or consciousness contained in living being that somehow survives natural death and further is living in some immeasurable space within the measurable universes and is somehow able to physically interact with living humans.OK, checking, I see you said you don't believe what she does. (What does that mean? That you don't believe her, or what she does? Do you believe she is in contact with spirits claiming to be dead people?)
I tend to agree with atheists on forums regarding certain criticisms. Many assume only atheists would tell them that they are mistaken.Out of curiosity, why were you accused of being an atheist when you are a theist?
It is nice to see you again.I just don't happen to believe in spirits anymore. Spirits meaning some type of immeasurable, energy or consciousness contained in living being that somehow survives natural death and further is living in some immeasurable space within the measurable universes and is somehow able to physically interact with living humans.
So do I.I tend to agree with atheists on forums regarding certain criticisms.
It is nice to see you again.
I guess that what you used to believe spirits are? I believe that the human spirit is synonymous with the human soul, and that when the physical body dies the soul survives death and takes on another form, a spiritual body. I don't believe a spirit is some kind of free-floating energy floating around in space, I believe it has a form which allows it to function, just as we have a physical body that allows us to function in this world. There is no way to know what that form will be like, but some psychic mediums have said that it resembles the body we had here, only it is not physical. That is also what the Baha'i Writings and the Bible seem to indicate, in so many words.
I don't believe that spirits are able to communicate to living humans in this world from the spiritual world, not unless that communication is facilitated by a psychic medium.
What @Sgt. Pepper has experienced are earthbound spirits who are trying to communicate with her, rather than spirits that reside in the spiritual world, and that is another subject.
Yes, that is what happened to my friend @Truthseeker and I think he told you the story. The spirit of as dead relative appeared to him and she looked like an actual person and then she vanished before his eyes. I have heard a lot of similar stories and seen them on TV.Yes, human spirits resemble living people when they manifest as either a partial or full-body apparition, and they will be transparent. Some spirits can, however, appear as a full-body apparition that resembles a solid (flesh and blood) living person, but they will need a massive amount of energy to do it. If you see these spirits, you'll think it's an actual person, only to see them vanish right before your eyes.
Yes, that is what happened to my friend @Truthseeker and I think he told you the story. The spirit of as dead relative appeared to him and she looked like an actual person and then she vanished before his eyes. I have heard a lot of similar stories and seen them on TV.
If spirits who are physically dead can appear like an actual person, why couldn't that be what the disciples and others saw after Jesus was crucified? Most Christians will argue that the physical body of Jesus must have risen from the grave and came back to life, in order for the Bible stories to be true, but I don't understand why that would have to be the case. They could have seen an apparition of Jesus that appeared and looked just like his physical body.
OK, so you think she's imagining it and she and others she influences believe she's telling the truth. OK.It means that I don't believe she can actually communicate with spirits. Why? Because I just don't happen to believe in spirits anymore. Spirits meaning some type of immeasurable, energy or consciousness contained in living being that somehow survives natural death and further is living in some immeasurable space within the measurable universes and is somehow able to physically interact with living humans.
I don't think my friend or anyone else who believes they communicate with spirits is lying. I know they believe it because I also used to believe it.
So no, I don't personally believe she is in contact with spirits and no, I don't think she is lying about her experiences. So I would never tell her that I think she is lying to me.
And no, I don't care to explain why I don't believe in spirits anymore other than I now believe there are physiological, psychological and emotional explanations for the experiences. I'm also not saying I am right about this, I am agnostic about them because as of now, they haven't been proven not to exist.
It's comments like these that make me realize what a blessing I have to realize that God warned His people, the Israelites, NOT to communicate with the dead. Or anything like a "spirit medium."It is nice to see you again.
I guess that what you used to believe spirits are? I believe that the human spirit is synonymous with the human soul, and that when the physical body dies the soul survives death and takes on another form, a spiritual body. I don't believe a spirit is some kind of free-floating energy floating around in space, I believe it has a form which allows it to function, just as we have a physical body that allows us to function in this world. There is no way to know what that form will be like, but some psychic mediums have said that it resembles the body we had here, only it is not physical. That is also what the Baha'i Writings and the Bible seem to indicate, in so many words.
I don't believe that spirits are able to communicate to living humans in this world from the spiritual world, not unless that communication is facilitated by a psychic medium.
What @Sgt. Pepper has experienced are earthbound spirits who are trying to communicate with her, rather than spirits that reside in the spiritual world, and that is another subject.
It means that I don't believe she can actually communicate with spirits. Why? Because I just don't happen to believe in spirits anymore. Spirits meaning some type of immeasurable, energy or consciousness contained in living being that somehow survives natural death and further is living in some immeasurable space within the measurable universes and is somehow able to physically interact with living humans.
I don't think my friend or anyone else who believes they communicate with spirits is lying. I know they believe it because I also used to believe it.
So no, I don't personally believe she is in contact with spirits and no, I don't think she is lying about her experiences. So I would never tell her that I think she is lying to me.
And no, I don't care to explain why I don't believe in spirits anymore other than I now believe there are physiological, psychological and emotional explanations for the experiences. I'm also not saying I am right about this, I am agnostic about them because as of now, they haven't been proven not to exist.
It is nice to see you again.
I guess that what you used to believe spirits are? I believe that the human spirit is synonymous with the human soul, and that when the physical body dies the soul survives death and takes on another form, a spiritual body. I don't believe a spirit is some kind of free-floating energy floating around in space, I believe it has a form which allows it to function, just as we have a physical body that allows us to function in this world. There is no way to know what that form will be like, but some psychic mediums have said that it resembles the body we had here, only it is not physical. That is also what the Baha'i Writings and the Bible seem to indicate, in so many words.
I don't believe that spirits are able to communicate to living humans in this world from the spiritual world, not unless that communication is facilitated by a psychic medium.
What @Sgt. Pepper has experienced are earthbound spirits who are trying to communicate with her, rather than spirits that reside in the spiritual world, and that is another subject.
I would consider the term soul to be interchangeable with spirit and would use the same criteria as to their description and ability to exist whether in this world or some other immeasurable place you call the spirit world in the universes.It is nice to see you again.
I guess that what you used to believe spirits are? I believe that the human spirit is synonymous with the human soul, and that when the physical body dies the soul survives death and takes on another form, a spiritual body. I don't believe a spirit is some kind of free-floating energy floating around in space, I believe it has a form which allows it to function, just as we have a physical body that allows us to function in this world. There is no way to know what that form will be like, but some psychic mediums have said that it resembles the body we had here, only it is not physical. That is also what the Baha'i Writings and the Bible seem to indicate, in so many words.
I don't believe that spirits are able to communicate to living humans in this world from the spiritual world, not unless that communication is facilitated by a psychic medium.
What @Sgt. Pepper has experienced are earthbound spirits who are trying to communicate with her, rather than spirits that reside in the spiritual world, and that is another subject.
I am really glad you are able to share your experiences and that people are more accepting of them without degrading what you do or insulting you personally. That is just not kind. I know there are many people who believe and have been helped emotionally by mediums such as yourself. And what an exciting ability!I know that your post wasn't directed at me, but I still wanted to say that I do appreciate your honesty and willingness to talk about this topic despite the fact that you don't believe. Personally, I don't mind skeptics as long as they're polite and don't treat me badly or make fun of me. I'm not bothered by the fact that some individuals don't believe ghosts are real, psychic mediumship is possible, or that there is anything else paranormal. I understand that their skepticism does not change the fact that I've been a psychic medium since I was six years old. However, I'm pleased to know that believing in ghosts and other paranormal phenomena has become more acceptable in contemporary society. As I noted in another post here, the negative stigma associated with believing in ghosts (and in other paranormal phenomena) has significantly decreased over the past twenty years or so. In fact, I think that's very encouraging.