• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Aren't you glad Jesus got violently executed? Why not?

Spiderman

Veteran Member
It seems Christianity ( in it's main branches at least) can't deny that the violent humiliation, crowning with thorns, martyrdom/execution of their founder and "Messiah" (God-Incarnate according to most traditions) was simply fantastic/excellent/great (something to celebrate and delightful to contemplate and make artwork and movies of even).

John the Baptist said Christ was "the lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world".

As the Angel of death was going around killing Egyptian babies and children (because God "hardened Pharaoh's heart"o_O) at God's command, the lamb had to be violently slain, eaten, and blood smeared on the doorposts.

Jesus clearly wanted to be eaten as the Paschal Lamb, but also wanted to be killed (because his Father wanted him killed). When it was time for Christ to die, he didn't say, "now has the time for my humiliation and violent death come", he said "now has the time come for the Son of man to be glorified...for this reason I came into the world".

So, can't we thank the people that stripped him down, put all that energy into making a cross, flogging his flesh so that by his stripes we are healed, making that lovely crown of thorns (crown for a King of Kings), pounding those nails into his hands and feet, and lancing his side? We can't thank them enough.

download (13).jpeg


That sounds like hard disturbing work to me that helped with our redemption. Somebody's gotta do it right?

Abraham's call to fame and glory was he agreed to a voice instructing him to slit the throat of (and burn) his only son. Now adays Doctors and mental health professionals wouldn't find that to be noble or healthy behavior and prescribe meds and straight jackets for people hearing voices tell them to do such deeds, (especially to children).

(Could you imagine Isaac's concern about his (very old) Father's mental health then, or how a therapist would deal with something like that? Foster care for Isaac , and a nursing home for Abe perhaps ? :D)

Maybe Jesus chose Judas to betray him and commit suicide, and Peter to deny him thrice, not in spite of their folly, but because of it?

Can Christians rejoice over it all? Isn't that what redeemed and saved the world even more than the sunshine itself?

What is ugly? Painful is good, for Bible is full of violence, ugliness, and pain to accomplish God's agenda. How about the scorched Earth policies, slavery, and total genocides God ordered so that Israel would glorify him and have a promised land?

God is entertained by or delighted by it. It doesn't seem one can argue otherwise, but please do, because it's an easy debate for me to win if we go by the Bible or Quran.

Anyway, I get to feeling really bad about my mental and emotional health , so having something like the Bible makes me feel a little better.

Compared to Yahweh I'm....:D (Not healthy, but... ) less violent and more compassionate (and don't contradict myself as much).

I love my earthly Father but make fun of him all the time. I give Abba a bad time. Doesn't mean I don't love him. Israel means "contender with God" (for newbies) .:)

Also, I'm not promoting the acts and none of them were illegal regarding the Old Testament stuff. (Not by God's law despite God violating his own 10 commandments too many times to count. Who will put God on trial?. ;) I would wonder what @Kelly of the Phoenix would have to say about some of this. Or you gentle reader. :)
 
Last edited:

Rival

Diex Aie
Staff member
Premium Member
He was certainly a false teacher, imo, and he deserved ignoring at the least and driving out at best. Killing him may have been going too far, because it didn't exactly make his message go away...
 

Nakosis

Non-Binary Physicalist
Premium Member
It seems Christianity ( in it's main branches at least) can't deny that the violent humiliation, crowning with thorns, martyrdom/execution of their founder and "Messiah" (God-Incarnate according to most traditions) was simply fantastic/excellent/great (something to celebrate and delightful to contemplate and make artwork and movies of even).

John the Baptist said Christ was "the lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world".

As the Angel of death was going around killing Egyptian babies and children (because God "hardened Pharaoh's heart"o_O) at God's command, the lamb had to be violently slain, eaten, and blood smeared on the doorposts.

Jesus clearly wanted to be eaten as the Paschal Lamb, but also wanted to be killed (because his Father wanted him killed). When it was time for Christ to die, he didn't say, "now has the time for my humiliation and violent death come", he said "now has the time come for the Son of man to be glorified...for this reason I came into the world".

So, can't we thank the people that stripped him down, put all that energy into making a cross, flogging his flesh so that by his stripes we are healed, making that lovely crown of thorns (crown for a King of Kings), pounding those nails into his hands and feet, and lancing his side? We can't thank them enough.

View attachment 54126

That sounds like hard disturbing work to me that helped with our redemption. Somebody's gotta do it right?

Abraham's call to fame and glory was he agreed to a voice instructing him to slit the throat of (and burn) his only son. Now adays Doctors and mental health professionals wouldn't find that to be noble or healthy behavior and prescribe meds and straight jackets for people hearing voices tell them to do such deeds, (especially to children).

(Could you imagine Isaac's concern about his (very old) Father's mental health then, or how a therapist would deal with something like that? Foster care for Isaac , and a nursing home for Abe perhaps ? :D)

Maybe Jesus chose Judas to betray him and commit suicide, and Peter to deny him thrice, not in spite of their folly, but because of it?

Can Christians rejoice over it all? Isn't that what redeemed and saved the world even more than the sunshine itself?

What is ugly? Painful is good, for Bible is full of violence, ugliness, and pain to accomplish God's agenda. How about the scorched Earth policies, slavery, and total genocides God ordered so that Israel would glorify him and have a promised land?

God is entertained by or delighted by it. It doesn't seem one can argue otherwise, but please do, because it's an easy debate for me to win if we go by the Bible or Quran.

Anyway, I get to feeling really bad about my mental and emotional health , so having something like the Bible makes me feel a little better.

Compared to Yahweh I'm....:D (Not healthy, but... ) less violent and more compassionate (and don't contradict myself as much).

I love my earthly Father but make fun of him all the time. I give Abba a bad time. Doesn't mean I don't love him. Israel means "contender with God" (for newbies) .:)

Also, I'm not promoting the acts and none of them were illegal regarding the Old Testament stuff. (Not by God's law despite God violating his own 10 commandments too many times to count. Who will put God on trial?. ;) I would wonder what @Kelly of the Phoenix would have to say about God breaking his commandments. Or you gentle reader. :)

IT, IMO, justifies the despicable nature of man as promoted by the church.
Do you think this is what Jesus wanted?

I think it more likely the narrative created because Jesus was not the Messiah they expected.
 

sun rise

The world is on fire
Premium Member
I don't believe Jesus died on the cross (a different matter) but that the Christ voluntarily takes on the suffering of creation in order to move it forward (I would not use the word 'sin' either).
 

Jeremiah Ames

Well-Known Member
Of course, I’m not glad.

But his death, and the horrible treatment he received while on earth was done for a reason. The same reason the prophets did the unusual things they did and the way some died.

It is all a representation of the destruction the Jewish religion was doing to the scriptures.
 

osgart

Nothing my eye, Something for sure
I guess it beats choosing to have mercy from above without all the crucifixion drama and victimization.

Christianity is there to inform us all how crazy, and senseless human nature can be. It's invented to stamp out real justice in the world. Crazy and senseless must be the point of the religion.

If you can find sense in it, amen, so be it. I can't find any sense in it. Wouldn't it be better to find genuine justifications that all reasonable people can live with instead of creating a God that kills and commands killing while offering no reasons for all the death and destruction.

I think sincere believers like to make of it what they need and wish it to be. All other believers use it for politics, and lifestyle.
 

danieldemol

Veteran Member
Premium Member
I'm grateful for the progress that came from martyred people, but not glad that they were martyred, as it was not necessarily inevitable.

If we were sufficiently educated we could sort the good things that martyrs taught from the negative teachings and provided they weren't a threat to the safety of the people (i don't really know if the Historical Jesus was an armed rebel or not), they needn't be executed (especially in societies where imprisonment is a practical option).

In my opinion.
 

Kenny

Face to face with my Father
Premium Member
It seems Christianity ( in it's main branches at least) can't deny that the violent humiliation, crowning with thorns, martyrdom/execution of their founder and "Messiah" (God-Incarnate according to most traditions) was simply fantastic/excellent/great (something to celebrate and delightful to contemplate and make artwork and movies of even).

John the Baptist said Christ was "the lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world".

As the Angel of death was going around killing Egyptian babies and children (because God "hardened Pharaoh's heart"o_O) at God's command, the lamb had to be violently slain, eaten, and blood smeared on the doorposts.

Jesus clearly wanted to be eaten as the Paschal Lamb, but also wanted to be killed (because his Father wanted him killed). When it was time for Christ to die, he didn't say, "now has the time for my humiliation and violent death come", he said "now has the time come for the Son of man to be glorified...for this reason I came into the world".

So, can't we thank the people that stripped him down, put all that energy into making a cross, flogging his flesh so that by his stripes we are healed, making that lovely crown of thorns (crown for a King of Kings), pounding those nails into his hands and feet, and lancing his side? We can't thank them enough.

View attachment 54126

That sounds like hard disturbing work to me that helped with our redemption. Somebody's gotta do it right?

Abraham's call to fame and glory was he agreed to a voice instructing him to slit the throat of (and burn) his only son. Now adays Doctors and mental health professionals wouldn't find that to be noble or healthy behavior and prescribe meds and straight jackets for people hearing voices tell them to do such deeds, (especially to children).

(Could you imagine Isaac's concern about his (very old) Father's mental health then, or how a therapist would deal with something like that? Foster care for Isaac , and a nursing home for Abe perhaps ? :D)

Maybe Jesus chose Judas to betray him and commit suicide, and Peter to deny him thrice, not in spite of their folly, but because of it?

Can Christians rejoice over it all? Isn't that what redeemed and saved the world even more than the sunshine itself?

What is ugly? Painful is good, for Bible is full of violence, ugliness, and pain to accomplish God's agenda. How about the scorched Earth policies, slavery, and total genocides God ordered so that Israel would glorify him and have a promised land?

God is entertained by or delighted by it. It doesn't seem one can argue otherwise, but please do, because it's an easy debate for me to win if we go by the Bible or Quran.

Anyway, I get to feeling really bad about my mental and emotional health , so having something like the Bible makes me feel a little better.

Compared to Yahweh I'm....:D (Not healthy, but... ) less violent and more compassionate (and don't contradict myself as much).

I love my earthly Father but make fun of him all the time. I give Abba a bad time. Doesn't mean I don't love him. Israel means "contender with God" (for newbies) .:)

Also, I'm not promoting the acts and none of them were illegal regarding the Old Testament stuff. (Not by God's law despite God violating his own 10 commandments too many times to count. Who will put God on trial?. ;) I would wonder what @Kelly of the Phoenix would have to say about some of this. Or you gentle reader. :)
Can I rejoice that God knows much more than we do?

I am also glad that Abraham entered into covenant with God to open the gateway for The Word to pay for our sins (The Lamb of God that takes away the sins of the world)
 

shunyadragon

shunyadragon
Premium Member
No, but that is the consequence of the chain of events in the life of Jesus and the times he lived regardless of whether his claim was true of not.

Jesus claimed to fulfilled the prophecies of the OT for the promised Messiah and the claim of being the King of the Jews. This crime was punishable by execution by Roman authorities for treason against Rome. The punishment for this crime was crucifiction
 

Spiderman

Veteran Member
No, it's an indictment of humanity that it came to that.
I know. I was in a weirdo mood when I made this thread. I was giving God a bad time but in a loving way, just my sense of humor is weird and I think Abba (Daddy) can be bizzare sometimes.

Hey, I like your new avatar by the way Frank. Charming smile and cap. :)

I just got a clean shave today. The Rosary I got yesterday. I got clean off drugs in May.

IMG_20210823_210955.jpg

Just know God loves you and so does Saint Francis of Assisi I believe. I sometimes get the hunch you feel like a leper , but I would never know it by most of your posts. You give me hope in many areas because things just are not black and white. You also helped me overcome some of my offensive far-right views, obsession with right wing Dictators, and phobias of certain people.

You think very rationally and offer thoughts like a Theologian sometimes and yet have experimented with Islam, Catholicism, Orthodoxy, Paganism, other.

I didn't think I would see you wearing that cap. I love it! :)

Don't ever feel life is worthless. You never know the people you impact. ;)

(Sorry, Not relevant to the thread I guess, but not empty flattery either. I don't flatter unless it's from the heart. And I'm proud of you, and your mom (and Dad you never got to meet) should be proud. Glad your Mom never followed through with her temptation to abortion, and it's good for my views to be challenged.

You have a Dad in Heaven and he is proud of you. Don't give up. Stand your ground! And feel free to give me a slap upside the head when I'm being a dingbat! :)
 

1213

Well-Known Member
...God violating his own 10 commandments too many times to count. ...

It seems to me that you don’t really know what the Bible tells, so many baseless claims. But, please tell, what commandment God has violated and how?
 
  • Like
Reactions: DNB

Spiderman

Veteran Member
It seems to me that you don’t really know what the Bible tells, so many baseless claims. But, please tell, what commandment God has violated and how?
"Thou shalt not kill"

But then ordering women and babies and children to be killed is one example.

But I kinda made my peace with God yesterday so don't want to ruin that just yet.
 

DNB

Christian
It seems Christianity ( in it's main branches at least) can't deny that the violent humiliation, crowning with thorns, martyrdom/execution of their founder and "Messiah" (God-Incarnate according to most traditions) was simply fantastic/excellent/great (something to celebrate and delightful to contemplate and make artwork and movies of even).

John the Baptist said Christ was "the lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world".

As the Angel of death was going around killing Egyptian babies and children (because God "hardened Pharaoh's heart"o_O) at God's command, the lamb had to be violently slain, eaten, and blood smeared on the doorposts.

Jesus clearly wanted to be eaten as the Paschal Lamb, but also wanted to be killed (because his Father wanted him killed). When it was time for Christ to die, he didn't say, "now has the time for my humiliation and violent death come", he said "now has the time come for the Son of man to be glorified...for this reason I came into the world".

So, can't we thank the people that stripped him down, put all that energy into making a cross, flogging his flesh so that by his stripes we are healed, making that lovely crown of thorns (crown for a King of Kings), pounding those nails into his hands and feet, and lancing his side? We can't thank them enough.

View attachment 54126

That sounds like hard disturbing work to me that helped with our redemption. Somebody's gotta do it right?

Abraham's call to fame and glory was he agreed to a voice instructing him to slit the throat of (and burn) his only son. Now adays Doctors and mental health professionals wouldn't find that to be noble or healthy behavior and prescribe meds and straight jackets for people hearing voices tell them to do such deeds, (especially to children).

(Could you imagine Isaac's concern about his (very old) Father's mental health then, or how a therapist would deal with something like that? Foster care for Isaac , and a nursing home for Abe perhaps ? :D)

Maybe Jesus chose Judas to betray him and commit suicide, and Peter to deny him thrice, not in spite of their folly, but because of it?

Can Christians rejoice over it all? Isn't that what redeemed and saved the world even more than the sunshine itself?

What is ugly? Painful is good, for Bible is full of violence, ugliness, and pain to accomplish God's agenda. How about the scorched Earth policies, slavery, and total genocides God ordered so that Israel would glorify him and have a promised land?

God is entertained by or delighted by it. It doesn't seem one can argue otherwise, but please do, because it's an easy debate for me to win if we go by the Bible or Quran.

Anyway, I get to feeling really bad about my mental and emotional health , so having something like the Bible makes me feel a little better.

Compared to Yahweh I'm....:D (Not healthy, but... ) less violent and more compassionate (and don't contradict myself as much).

I love my earthly Father but make fun of him all the time. I give Abba a bad time. Doesn't mean I don't love him. Israel means "contender with God" (for newbies) .:)

Also, I'm not promoting the acts and none of them were illegal regarding the Old Testament stuff. (Not by God's law despite God violating his own 10 commandments too many times to count. Who will put God on trial?. ;) I would wonder what @Kelly of the Phoenix would have to say about some of this. Or you gentle reader. :)
What should impress you is how God is able to deal with both the good and bad in life, in regard to both people and circumstances, and in some inexplicable and wise manner intertwine all their actions to either, let the wicked people mete out justice (get their hands dirty), allow the faithful to be glorified at the hands of the condemned, expose the faults of some but allowing a greater good to transpire.

God is revealing that life on earth is temporal, that justice will not always be exacted, the good may die young, and thus we shouldn't put our hopes in what occurs on earth. That His ways are unsearchable, and that it is His prerogative to do as He likes - but, that we He likes, is always good.
 
Top