Thank you everybody. I will have to look into a Justice of the Peace, although I live in Iowa. I don't think too many people at the courthouse will even know what I'm talking about. I guess the question I should have asked was: "How can we have an atheist wedding without discrimination and also have people take our marriage seriously?" Unfortunately, I think I'm asking too much out of humanity.Oh, I'm so sorry. That's terrible...
Oh, don't be sorry - it's water under the bridge. I'm very glad I caught on to his cheatin' ways before we tied the knot.
Your family will take your marriage seriously however you do it. What they might be is
disappointed, but not dismissive. My fiance's Catholic mother was pretty heartbroken her son wouldn't be married in a Catholic church, but she also understood that it would have been dishonest, since I'm not a Catholic or even a Christian, and that it was OUR day, not hers. You shouldn't worry about your parents or your family - what matters is that YOU take your marriage seriously, and with me that never would have happened if our vows were sandwiched in a long, boring sermon about religious crap I don't believe in and a bunch of rituals and symbols that are meaningless to me.
Unfortunately, my parents are Catholics. They won't pay for an atheist party...
S'OK - the bride's parents are supposed to pay.
Also, it's much cheaper to break the mold when it comes to weddings. Our wedding was only going to cost us 1 or 2 grand, most of which would be spent on food and beer - not 10 or 20 grand like the religious weddings I've been to. Once you get started with a "traditional" wedding, it's hard to stop. First it's just "we should do it in a church because that's what my parents want", then before you know it you have 5 bridesmaids in matching dresses and a fully catered hall, a thousand dollars worth of flowers, a ridiculous-looking dress you will only wear once in your life that cost more than any other garment you will ever own, an open wine bar and a professional photographer AND videographer.
BTW, I forgot to mention, my cousin got married in a brewery in 2007. No kidding. It was a really nice wedding, and the food was great. The beer was pretty good too. There was no question of people not taking it seriously - he and his wife are so obviously in love.