Okay, what are the God revealed Scriptures of Hinduism, Buddhism and Judaism... And, who was the "manifestation" that revealed them? Those "revealed" Scriptures should still be true, since you're saying that only the interpretations were wrong.
But I think Baha'is believe the Scriptures themselves have issues, because they were written by the followers of that religion years later. So there is no way to know what the "manifestation" really "revealed". And, you'd think if these Scriptures were "The Word of God" they could be trusted to be true. But Baha'is tell us we can't. And we can't, for sure, take them literally. So if not literal, then what? We have to interpret them allegorically?
So the textbook, the Scriptures, are flawed and, on top of that, the teachers are not teaching "facts" but teaching their flawed interpretation of the flawed Scriptures of their religion. Or, is there Scriptures, other than the Quran and the Baha'i writings, that Baha'is believe to be accurate?
You just asked me the questions but you already knew the answers.
I said "whatever scriptures that they had" because all religions have some kind of scriptures. I think that the Buddhist and Hindu scriptures were written by men who got the information by way of oral tradition. I really don’t know where the Jewish scriptures originated. I do not know how true these scriptures were since they were written by men, not by a Manifestation of God. On top of that some interpretations were wrong. Yes, we have to decide when to interpret literally and when to interpret allegorically. That is true of any scriptures,
As I have posted to you many times, the Qur’an and the Baha'i writings are the only authentic scriptures so they are the only ones I believe are accurate. The statements on official Baha’i positions are in this website:
The Bible: Extracts on the Old and New Testaments
I don't see it. What did Krishna and his teachings have to do with people outside of India? Then was that abrogated by the Bible? Now, if true, I can see how and why the Baha'i teachings would abrogate the teachings of all the other religions. It is the first that could have an effect the whole world. But do you really think all the other religions are going to go away?
I was not saying that God wanted the previous religions to cease to exist whenever a new religion was revealed. I was only saying that from God’s perspective, when God sends a new Messenger God expects people to recognize Him and follow his teachings and laws. However, that did not apply before the Revelation of Baha’u’llah because before that Messengers only came to certain parts of the world and other people in the world did not even know about Him.
Christianity and Islam were the first universalizing religions, ones that see their religion as applicable to everyone. But even though Muhammad came after Jesus that does not mean that God expected Christians to recognize Muhammad and become Muslims back when Muhammad came. The theology of progressive revelation had not even been revealed yet, so probably God intended for all those separate religions to exist until He sent Baha’u’llah to unite religions.
So now that everyone has access to the message of Baha’u’llah that are able to know that they should recognize all the religions that preceded their religion and the ones that came later rather than clinging to their own religion for dear life, as if God is trying to take something away from them. Nobody is trying to rip their precious religion from their arms just because there is a new religion, but Christians just have to be the only way and Jews also believe they are the only true religion. To their credit, at least Muslim recognize Judaism and Christianity as true religions and to my knowledge Buddhism and Hinduism do not even think in terms of being ‘the only true religion.’
And speaking of abrogating... In our generation we saw how Eastern religions spread in the U.S. They weren't dead and gone. They brought teachings and spiritual practices that weren't all that known in the West. And will the Baha'i Faith replace those meditation techniques and spiritual practices with something better?
Abrogation is separate from whether religions continue to exist and spread, or even whether they have beneficial things to offer. When a dispensation is abrogated by a new revelation from God, God is ordering the affairs of the world through the teachings and laws that are revealed by the new Messenger. Although I know that dispensations existed in the past I do not know if they were abrogated by the next dispensation. All I know is what Shoghi Effendi wrote,
“the Revelation identified with Bahá’u’lláh abrogates unconditionally all the Dispensations gone before it.” God Passes By, p. 100
I think what it does replace is the possible, and probable, "superstitious" beliefs of old religions. Like angels, demons, God/men etc. but it replaces them with an invisible, unknowable, unprovable God. and then "manifestations" who are the only ones that can communicate directly with that God. So great... if it's true. But, if it's not true then it just a man saying God told him such and such and we all should just do it, because he said so. Anyway, again thanks for hanging in there. At least some of the other Baha'is pop in once in a while.
That is true what you said about what replaces what and also that it is great
if it is true. It all hinges on whether Baha’u’llah was who He claimed to be in which case the Baha’i Faith is true, but obviously the converse also applies. It is true or false, I have been saying that since I came to my first forum eight years ago.
Thanks for bringing some things to my attention by your careful analytical thinking, because sometimes I get caught up in a certain way of thinking without considering all the variables. I try to simplify it to make in understandable but it is not always that simple.