• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

British People: Monarch or No?

Brits: do you support the Monarchy?


  • Total voters
    14

Kirran

Premium Member
Nope.

This is what makes Britain:

_89511.jpeg

Are you saying that I'm not British because I'm vegetarian?
 

Kirran

Premium Member
Fish and chips are a fine example of traditional British cuisine, being derived from the combination of the fried fish brought to the British Isles by Spanish Jews in the 1600s with the fried product of a South American indigenous staple crop brought to the UK by, well, other Spanish people at around the same time.

I'm a vegetarian too, bro. But come on, no-one does 'fish fried in the Jewish style with chips' quite like we do.

You beat me to it r.e. Jewish-style-frying. Why didn't I know you were vegetarian, that's odd. Kudos. Wait, so does this mean neither of us are British? Shall we start a new country?
 

Toten

Member
Why do you think we should maintain unity if lots of people don't want it? Don't get me wrong, I am no nationalist, but if I must choose between British nationalism and Scottish/Welsh/English/Irish nationalism, I'll tend to go with the latter.

I don't think people should be forced to do anything of course. But it's still part of British history and culture. It's part of their identity as a people. I don't mind Scottish/Welsh/Irish nationalists wanting to be independent, since they were originally their own sovereign kingdoms, but for people of England it's a symbol of their heritage and how far they've come as a people since the Normans came and founded the Kingdom.
 

Rival

Diex Aie
Staff member
Premium Member
Historical, cultural, political, social, and traditional value. As well as, like I've said, being a symbol of British identity.
But it isn't; there are many republican Brits who want the Monarch gone. So it's anything but a British identity symbol, since many Brits evidently don't identify with it.
 

Kirran

Premium Member
I don't think people should be forced to do anything of course. But it's still part of British history and culture. It's part of their identity as a people. I don't mind Scottish/Welsh/Irish nationalists wanting to be independent, since they were originally their own sovereign kingdoms, but for people of England it's a symbol of their heritage and how far they've come as a people since the Normans came and founded the Kingdom.

I'm from Wales, but I don't support Welsh independence to be honest. The kingdom was around long before the Normans! Actually William the Conqueror was able to invade due to an ongoing succession struggle to which he was a contender, along with two other lads.

How is the monarchy, the one thing that hasn't changed since 1066, standing up for how far we've come?

Not to mention the whole undemocratic thing. Maybe democracy isn't a British thing?

Nope, mushy peas and mint sauce is a known dish here oop north.

I have lived in the North for three years - have I been living a sheltered life? Or is this a Yorkshireism? If so, I must say that I am an ardent supporter of independence for Yorkshire. And then we'll shut down the border so there's no contact with the outside world.
 

lewisnotmiller

Grand Hat
Staff member
Premium Member
Should have known an uncouth colonial would be the one to utter such blasphemy.

Yep. It's kinda redundant to put 'uncouth' and 'colonial' in the same sentence though. They mean the same thing! ;)

Full disclosure time, my paternal grandfather hailed from the Midlands. Never quite lost his accent, even after living here for almost 60 years.
 

Rival

Diex Aie
Staff member
Premium Member
I have lived in the North for three years - have I been living a sheltered life? Or is this a Yorkshireism? If so, I must say that I am an ardent supporter of independence for Yorkshire. And then we'll shut down the border so there's no contact with the outside world.

It is quite a dated thing but yes; at carnivals etc. mushy peas were served in like a polystyrene cup with mint sauce as a warm snack, sort of like how people eat a cone of chips today.
 

Kirran

Premium Member
Yep. It's kinda redundant to put 'uncouth' and 'colonial' in the same sentence though. They mean the same thing! ;)

Full disclosure time, my paternal grandfather hailed from the Midlands. Never quite lost his accent, even after living here for almost 60 years.

Haha!

My paternal grandfather was from Chile! He never quite lost his accent either.

It is quite a dated thing but yes; at carnivals etc. mushy peas were served in like a polystyrene cup with mint sauce as a warm snack, sort of like how people eat a cone of chips today.

Hmm, interesting. I guess I shouldn't knock it if I haven't tried it. Mail order me some next time you see it being sold.
 

lewisnotmiller

Grand Hat
Staff member
Premium Member
It is quite a dated thing but yes; at carnivals etc. mushy peas were served in like a polystyrene cup with mint sauce as a warm snack, sort of like how people eat a cone of chips today.

Of course, over here we take old Brit traditions and further mangle them.
I give you, the pie floater...

DSC04125.JPG

Weird South Australian thing which you don't see around too much any more.
Mushy peas, or a pea soup with mint, with a good old pie dropped in the middle.
 

Kirran

Premium Member
Of course, over here we take old Brit traditions and further mangle them.
I give you, the pie floater...

DSC04125.JPG

Weird South Australian thing which you don't see around too much any more.
Mushy peas, or a pea soup with mint, with a good old pie dropped in the middle.

You people are weird.

Is it nice?
 

lewisnotmiller

Grand Hat
Staff member
Premium Member
You people are weird.

Is it nice?

Doubt I could find one anywhere in my state. I tried one once just because they were common in Adelaide, and it was kinda a 'When in Rome' thing. I mean, they weren't bad or anything, I just didn't see the point really.
 
Top