• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Does this sounds Good to you ? or Bad ?

HonestJoe

HonestJoe

Well-Known Member
chinu said:
Suppose this whole universe wouldn't have existed at all. Neither me, nor you, or RF, or countries, or earth, or stars, or skies, everything.

Does this sounds Good to you ? or Bad ?
Click to expand...
Neither. If nothing existed, good and bad wouldn't exist as concepts either. There would be nothing to be good or bad. It's like asking how "no food" tastes.
 
stvdv

stvdv

Veteran Member
ChristineM said:
@stvdv a word of reassurance please
Click to expand...
Oh, sorry for the confusion. I can see now, after rereading it, that it could be interpreted as a bit morbid. But I just tried to make sense of below
Suppose this whole universe wouldn't have existed at all. Neither me, nor you, or RF, or countries, or earth, or stars, or skies, everything.
Does this sounds Good to you ? or Bad ?
Click to expand...
Above is a strange question to ask us, how we would feel if we would never have existed, isn't it. Probably the reason that I answered strange too.

Hence I replied "I can only say how I feel in this moment, NOW"

I had a great life, and I am okay if I would die NOW (meaning I have no regrets or plans I missed out on).
But I am not going to die yet (Deo Volente)

Sai Baba told me, that I can only die if He wants. And He told me that I can easily get 70 years with a particular problem I have and was worried about. So the next 14 years, I probably won't die (unless other problems pop up:D). Keep that in mind, in case I make another strange reply.:D

@ChristineM
Did you really think, that I create 2 thread in the evening, knowing that I would die a few minutes or even hours later:).
That does not make sense, does it? But sorry for the confusion.
 
Last edited:
P

Ponder This

Well-Known Member
chinu said:
Suppose this whole universe wouldn't have existed at all. Neither me, nor you, or RF, or countries, or earth, or stars, or skies, everything.

Does this sounds Good to you ? or Bad ?
Click to expand...

Maybe only things which exist can be good or bad and things which don't exist aren't anything at all.

The whole universe taken altogether is good.
The absence of a universe isn't anything.

Which is to say, just because something is good doesn't mean that it's absence is bad.
 
chinu

chinu

chinu
ADigitalArtist said:
If it had never existed I wouldn't have been around to feel anything about it. It's a non-issue.
Click to expand...
Friend, its like asking, how do you feel AFTER something is done ?
For example: you buy a new home and went into that new home AFTER selling your old home. Was that a smart decision of yours, or NOT. Because this decision is based on many AFTERWARDS things which you observe after moving into your new home.
 
chinu

chinu

chinu
ChristineM said:
Doesn't make any difference, if it didn't exist who would know?
Click to expand...
Its like asking, how do you feel AFTER something is done ?
For example: you buy a new home and went into that new home AFTER selling your old home. Was that a smart decision of yours, or NOT. Because this decision is based on many AFTERWARDS things which you observe after moving into your new home.
 
chinu

chinu

chinu
SalixIncendium said:
Neither. How would it make sense that the human concepts of good and bad would exist in the absence of human existence?
Click to expand...
Now that you have already know. Its like asking, how do you feel AFTER something is done ?
For example: you buy a new home and went into that new home AFTER selling your old home. Was that a smart decision of yours, or NOT. Because this decision is based on many AFTERWARDS things which you observe after moving into your new home.
 
chinu

chinu

chinu
robocop (actually) said:
Literally not enough information.
Click to expand...
Friend, its like asking, how do you feel AFTER something is done ?
For example: you buy a new home and went into that new home AFTER selling your old home. Was that a smart decision of yours, or NOT. Because this decision is based on many AFTERWARDS things which you observe after moving into your new home.
 
MNoBody

MNoBody

Well-Known Member
chinu said:
Suppose this whole universe wouldn't have existed at all. Neither me, nor you, or RF, or countries, or earth, or stars, or skies, everything.

Does this sounds Good to you ? or Bad ?
Click to expand...
given that this whole frame of existence is depicted in the 'christian' cosmology as being a place of exile, wouldn't you be delighted to get sprung from the existential prison, the land of banishment, and have the prodigal's return?
why so concerned for what others think about such simple matters?
 
R

rational experiences

Veteran Member
chinu said:
Its like asking, how do you feel AFTER something is done ?
For example: you buy a new home and went into that new home AFTER selling your old home. Was that a smart decision of yours, or NOT. Because this decision is based on many AFTERWARDS things which you observe after moving into your new home.
Click to expand...

After having this event forced upon my life, I did not want to move from my current living house, and it involves a male thesis about my female life and self sanctity in my life as a victim and experience about how occult science is a liar.

Science of the invention is a liar, a manipulator a male group who took natural substances and alchemised them as a Satanic act, as taught by their brother the medical healer science psyche. Told them that it was Satanism, knew that a hot dense state/melt is Satanism.

Told him and taught him why God the entity planet O one and first was a holy body of its own spirits (gases) and to never change it. For he experienced after the fact of his group brother's choices, which he did not control, the group experience, the group control, the group making choices for all of natural one holy selves.

For each and every body living on Planet Earth is natural is one owned defined self presence and so the teachings one said everything is holy and natural and a self.

Even the body of Earth was holy by that defined reasoning and you were "quoted" taught to not be unreasonable if you wanted to own a machine, then it needed to be totally supportive of natural life and not used to attack us.

Which you brothers in groups denied and all own conditions in life today about our destruction. As basic and simple a teaching as it is.

I might be forced to live and change my house, by conditions of what I currently own, how I feel in that house as I live owning it...to something far less than what I deserve. What does that comparison have to have on a forum, unless it owns some male identification to my life as a science known victim?
 
chinu

chinu

chinu
QuestioningMind said:
My existence is a requirement for me determine if something is good or bad. But in your scenario I don't exist, so it becomes a meaningless question.
Click to expand...
I tried a lot to find you in that scenery/picture click. Perhaps, you was missing because you wasn't interested to come in ?

Anyways, thank you, may be another time :)
 
chinu

chinu

chinu
HonestJoe said:
Neither. If nothing existed, good and bad wouldn't exist as concepts either. There would be nothing to be good or bad. It's like asking how "no food" tastes.
Click to expand...
Its like asking.. what if there would have been NO-HUNGER exist at all.

Keep your delicious ice cream back in your fridge and save little for me too, we will sit and eat together, afterwards :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top