• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Ethics of creating your own religion

Unveiled Artist

Veteran Member
Religion to me is how you practice your faith. So, if I were a Christian, Id find ways to express Christs message to others both in word and in deed. Likewise, if I were Wiccan Id find ways I can physically helped nature and ways to let the Goddess and God know you love Her.​

With that said, we all have religion. We all decide on what we want to focus on in life we try to put them in action, say go to school, have a family, to devotional callings to be a priest, or work overseas for the homeless.

In this thread, Im focusing on how we practice our faiths.
--
Can we make up our own religion?

By the definition I gave above, one might say yes. We (or God, perhaps) decide our own lives and do what we want to do in it.

My point....I feel there is are issues when creating your own religion. The problem is based on two things:

Tradition (what has been laid down before cannot or shouldnt be changed)

The rules of the game. (This is how the game plan is set. Cant change the rules to fit your own needs) Of that be the case, everyone can "pass-go"

--

Having a non traditional faith is fine. However, I see that we become eclectic when we go outside traditional values.

This is my personal opinion. I feel eclecticism puts more emphasis on believes as abstract philosophies. For example, if someone is a Christian Wiccan, they could say "I believe the love that Christ has and I believe in Mother nature because she takes care of us". Yet, Christ did not promote mixed beliefs. He did not promote that you can worship Mother Earth and still find goodness in Christ and Not believe in His Father.

Likewise with Buddhism (Nichiren and Zen) and Muslim. While the Buddha did not have a strict code for layman as he did monks, he also said not to look outside yourself for answers. So you cant look outside to God to find the Buddha nature in you. The Buddha taught the opposite. So how can you mix the two?

--
Making up a faith upsets the "rules of the game." I see many seekers still wondering because they have abstract concepts to pull from and overlaps in all faiths....love, charity, finding oneself, humbleness, and so forth.

However, I see so many question because the "religion" cannot mix as concepts can. How do you geneflex to thr Eucharist one day and bow to the Buddha the next? In my opinion, it is unethical to make up your own rules so you can "get out of jail free" card. In Christianity, Christ gives you the card. In Buddhism, you have to be comfortable where you at to help others get out first. How can they both match, religious wise not concept?

I find when we mix religions (practices) we walk on egg shells. I feel to be a spiritual person you must donso in Action. If your actions, or religion, are not the same in practice, how do you justify it by concept.

Yes, you can create your own religion. I just find tradition and sticking to the rules helpful in spiritual growth.
 

suncowiam

Well-Known Member
Why do people need to make their own religions when so many pick and choose their religions. Its easy. I will translate this verse to mean this then that verse to be that... I can say certain sections are poetic then claim other sections are literal. Or I just make assumptions on what god thinks and proclaim to know the will of god. No need to make a new religion.
 

Unveiled Artist

Veteran Member
The way I see it, making our own religions is ethically superior to the alternative. It means taking full responsibility.

Maybe I am just not understanding what the problem would be?

It does take a lot of responsibility. I havnt had bad experiences with non eclectic faiths. I honestly feel if the connection between other believers and community faith helps a lot. I think itw good to have a foundation before picking and choosing.
 

arthra

Baha'i
"Can we make up our own religion?"

I think that people are free to investigate and explore religions and maybe in that process develop what could be considered making up a religion...

but the problem I see with that is you make up your own standards over time and revise them.. to me you end up not having many viable ethical positions in the long run.

I know several people who developed their own religion or church for tax purposes... Their home is their church.. I think when "religion" gets to be a tax dodge... there's not much to it. I had a cousin that was married by a fellow with a universal life church ministry .. "get ordained click here".. while it's "legal" it doesn't really stand for much.
 

Kuzcotopia

If you can read this, you are as lucky as I am.
People are very much making up their religion even when they profess to follow a particular religion.

Agreed. I think that if you believe in something supernatural, then you have little to go on but your intuition. I think there are as many interpretations of belief as there are believers.

To the OP, I'd say that I would definitely make up my own religion if I felt the need. I hold a certain aesthetic appreciation of the natural world, but it falls just short of reverence. If I ever crossed that line with a religious experience, I'd have to add some elements of faith to the equation to explain the source of that reverence.
 

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
Someone created all religions up to this point.​

Why not?

Different strokes for different folks.
 

JFish123

Active Member
Creating your own religion and your own God... I believe it was the prophet Isaiah who once told the story of a man who fathered wood for a fire to cook his meal. And after his meal was done, he took the remaining wood and carved an idol with it and bowed down before it, thanking it for the meal. All over the bible calls this foolish to pray to a God you yourself made.
 

tiki

বরিশালের রাজকুমারী
If I believe is respects god to put mud on my feet its what I better do.
 

psychoslice

Veteran Member
The way I see it, making our own religions is ethically superior to the alternative. It means taking full responsibility.

Maybe I am just not understanding what the problem would be?
Yes that's how I see it also, just as there are many mistakes in religion, so it will also be with our own religion, but, it will be our own mistake, and it will be our job to rectify that mistake, this to me is maturing in spirit.
 

Quintessence

Consults with Trees
Staff member
Premium Member
People are very much making up their religion even when they profess to follow a particular religion.

Yup. Pretty much what I was going to say. Everybody follows a religion of one. Meaningfulness woven into our lives is necessarily focused on the loci of the self.
 

jeager106

Learning more about Jehovah.
Premium Member
Creating a religion wasn't an issue for Muhammud, Koresh, Jim Jones, or the Heavens Gate people.
Every "denomination" that broke away from the Catholic Chruch could be a new religion when compared
to the Catholic faith.
Create away and have fun.
 

psychoslice

Veteran Member
Creating a religion wasn't an issue for Muhammud, Koresh, Jim Jones, or the Heavens Gate people.
Every "denomination" that broke away from the Catholic Chruch could be a new religion when compared
to the Catholic faith.
Create away and have fun.
The Catholics also created their religion, there is a lot of stuff they do that isn't in the bible.
 

1137

Here until I storm off again
Premium Member
Your argument is a fallacy known as the appeal to tradition. Just because some religions are old or teach specific things does not make those things unchangeable. One reason might be that traditional religions are just plain wrong at times. Another may be the religion evolves as we evolve, and so we constantly should update it.
 

psychoslice

Veteran Member
Your argument is a fallacy known as the appeal to tradition. Just because some religions are old or teach specific things does not make those things unchangeable. One reason might be that traditional religions are just plain wrong at times. Another may be the religion evolves as we evolve, and so we constantly should update it.
Updating would be a good idea, in stead of living in the past and worshiping old worn out beliefs.
 

Baladas

An Págánach
Every religious person creates their own religion to some extent.

Traditions can be wonderful, but in my opinion they must be subject to critical examination.
 

Christina023

New Member
Every religious person creates their own religion to some extent.

Traditions can be wonderful, but in my opinion they must be subject to critical examination.

I agree with that point. I believe that religious person may take certain concepts from religion that he or she preffers the most and at the same time, there should be personal judgements about traditional dogmas and level of their acceptance.
 

Kuzcotopia

If you can read this, you are as lucky as I am.
I think that we also have to watch out for accepting things just because they are new. That's also a fallacy called the appeal to novelty.
 
Top