dybmh
ויהי מבדיל בין מים למים
Ah well if the OP is assuming a non creator type God (then my bad). In that case my only criticism would be that it is not physically visible like the Lady it is being compared to in my view.
I think the analogy is supposed to be: IF something beautiful appears and a skeptic assumes the worst of it THEN that skeptic is "weird". Based on the thread title, If there is a hidden assumption, perhaps it's the beauty of God. I think I mentioned it earlier. If God does not appear to someone as something beautiful, then the analogy changes.