Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
I was talking about the Goddess, not the princess.
"Lady of Dendera" and "Gold" or "Golden One" are common titles of Hathor.
The hymn you found there is beautiful, but it entirely centers on Sekhmet, who is arguably an alternate form of Hathor... but by many considered a different goddess
we sacrifice geese and oryxes for Her,
The hymn you found there is beautiful, but it entirely centers on Sekhmet, who is arguably an alternate form of Hathor... but by many considered a different goddess
How come in many religions they sacrifice animals, and are these sacrifices similar in many religions, such as sacrificing cattle and geese, to Sekhmet?
In the "Book of the Celestial Cow", it is clearly said that Sekhmet came into being when Hathor fell into a blood frenzy after killing rebellious humans. According to this text, Hathor transforms into Sekhmet.How was Sekhmet arguably and alternately from Hathor, and what caused people to consider Sekhmet a different goddess? What are the differences from Sekhmet and Hathor that they'd considered?
Your mind works in weird ways, my friend, but I appreciate your active and questioning brain.
So. Let me see
Sacrifice is a common way of creating a relationship with the divine in many cultures.
Animals, especially domesticated animals, have long been a valuable resource for humans and as such, they are also a high quality offering for the gods.
Egyptian offerings were often redistributed to the humans after being presented on an offering table, and not burned at all. In Greece and Rome, parts of the sacrificial animal were usually burned on the altar, while the meat was eaten by the humans. So there may be differences in the way a ceremony was conducted, but the general idea was fairly similar.
In the "Book of the Celestial Cow", it is clearly said that Sekhmet came into being when Hathor fell into a blood frenzy after killing rebellious humans. According to this text, Hathor transforms into Sekhmet.
However, in other texts and hymns no mention is made of this connection between the two, or Sekhmet may be seen as the wilder form of Bastet.
You need to understand that in Egyptian mythology, the limits between deities are not that clearly defined. They constantly transform into each other or get syncretized, or get split up in different forms and manifestations.
When for year 2024 goats are killed for sins of Israel, Yom Kippur 2024 Friday, October 11 Saturday, October 12, [10 Tishrei 5785]: which means goats run off of mountains—it's called Yom Kippur.
Each year this takes place and this year it's October 11 and October 12.
The 10th day of Tishrei, 5785 on the Jewish calendar is Yom Kippur, or the Day of Atonement
You need to understand that in Egyptian mythology, the limits between deities are not that clearly defined. They constantly transform into each other or get syncretized, or get split up in different forms and manifestations.
I am myself, not clear as to the philosophy behind animal or human sacrifice. One possibility is that this was just a social system to share the meat of the sacrificial animal but I think there may be a deeper psychic influence. In the Hindu system it is said that when an animal is sacrificed, the god take the soul and leave the body for the human beings. But how God would take a soul is beyond my comprehension, and I would very much like input from all the members on this point.Your mind works in weird ways, my friend, but I appreciate your active and questioning brain.
So. Let me see
Sacrifice is a common way of creating a relationship with the divine in many cultures.
Animals, especially domesticated animals, have long been a valuable resource for humans and as such, they are also a high quality offering for the gods.
Egyptian offerings were often redistributed to the humans after being presented on an offering table, and not burned at all. In Greece and Rome, parts of the sacrificial animal were usually burned on the altar, while the meat was eaten by the humans. So there may be differences in the way a ceremony was conducted, but the general idea was fairly similar.
In the "Book of the Celestial Cow", it is clearly said that Sekhmet came into being when Hathor fell into a blood frenzy after killing rebellious humans. According to this text, Hathor transforms into Sekhmet.
However, in other texts and hymns no mention is made of this connection between the two, or Sekhmet may be seen as the wilder form of Bastet.
You need to understand that in Egyptian mythology, the limits between deities are not that clearly defined. They constantly transform into each other or get syncretized, or get split up in different forms and manifestations.
Sacrifice is a common way of creating a relationship with the divine in many cultures.
Animals, especially domesticated animals, have long been a valuable resource for humans and as such, they are also a high quality offering for the gods.
Egyptian offerings were often redistributed to the humans after being presented on an offering table, and not burned at all. In Greece and Rome, parts of the sacrificial animal were usually burned on the altar, while the meat was eaten by the humans. So there may be differences in the way a ceremony was conducted, but the general idea was fairly similar.
All of them usually ate the animals. The Greek and Romans only burned head, bones and some intestines, while the main part of the meat was taken away for the humans to eat.@Tamino
At least people eat the animals, and you were claiming that Egyptian offerings were often redistributed to the humans, so that means that humans eat the animals.
So basically it's Greece and Rome who do the sacrificial and not the Egyptians. I learned that Jews sacrifice animals even to this day.
I am not familiar with Jewish festivals ... they also have different types of offering and I don't know what and how the celebrate in OctoberThe next time Jews will kill animals as a sacrifice is on October 11 and 12 of this year.
I hope the Jews will eat the goats after they sacrifice
Because you tend to focus on a single word or phrase and then you want to know all about it.I hope I did better this time asking
I still don't understand why you think my mind is weird, and I still want to know the details of why you think this.
I think that is the basic idea, yes: a sharing of precious food. Not just among humans, but also between humans and deities.I am myself, not clear as to the philosophy behind animal or human sacrifice. One possibility is that this was just a social system to share the meat of the sacrificial animal
I agree entirely.All of them usually ate the animals. The Greek and Romans only burned head, bones and some intestines, while the main part of the meat was taken away for the humans to eat.
A complete holocaust, or burning of the entire sacrifice, was rare.
@Tamino , I would like to know if there is a psychic interpretation to the sacrifice. It seems to me that the soul of the sacrificial animal or human continues to live after the sacrifice and somehow that soul provides some benefit to the gods. I am trying to understand what could be the possible relationship between the soul of the sacrificial animal and the gods? I think there is more to it than what I can understand.But it is extremely difficult to give any general explanations here... the theology behind different types of sacrifices can have a lot of nuance in different cultures. A closer look at a single culture would give you a better insight, I think.
Interesting question. Once again, the only context I know in depths is the ancient Egyptian case.@Tamino , I would like to know if there is a psychic interpretation to the sacrifice. It seems to me that the soul of the sacrificial animal or human continues to live after the sacrifice and somehow that soul provides some benefit to the gods. I am trying to understand what could be the possible relationship between the soul of the sacrificial animal and the gods? I think there is more to it than what I can understand.
I don't think sacrifice can be explained in physical terms. Where I live in the Himalayas, there was a case of a village chief wanting to make a canal to bring water. Local people tell me that the canal was made but water would not flow. Then the chief had a dream and in the dream the goddess told him to sacrifice his son and he sacrificed his young son maybe about eight years old and after the sacrifice the water began to flow. This is a story that is even today celebrated in my village. So, there has to be a psychic interpretation of sacrifice. I can understand the sacrifice being sacrificial animal being buried with the king to assist him in his afterlife. But the sacrifice without a burial has to be for a different purpose rather than just meat. And I am not able to fathom it. Therefore, my question.Interesting question. Once again, the only context I know in depths is the ancient Egyptian case.
Human sacrifice is known from two entirely different cases.
One, the killing (or suicide??) of people to be buried with the King or Queen in the Early Dynastic. Those lives were not sacrificed to a deity, they were killed so they could follow their ruler into eternity. According to current research, those people were of high solcial status - a royal court, rather than a bunch of servants.
Two, the murder of prisoners of war in the New Kingdom. This is an offering of Ma'at: the king, as the ruler, defeats foreigners who are seen as a manifestation of chaotic forces, and thus ritually establishes order and safety in his country - as is his sacred duty. Again, neither the souls nor the blood of those people is the offering, but the removal of their life and agency.
In the Egyptian context, the animal sacrifice is actually more interesting. There's an interesting interpretation being discussed in Egyptology (note that this is one of several interpretations... it's not fact, it's just one way to interprete the sources, but it's plausible). They say that the Egyptians, who did not see a natural difference between humans and animals, always felt guilty about taking an animal's life. So they felt the need to justify eating it.
There are parts in ritual where the sacrificial animal is equated to Seth - thus making it an agent of chaos, whose killing is justified to reestablish order (=Ma'at). It's the exactly same justification as with the prisoners of war above.
The other, far more boring, aspect of animal sacrifice is the simple sharing of food. In Egypt, sacrificial animals are never sacrificed on top of the altar or in the sanctum of the temple - the blood and death would be considered impure. Not the death or the blood or the soul constitute the offering, but the meat and nourishment taken from it.
This is a direct contradiction to Greek practice, where the animal is led up to the altar and being killed right there, and its blood collected to be an offering. However, the Greeks also have that aspect of feeling guilty about killing animals: An animal being offered had to be in perfect health, and had to walk up to the altar on its own. If the animal tried to get away or showed signs of fear and stress, that was considered a very bad omen. So the Greeks clung to the idea that the animal somehow consented to being sacrificed and eaten. This type of animal sacrifice as a communal meal was also practiced in Greece whenever someone decided to slaughter one of their domestic animals, I think they considered it the 'right way' to kill a pig or cow.
The Jewish offering practice also has interesting aspects to it. Consider the prohibition of consuming blood, as this was seen as the seat of the soul, the ruah, and belongs to God alone. And consider the stories in the bible... Abraham having a calf slaughtered when the Angels come to visit, the Father having an animal prepared to be eaten when his lost son returns... those stories are not a simple matter of having a barbeque. They stress the importance of those visits - one does not kill an animal for a small occasion. Only a big show of hospitality, honored guests and the sharing of precious resources justifies such a meal.
I think the feeling of guilt about killing does not make sense. Violence has is a very much a part of nature. The food cycle is entirely violent from amoeba to fish to humans and so forth. So, there is no guilt in killing for food. The land does not feel guilty not to humans about killing. I think there has to be a psychological explanation that I'm looking for.So if you look at the deep seated psychological meaning of animal sacrifice, I personally think that feeling guilt about the killing, and justifying that violence by making it a sacred act, is a big part of it in several cultures.
Because you tend to focus on a single word or phrase and then you want to know all about it.
That means that you jump from one topic to an entirely unrelated one all the time.
Your mind works in weird ways, my friend, but I appreciate your active and questioning brain.
I was talking about the Goddess, not the princess.
"Lady of Dendera" and "Gold" or "Golden One" are common titles of Hathor.
HatHor, the Golden One, Lady of Dendera ... and I totally didn't see that coming, I never liked Ancient Egypt all that much as a child. But then I travelled to Egypt and my soul never left again.
HatHor, the Golden One, Lady of Dendera ... and I totally didn't see that coming, I never liked Ancient Egypt all that much as a child. But then I travelled to Egypt and my soul never left again.
I was talking about the Goddess, not the princess.
"Lady of Dendera" and "Gold" or "Golden One" are common titles of Hathor.
HatHor, the Golden One, Lady of Dendera ... and I totally didn't see that coming, I never liked Ancient Egypt all that much as a child. But then I travelled to Egypt and my soul never left again.
Great questions.
Heavenly Rewards are Spiritual Rewards that are Eternal. My writings will not make sense to the Natural Mind. You are Interpreting the meaning of Eunuch in a Natural Way. A Seed has a Kernel and Shell. Your Interpretation is the Shell.
This Christian Gnostic cannot be offended, so have no concerns there. Yeshua/Jesus has the Ability of a Sacrificial Animal given to Elohim/God. Yeshua/Jesus Transcends the Beast Man.
The fact that Gnosticism is a modern world does not change the ground reality. The fact is that there is a spiritual version of the Hebrew, Christian and Islamic scriptures. In Hebrew the Gnosticism follows from the ten sefirot. In Christianity, Gnosticism is in Pistis Sophia. And in Islam it is in the Sufi traditions.
Your mind works in weird ways, my friend, but I appreciate your active and questioning brain.
Animal sacrifice was a part of the evolving nature of human religious ritual going back to the Neolithic. Human rituals and beliefs began as forms of animism, and evolved to anthropomorphic polytheism, human and reincarnated Gods. The cultures evolved to Revelation anthropomorphic Monotheism and in the Orient to abstract spiritualism. Beliefs in some religions evolved into non-anthropomorphic unknowable God as in Islam and the Baha'i Faith. There is rise of atheism and agnosticism in recent history.I am myself, not clear as to the philosophy behind animal or human sacrifice. One possibility is that this was just a social system to share the meat of the sacrificial animal but I think there may be a deeper psychic influence. In the Hindu system it is said that when an animal is sacrificed, the god take the soul and leave the body for the human beings. But how God would take a soul is beyond my comprehension, and I would very much like input from all the members on this point.
I do not find an answer to my question as to what is the science behind animal or human sacrifice. I think we can let it rest here. Thanks for your patience.Animal sacrifice was a part of the evolving nature of human religious ritual going back to the Neolithic. Human rituals and beliefs began as forms of animism, and evolved to anthropomorphic polytheism, human and reincarnated Gods. The cultures evolved to Revelation anthropomorphic Monotheism and in the Orient to abstract spiritualism. Beliefs in some religions evolved into non-anthropomorphic unknowable God as in Islam and the Baha'i Faith. There is rise of atheism and agnosticism in recent history.
We spiritual evolve whether Gods exist or not.
It is not as much anthropological science with an explanation, but simply the evolution of all the cultures of the world over time.I do not find an answer to my question as to what is the science behind animal or human sacrifice. I think we can let it rest here. Thanks for your patience.
I Am Christian Gnostic. Yeshua Messiah/Jesus Christ is the Original Christian Gnostic indicated by Yeshua's/Jesus's Non-Slaughter of Animals. The Christian Gnosticism that Elohim/God has shown me is the Original Teaching of Yeshua/Jesus that has Differences from Traditional Christian Gnosticism.Lately I learned more about John the Baptist. Another past person.
I don't mind learning past people, I love psychoanalyzing
Oh @Elihoenai is gnostic. @Bharat Jhunjhunwala many times you share that you read about Sophia
I think there is something to the statement that the gods take the soul and the humans take the meat. So, when a living animal or human being is sacrificed, the body is obviously taken by the human beings, but how the soul is taken by the gods. This I do not understand. If you have any thoughts, please do share. Thank you.It is not as much anthropological science with an explanation, but simply the evolution of all the cultures of the world over time.
There is some basis in the human anthropological nature to "give up something in hopes to insure the prosperity of the whole."