• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

I Demand a MULTI-ETHNIC / CULTURE DIR

Sha'irullah

رسول الآلهة
It has come to me that a DIR should be made in the general "Everything but the kitchen sink" section for ethnicity and culture.
Because religion is so deeply rooted in culture, nationality and ethnic backgrounds it seems logical to me that such a sub-forum should be made for this.
 

Avi1001

reform Jew humanist liberal feminist entrepreneur
Great idea, Sha...I am totally on board...only I think we should go all they way....and create a Black DIR !!!....btw...I consider myself a Black Jew...in the same sense that Bill Clinton considers himself....the first Black President !!!
 

Sha'irullah

رسول الآلهة
Great idea, Sha...I am totally on board...only I think we should go all they way....and create a Black DIR !!!

Why not just have it subdivided? Have one for general area of ethnic backgrounds. The usual divisions are European, African and Asian.
 

Avi1001

reform Jew humanist liberal feminist entrepreneur
Why not just have it subdivided? Have one for general area of ethnic backgrounds. The usual divisions are European, African and Asian.
You the boss, Sha....it's your DIR...I'm just here to root for you...and fight the good fight...:)
 
Last edited:

Avi1001

reform Jew humanist liberal feminist entrepreneur
Don't be afraid...Sha...you can win this....just fight the good fight ...:)
 

melk

christian open minded
Sha, Avi,
I don't think we need a specific dir for defending peace or multiculturalism or whatsoerver, that would exclude the people that desagree with those banners.
If we get out of the world, it won't change. We must fight the good fight, with everybody in, so that not the racist or the bigoted or the hater will be eliminated, but racism, hatred and bigotry will end.
 

ShivaFan

Satyameva Jayate
Premium Member
I don't understand what the focus of this ethnicity and culture DIR would be because some are already talking about race.

In most cases, there is zero relation between race and a particular religion, this is pretty much true for all the "major religions", they include and span all races.

As far as "culture" and race, cultures vary dramatically within a single "race", for example I interact directly with African nations such as Angola, Nigeria, or South Africa on almost a bi-weekly basis. Even considering race, I do not see them even all as the same race, the differences are as distinct between a Cabinda based African and North-Eastern Nigerian as are different as a Korean is different than a Han Chinese. They don't even look the same, even skin pigmentation is different. And their cultures vary dramatically, almost no resemblance, and within Angola there are four different cultures. I hear about "rap hiphop culture" in Oakland CA, many are "black" but that "culture" has nothing to do with "black Soweto culture".

In India, Panjabi culture is different from Tamil culture, so on and so forth. India has 24 official languages and vastly different cultures in the mix. What would you call the "India ethnicity and culture" sub DIR? "Asian"? What a joke - so members of my own family would use the same subforum as, oh, the Chinese?

hmmm... back to race, DNA research proves practically no one, zero, is any "pure race"... What race is my daughter? She has many races in her DNA.

Now if it is a new DIR where someone can talk about their regional (or diaspora) "culture", that might make sense. One dumping ground for all and no sub-sections such as "black" (what?) or "Asian", no.

So one place where ... oh, I don't know... someone can post something like "Hi, my name is Heidi! Here is some cultural info on my passion for German steins (stoneware Steingut) from my home near the German-Swiss border!" ... or someone posting about the culture of bread in their region of India, whatever ... but we sort of already have that now in various forums, yes?

I see a lot of "Euro" types in S.F. really into Anime Culture. They are "white", but Anime and Manga of Japan is their "culture". Where would they post to tell us about their culture? Asian? But the SF Anime "white" gals use different koolaid colors in their hair than in Japan, and they have a slight punk-goth fusion element with black lipstick and such.

eeeehhhh ... this isn't going to work, in fact it might start trouble already.
 

Draka

Wonder Woman
At first I was caught by the word "Demand". I think things always go over better when suggested or asked for, not demanded. Also, others here have a point, the whole forum is multi-cultural anyway. I thought one of the main ideas of this forum was to bring people together to discuss religion and learn from each other.
 
Last edited:

oldbadger

Skanky Old Mongrel!
It has come to me that a DIR should be made in the general "Everything but the kitchen sink" section for ethnicity and culture.
Because religion is so deeply rooted in culture, nationality and ethnic backgrounds it seems logical to me that such a sub-forum should be made for this.

How the DIR sections expand!
If you are seeking a DIR then you are seeking to exclude people from various debates and discussions. Is this what you want..... segregation of nationalities and ethnic backgrounds?

Sounds to me as if we are going the wrong way with DIRs! :)
 

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Open a multi ethnic/multi cultural DIR and you're going to end up with all sorts of riff-raff and cynical curmudgeons (myself?) posting all sorts of rude and disturbing invective. Are we really ready for that?
rolleyes.gif


If we must indulge in such liberal madness I'd ask that the DIR be closed at least to the lesser apes -- gibbons and their shiftless, irresponsible ilk. No good could come from that...
 
Top