• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

"It's Me, Judy. Let's Talk About Book Bans"

Rachel Rugelach

Shalom, y'all.
Staff member
Banned Books Week (October 1st - 7th) is an annual event that celebrates the freedom to read and focuses on efforts across the country to remove or restrict access to books.

Below is a special message from author Judy Blume, released today in support of Banned Books Week, and posted here in its entirety with the author's permission to spread the word:

"When I was a kid, my parents let me read whatever I wanted, whether I'd found the book on our bookshelves at home, in the public library, or at the local bookstore. As readers themselves, they knew what was important: I was reading. At the time, I had no idea what a gift that was, but I do now—and that is why I am writing to you today at the start of Banned Books Week.

"The freedom to read is under attack in this country. It sounds like I'm being overdramatic, and I wish I was, but the numbers don't lie. Last year the American Library Association, which has been tracking book bans for over 20 years, reported the highest number of bans and challenges since they started keeping records.

"Preliminary data for this year shows we are once again on track for a record-breaking year for bans and challenges, and that the coordinated censorship efforts we've seen on school libraries are now increasingly targeting public libraries.

"Unfortunately, censorship is not a new issue—I've faced book bans and challenges myself for years, including for Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. But without a doubt, the problem has gotten worse. I've also watched in anger as the book banners of today have expanded their efforts while increasingly setting their sights on silencing underrepresented voices—particularly LGBTQ+ people and people of color—whose books are the most frequent targets of censorship.

"This Banned Books Week, I am proud to stand with The New York Public Library as it launches its new Books for All campaign championing the freedom to read. This national initiative is in partnership with the American Library Association and will last throughout the whole school year. Books for All can help you learn about and discuss some of the books that are being banned or challenged and ways to take action.

"One of the easiest ways to take action? Read one of the many delightful books that the banners are trying to censor. As part of Books for All, the Library is offering unlimited access to books that have been the subject of bans or challenges[/url], via its free e-reader app SimplyE, no library card required. The books are part of the Library's new Teen Banned Book Club, in recognition that many of the titles the banners are zeroing in on are for young people. The first featured title—the young adult fantasy novel Each of Us a Desert by Mark Oshiro—is available today. More information about how to download the book and other NYPL offerings can be found below.

"Another way to take action? Support your local library, use your local library, and say 'thank you' to your local librarian. Public libraries encourage the free and open exchange of ideas for everyone. Librarians introduce us to books that show we are not alone—and books that show ways of life we couldn't imagine. For our democracy, we need both.

"Please join me in supporting libraries and standing up for the freedom to read this Banned Books Week and all year long."

Judy Blume
Author


Here is the link for the New York Public Library's instructions on How to Read the Latest Teen Banned Book Club Title on SimplyE, as mentioned by Judy in her message above. It is FREE, no library card required, but participants must register as being at least 13 years of age.

 

SalixIncendium

अहं ब्रह्मास्मि
Staff member
Premium Member
I've given away all of my physical library, and my entire library is now on Kindle.

Reading the OP led me to do some investigating as to whether or not Amazon is within its rights to yank purchased e-books from one's library.

From what I understand, Amazon has the ability to delete books remotely, and you have no rights to them, as you don't own them.

It doesn't appear downloading them helps either, because opening the files requires Amazon's proprietary applications.

I'm currently regretting my decision to buy e-books in lieu of paper copies. And I was thinking I was helping the environment. :confused:
 

SalixIncendium

अहं ब्रह्मास्मि
Staff member
Premium Member
Do you anticipate Amazon doing so?
I've been working in partnership with Amazon for the last three years, and I've seen a lot of stupid from them. If a book is banned, or for whatever reason, legislature prevents further sale of a title, I have no doubt Amazon would remove the book from the library.
 

Rachel Rugelach

Shalom, y'all.
Staff member
I've given away all of my physical library, and my entire library is now on Kindle.

Reading the OP led me to do some investigating as to whether or not Amazon is within its rights to yank purchased e-books from one's library.

From what I understand, Amazon has the ability to delete books remotely, and you have no rights to them, as you don't own them.

It doesn't appear download them helps either, because opening the files requires Amazon's proprietary applications.

I'm currently regretting my decision to buy e-books in lieu of paper copies. And I was thinking I was helping the environment. :confused:

I believe that most public libraries nowadays provide e-books for loan, which you can download directly to your device. Granted, the books will return themselves when the loan period has expired -- but the plus side is that you'll never pay a fine on an overdue book again. You can also renew books that you're not yet done with. Check with your own public library to find out more.

I'm not overly worried about Amazon yanking books that I've paid for. The only time I've ever experienced Amazon doing something similar, was when Amazon lost its rights to certain video productions. In which case, it was the licensing corporation for the video that was chiefly responsible.

I'd really worry more about a hostile EMP attack on our nation rendering all our electronic devices useless. In which case, we'd be in the midst of World War III and have a lot of other concerns -- chiefly survival. Some public libraries do have contingency plans for such scenarios. New York Public Library has a vast underground bunker (beneath Bryant Park) where several million volumes are stored.
 

McBell

Unbound
I've given away all of my physical library, and my entire library is now on Kindle.

Reading the OP led me to do some investigating as to whether or not Amazon is within its rights to yank purchased e-books from one's library.

From what I understand, Amazon has the ability to delete books remotely, and you have no rights to them, as you don't own them.

It doesn't appear downloading them helps either, because opening the files requires Amazon's proprietary applications.

I'm currently regretting my decision to buy e-books in lieu of paper copies. And I was thinking I was helping the environment. :confused:
I actually love my Kindle.
But it can only hold about a fourth of the ebooks I have....

I solve this by having them copied to my pc (and to a usb drive in the safe).

Which means that even if Amazon wants to delete some books, they can not delete them from my USB drive in the safe,

OASN:
I use Calibre to convert all my books into epub format so they are more compatible with other devices, primarily my phone be cause the Kindle app sucks.
 

SomeRandom

Still learning to be wise
Staff member
Premium Member
I love banned books week.
Lol
I try to read as many banned books as I can
And tell my nieces/nephews that there are books that the “man” hates. So they end up reading a little bit more lol
 

fantome profane

Anti-Woke = Anti-Justice
Premium Member
From what I understand, Amazon has the ability to delete books remotely, and you have no rights to them, as you don't own them.
That is a scary idea, I have so many kindle and audible books and I keep buying more.


But why would Amazon do this? It would be a very quick way to **** off a lot of customers. What would be in it for them?
 

SalixIncendium

अहं ब्रह्मास्मि
Staff member
Premium Member
I actually love my Kindle.
But it can only hold about a fourth of the ebooks I have....
I haven't had an actual Kindle for years. I read on my iPad Mini and my Mac.
I solve this by having them copied to my pc (and to a usb drive in the safe).

Which means that even if Amazon wants to delete some books, they can not delete them from my USB drive in the safe,

OASN:
I use Calibre to convert all my books into epub format so they are more compatible with other devices, primarily my phone be cause the Kindle app sucks.
Does Calibre open AZW, AZW3 (KF8), and KFX file formats?
 

SalixIncendium

अहं ब्रह्मास्मि
Staff member
Premium Member
That is a scary idea, I have so many kindle and audible books and I keep buying more.


But why would Amazon do this? It would be a very quick way to **** off a lot of customers. What would be in it for them?
Changes in legislation or in the interest of being politically correct, perhaps.
 

Rachel Rugelach

Shalom, y'all.
Staff member
That is a scary idea, I have so many kindle and audible books and I keep buying more.


But why would Amazon do this? It would be a very quick way to **** off a lot of customers. What would be in it for them?

In addition to what @SalixIncendium has already posted, more answers to the question as to whether Amazon can delete your purchased Kindle books can be found at this Quora discussion:


Basically, you don't actually own the e-books that you purchase for your Kindle from Amazon (or for your Nook from Barnes & Noble, or for your Kobo eReader from Rakuten Kobo). What you're really paying for is a license to keep and access the electronic file that contains your e-book.

In fact, none of these book-sellers own the e-books, either -- they have only purchased the right from the publisher to digitize the content of a book. There are licensing agreements and Digital Rights Management Law (all favoring the original publishing entity) that have a greater say about the status of their e-books.

@McBell, one person taking part in the Quora discussion mentioned having transferred all his Kindle books to a Calibre folder on his computer, same as you did. That sounds like a wise move and I'm going to do it with my own e-books. Thanks for that helpful information you provided! In the past, I've also downloaded a lot of free Google books to my computer -- mostly reference books of historical interest which are now old enough to be in the public domain.

I suppose the moral of the story is this: Not only must we fight for the right to read by supporting Banned Books Week, it is also incumbent upon us all to find ways to preserve the books we enjoy -- even if that means finding creative ways to thwart publishers who may or may not act on their own rights to have selected e-books deleted from our electronic devices.

Public libraries are, by their very nature, subversive organizations (and rightfully proud of it). I'll leave y'all with some great quotes about libraries, starting with my favorite:

"Our whole American way of life is a great war of ideas, and librarians are the arms dealers selling weapons to both sides." -- James Quinn, Reference Librarian, Gonzaga University School of Law

"A truly great library contains something in it to offend everyone." -- Jo Godwin, editor of Wilson Library Bulletin

"If you want to get laid, go to college. If you want an education, go to the library." -- Frank Zappa, musical genius and free-form improvisationist

"Libraries are brothels for the mind. Which means that librarians are the madams, greeting punters, understanding their strange tastes and needs, and pimping their books." -- Guy Browning, humorist and film director.

Cheers!
-- Madam Rachel
 

McBell

Unbound
I haven't had an actual Kindle for years. I read on my iPad Mini and my Mac.

Does Calibre open AZW, AZW3 (KF8), and KFX file formats?
I have converted AWZ and AWZ3 files to epub, I am unsure about the KFX.

I do not recognize the KFX.
So I have either not run across it, or did not pay enough attention to notice it if I did.

Calibre is free to download and use.
It allows you edit the ebook itself, edit the metadata, and view.

To be honest, I have not had an ebook that Calibre did not open.


 

McBell

Unbound
In addition to what
[USER=76416]@McBell
, one person taking part in the Quora discussion mentioned having transferred all his Kindle books to a Calibre folder on his computer, same as you did. That sounds like a wise move and I'm going to do it with my own e-books. Thanks for that helpful information you provided! In the past, I've also downloaded a lot of free Google books to my computer -- mostly reference books of historical interest which are now old enough to be in the public domain.
The reason I also put them on a usb is because I had a computer get fried (including the printer, external HDs, monitor, etc.) and lost all the information on it.

That can not happen to a usb in a safe across the house from the computer
 

icehorse

......unaffiliated...... anti-dogmatist
Premium Member
I've given away all of my physical library, and my entire library is now on Kindle.

Reading the OP led me to do some investigating as to whether or not Amazon is within its rights to yank purchased e-books from one's library.

From what I understand, Amazon has the ability to delete books remotely, and you have no rights to them, as you don't own them.

It doesn't appear downloading them helps either, because opening the files requires Amazon's proprietary applications.

I'm currently regretting my decision to buy e-books in lieu of paper copies. And I was thinking I was helping the environment. :confused:

fwiw, I use my kindle ONLY for reading novels. Any book that I might want to refer to later I buy a physical copy of.
 

Bthoth

Well-Known Member
"""""the freedom to read """""

As a child, I read about everything that I could get my hands on. By 17yrs old I think I read the bible in it's entirety for the 3rd time. The first pass was because church was a weekly requirement and I had a hard time keeping up with the preaching methodology, so I asked how could I find the straight answers and was told, 'read the bible'.

Now after 50+ years beyond the early age, I often wonder why so many claim religious opinions that are different than what the bible(s) represents within.


I wish more folk that claim the biblical beliefs would actually read the book(s) versus claiming a religion that uses the material and practically creating new tangents that do not even exist in the bible.
 

anna.

colors your eyes with what's not there
I've given away all of my physical library, and my entire library is now on Kindle.

Reading the OP led me to do some investigating as to whether or not Amazon is within its rights to yank purchased e-books from one's library.

From what I understand, Amazon has the ability to delete books remotely, and you have no rights to them, as you don't own them.

It doesn't appear downloading them helps either, because opening the files requires Amazon's proprietary applications.

I'm currently regretting my decision to buy e-books in lieu of paper copies. And I was thinking I was helping the environment. :confused:

I'm definitely in the physical books camp. I've tried Kindle, but it leaves me cold. I've always just considered it personal preference (I'm a margin writer and underliner, etc.) and yet - the OP is making me glad I stayed on that route.
 

icehorse

......unaffiliated...... anti-dogmatist
Premium Member
i did a quick online searching to compare the eco-costs of print vs. ereader. At first blush it would appear that after downloading mybe 50 books, the ereader is more eco-friendly. But i haven't yet read about the hidden eco-costs of keeping server farms running.

so i'm guessing that e-books maybe aren't some huge eco-win over print?
 

SalixIncendium

अहं ब्रह्मास्मि
Staff member
Premium Member
i did a quick online searching to compare the eco-costs of print vs. ereader. At first blush it would appear that after downloading mybe 50 books, the ereader is more eco-friendly. But i haven't yet read about the hidden eco-costs of keeping server farms running.

so i'm guessing that e-books maybe aren't some huge eco-win over print?
I no longer own an e-reader. As mentioned earlier in the thread I use the Kindle app on tablet or a computer. E-Books without the e-reader must be more eco-friendly than physical books in this case.
 

icehorse

......unaffiliated...... anti-dogmatist
Premium Member
I no longer own an e-reader. As mentioned earlier in the thread I use the Kindle app on tablet or a computer. E-Books without the e-reader must be more eco-friendly than physical books in this case.

Off the top of my head, if Amazon can delete a book from a kindle, I have to imagine they can delete one off of your laptop? The point being it's yet another ongoing monitoring, powered by server farms.
 
Top