Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
i don't.
as a Christian, i seek to pray without ceasing as Christ did- in personal ways to the Father, rather than via repeated prayers or phrases. when Jesus taught His followers the Lord's prayer, He gave a template for personal prayer, teaching them to "pray in this manner" (Matthew 6:9). the prayers of Jesus we have recorded in the Gospels were personal, spontaneous, and arose from situations Christ was facing. for example, John 11:41-42, Matthew 11:25-26, and Matthew 26:39.
Christ wants us to share in the joyful, living intimacy with God that He enjoys. through Him, by faith, we have access to a walk with the Father. personally, i feel that Christian prayer should first reflect that personal and open nearness to God that Jesus gives us, rather than a learned format or liturgical pattern.
I understand your point,but I think one of the aims of the repeated phrase is to turn off the inner chatter and enter into a deeper or higher level of consciousness.Then you can enter more earnestly in a deeper heart connected prayer state.I don't believe in formulaic prayers as and end all....say five hail mary's etc,but the jesus prayer serves a different purpose and goes far beyond formulaic prayer.i don't.
as a Christian, i seek to pray without ceasing as Christ did- in personal ways to the Father, rather than via repeated prayers or phrases. when Jesus taught His followers the Lord's prayer, He gave a template for personal prayer, teaching them to "pray in this manner" (Matthew 6:9). the prayers of Jesus we have recorded in the Gospels were personal, spontaneous, and arose from situations Christ was facing. for example, John 11:41-42, Matthew 11:25-26, and Matthew 26:39.
Christ wants us to share in the joyful, living intimacy with God that He enjoys. through Him, by faith, we have access to a walk with the Father. personally, i feel that Christian prayer should first reflect that personal and open nearness to God that Jesus gives us, rather than a learned format or liturgical pattern.
I understand your point,but I think one of the aims of the repeated phrase is to turn off the inner chatter and enter into a deeper or higher level of consciousness.Then you can enter more earnestly in a deeper heart connected prayer state.I don't believe in formulaic prayers as and end all....say five hail mary's etc,but the jesus prayer serves a different purpose and goes far beyond formulaic prayer.
I wouldn't dismiss the Jesus prayer. It has been used to great effect by about a third of the world's Christians. We would do well to at least "come and see" whether anything good can come from it, especially when so many of our brothers and sisters say so.
yes, but.... the Jesus prayer says this :
"Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner".
knowing that God hears and knows what we need before we even saying it, and seeming as how in the Gospel narratives, Jesus hears and answers prayers for help after one cry, why would it be necessary for a Christian to ask God's forgiveness in Christ multiple times, as a repeated prayer?
we know that God is faithful and just to forgive our sins. we know that we are sinners- we are saved by Jesus' mercy and brought into His body by faith and grace, by willfully deciding to take up our cross, and follow Him. it's a singular, life-changing choice, which Christ Himself calls being "born of the Spirit". it's not something that is absorbed by cultural osmosis, nor earned by worshipful acts. after one believes and follows, the walk of discipleship begins. as James says, faith without works is dead, and Christ gave some very clear commandments on what His followers should be *doing* in the world.
the issue i'm considering is not whether the words of the prayer are of good or not-good content, or whether the practice is traditional or practiced by many- but whether the practice of Christian mantras is Christian, in the sense of being Christ-taught or Biblical.
Have any of you ever asked God for something in prayer that was clearly good, yet God did not grant your request? For instance, if you knew a child who was dieing of cancer and prayed for God to cure them and the child died.
I no longer pray for god to grant me things or change things in the material world.I do pray for him to help me to know him and to help with my spiritual development and to help me both see and work out my flaws and defects of character or things that hinder my spiritual walk.God often does not interfere in human affairs and events,but i think you can pray for help in your spiritual development.Have any of you ever asked God for something in prayer that was clearly good, yet God did not grant your request? For instance, if you knew a child who was dieing of cancer and prayed for God to cure them and the child died.
I did when I was a Christian. The brief introduction by Mother Alexandra of Ellwood City is excellent:Does anyone here practice the jesus prayer?