Mutaqalimun
New Member
In Islam there are mainly 3 positions on this matter:
1.Shiite view Kalamullah Quran was created
2.Sunni Salafist view Kalamullah Quran was uncreated
3.Sunni Ashariite view Kalamullah Quran consist of two (created&uncreated)
In perspective that SHRIK is the ultimate unforgivable sin in Islam, I know if human comparing Allah or His essence as created creation it would be called SHRIK. But it would make those who believe in point 1 are SHRIK.
For those who compare any creation as uncreated as same as Allah is also commit SHRIK, in that case those who believe point 2 are in deep trouble.
Now for those who unclear in their position whether they follow point or point 2 for me are just the same if they can't clearly explained how they should believe in ambiguity.
So in that case please kindly inform which is which the better position, by presenting the most convincing evidence each position can offers,cause it quite confusing if in case in the future I'm converting to Islam.
Asalamulaikum warahmatuilahi wabarkhkattu
1.Shiite view Kalamullah Quran was created
2.Sunni Salafist view Kalamullah Quran was uncreated
3.Sunni Ashariite view Kalamullah Quran consist of two (created&uncreated)
In perspective that SHRIK is the ultimate unforgivable sin in Islam, I know if human comparing Allah or His essence as created creation it would be called SHRIK. But it would make those who believe in point 1 are SHRIK.
For those who compare any creation as uncreated as same as Allah is also commit SHRIK, in that case those who believe point 2 are in deep trouble.
Now for those who unclear in their position whether they follow point or point 2 for me are just the same if they can't clearly explained how they should believe in ambiguity.
So in that case please kindly inform which is which the better position, by presenting the most convincing evidence each position can offers,cause it quite confusing if in case in the future I'm converting to Islam.
Asalamulaikum warahmatuilahi wabarkhkattu