• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Need advice... wanting to be Vegan

ZooGirl02

Well-Known Member
Hey everyone. I could use some advice. I am wanting to be vegan but I have a few issues. My doctor wants me to take a multivitamin every day. Unfortunately the multivitamins I have contain gelatin which I know is an animal derived ingredient. I can't afford to throw them out or give them away or buy more. Would it be ethical to take the ones I have?

I also have another question. I have a history of iron deficiency anemia and Vitamin D deficiency. Would it be feasible to eat a Vegan diet while still getting enough of these vitamins and minerals?

Thanks in advance for your help.
 

LuisDantas

Aura of atheification
Premium Member
Hey everyone. I could use some advice. I am wanting to be vegan but I have a few issues. My doctor wants me to take a multivitamin every day. Unfortunately the multivitamins I have contain gelatin which I know is an animal derived ingredient. I can't afford to throw them out or give them away or buy more. Would it be ethical to take the ones I have?

It is probably not proper for us to tell you what is ethical for you to do.

Nevertheless, it seems to me that the best approach if you want to reduce your impact on animals as well as to take proper care of your health (far as vitamins go, anyway) is to simply put some effort into having a more balanced diet. But I may easily be missing some significant factors, so you will probably want to seek your nutritionist, doctor or other qualified person face to face.


I also have another question. I have a history of iron deficiency anemia and Vitamin D deficiency. Would it be feasible to eat a Vegan diet while still getting enough of these vitamins and minerals?

I would think that iron is easy enough to take, by way of beans, nuts, lentils, soy, pumpkin seeds, quinoa, spinach. Cooking in iron pots is supposed to help considerably, too. It is advisable to lessen you intake of coffee and to attempt to take calcium at different times from the iron, though. Taking Vitamin C helps in the absorption of iron as well, so try to combine iron foods with Vitamin C foods.

Vitamin D deficiency is often strongly linked to a lack of sunlight, so you might want to consider changing that. Food sources include mushrooms (particularly ****ake) and several brands of orange juice and cereals that are treated to have some of it.

However, I would advise you to keep having the medical supervision that you need and taking the nutritional supplements that are recommended for a while at least. Changing your diet might well lead to lessening or even removing completely such a need, but it is best to let your doctor say if it is working and to which degree.
 

Me Myself

Back to my username
Hey everyone. I could use some advice. I am wanting to be vegan but I have a few issues. My doctor wants me to take a multivitamin every day. Unfortunately the multivitamins I have contain gelatin which I know is an animal derived ingredient. I can't afford to throw them out or give them away or buy more. Would it be ethical to take the ones I have?

I also have another question. I have a history of iron deficiency anemia and Vitamin D deficiency. Would it be feasible to eat a Vegan diet while still getting enough of these vitamins and minerals?

Thanks in advance for your help.

Sure, a slong as vitamin d you take pills for it and also with b12. Iron you could deal with your diet, but you still want to make blood exams at first to see how you are going with your diet

Six months vegetarian my blood exams where perfect, because ñi researched how I had to eat to get everytng I need. The best idea would be to consult a nutritionist, but the part you cant not do is the blood exam after you ve been vegan a time, better one now and one thre months form now probably.

As I said, really research on the diet to get everything you need. There are a lot of vitamin d enriched foods too.

I wouldnt throw anything awys if you can avoid it, it is already bought. About the gelatin, if you cant get without gelatin, you might want to do an exception when it is NECESSARY for your health, in opposition to when it is just for gastronomical pleasure.
 

Me Myself

Back to my username
Oh and everything that danta said about vigamin d, iron, vitamin c, and medical suppervision.

Didnt include sunlight cause it is not possible everywhere in the world all the time i think? Every day I can do it in ecuador, but I understand depending seasons in other places it may not be that easy? Dont know.

:)
 

lewisnotmiller

Grand Hat
Staff member
Premium Member
Hey everyone. I could use some advice. I am wanting to be vegan but I have a few issues. My doctor wants me to take a multivitamin every day. Unfortunately the multivitamins I have contain gelatin which I know is an animal derived ingredient. I can't afford to throw them out or give them away or buy more. Would it be ethical to take the ones I have?

I also have another question. I have a history of iron deficiency anemia and Vitamin D deficiency. Would it be feasible to eat a Vegan diet while still getting enough of these vitamins and minerals?

Thanks in advance for your help.

Hmm...my sister is vegatarian (not vegan though), and also has iron deficiency anemia. She's been able to keep everything healthy for about...umm...18 years now (wow, time flies!), and had a couple of kids in that time.

Her main thing is to see the doctor regularly and get her bloods done, and take tablets to supplement as required. Obviously easier to be vegetarian than vegan, and she has her own chickens to supply eggs, etc. Main thing for her is iron. She's always got to be aware of her diet in relation to it, and she's often having to take supplements.
 

Me Myself

Back to my username
I must stress again. If you eat well, you dont have to have any iron problem.

(Bt that does mean you need to research on that)
 

Poisonshady313

Well-Known Member
Hey everyone. I could use some advice. I am wanting to be vegan but I have a few issues. My doctor wants me to take a multivitamin every day. Unfortunately the multivitamins I have contain gelatin which I know is an animal derived ingredient. I can't afford to throw them out or give them away or buy more. Would it be ethical to take the ones I have?

You don't have to call yourself a vegan. You could live a vegan-esque lifestyle. If you wanted to put a name on it, you could call yourself a super vegetarian.

There is no ethical dilemma if you simply refrain from voluntarily imposing upon yourself an ethical standard which would make you a hypocrite if you continued to take the multivitamin.

Or... if it means that much to you to actually be an official vegan, I would recommend trying to find a multivitamin that would take care of your needs but doesn't contain gelatin.
 

Me Myself

Back to my username
Also that ^

:D

Labels are supposed to help you define stuff. The label should fit you, not the other way around.
 

ZooGirl02

Well-Known Member
Hmmm, I think rather than being a strict Vegan I am going to be a Vegan but use animal derived products only when necessity dictates that I do so. For example with the vitamins I'll continue taking them and if I can't afford others I'll continue buying them. When it comes to shoes and other animal derived non-health products I'll also use animal derived products when necessity dictates I do so. That way it doesn't put too much burden on me but yet I am still lessening my impact on animals. Besides that I do have a cat and cats are obligate carnivores. I'm not about to deprive her of meat when she evolved to need it to live.
 

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
I don't see the problem. While your average supermarket bought multivitamin or mineral supplement usually contains animal products, I never had any problem finding vegetarian vitamins in co-ops, health food stores or specialized vitamin shops. It'll say "suitable for vegetarians" or "contains no animal products" or some such on the label.
 

lewisnotmiller

Grand Hat
Staff member
Premium Member
I must stress again. If you eat well, you dont have to have any iron problem.

(Bt that does mean you need to research on that)

That depends, really. My mum and sister both have iron issues. My mum is not vegetarian, and her's are not diet related. She ingests plenty of iron, but her body doesn't absorb it as effectively as it should. My sister might have a touch of that, I think (not too sure to be honest) and obviously it's more of a challenge for her to plan a diet high in iron as a vegetarian. But quite possible, I might add...
 

Vinayaka

devotee
Premium Member
Hey everyone. I could use some advice. I am wanting to be vegan but I have a few issues. My doctor wants me to take a multivitamin every day. Unfortunately the multivitamins I have contain gelatin which I know is an animal derived ingredient. I can't afford to throw them out or give them away or buy more. Would it be ethical to take the ones I have?

I also have another question. I have a history of iron deficiency anemia and Vitamin D deficiency. Would it be feasible to eat a Vegan diet while still getting enough of these vitamins and minerals?

Thanks in advance for your help.

My son and his fiance have been vegan for about 6 years. I know they read up on it a lot. I'm vegetarian (lacto) and have very few worried regarding iron and B12. They are always okay when we get them checked. As others have said, certainly in the beginning, lots of study should be undertaken, as well a occasional blood checks. Best of luck with it.
 

ZooGirl02

Well-Known Member
Well I am going back to being Catholic but I do still think I might want to be a Vegan or Vegetarian. I am really not sure yet. I am going to discuss it with my doctor because I do have a lot of health issues and I don't eat right as it is. If I took meat completely out of my diet it might have negative health effects.

That said, I hate the practices of factory farms. To me they are unnecessarily cruel to animals. I don't condemn meat eating and dairy eating/drinking at all because I do believe God gave us stewardship over the earth and animals and that animals are there for us to eat and use for clothing and such. However, I really do wish that there would be greater reforms as far as factory farms go. As for myself, I am definitely going to reduce the amount of animal products I consume and possibly try to eliminate the vast majority of them.
 

Vinayaka

devotee
Premium Member
If I took meat completely out of my diet it might have negative health effects.

Or ... it might have some really positive side effects. I've always wondered why the meat-eaters are so worried about where vegetarians get their protein, yet vegetarians seem far less worried about where meat-eaters get their vitamins.
 

lewisnotmiller

Grand Hat
Staff member
Premium Member
Or ... it might have some really positive side effects. I've always wondered why the meat-eaters are so worried about where vegetarians get their protein, yet vegetarians seem far less worried about where meat-eaters get their vitamins.

Speaking for myself, as a meat-eater, I was more interested in her iron levels, given that she said she had an iron deficiency. Same situation as my sister. Other than that, the only time I worry about vegetarians is when I'm grilling, and trying to work out how to stop the meat-juices spreading.
 

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Iron is a pretty common stuff. Finding supplements, if needed, shouldn't be a problem.
 

Kerr

Well-Known Member
Hmmm, I think rather than being a strict Vegan I am going to be a Vegan but use animal derived products only when necessity dictates that I do so. For example with the vitamins I'll continue taking them and if I can't afford others I'll continue buying them. When it comes to shoes and other animal derived non-health products I'll also use animal derived products when necessity dictates I do so. That way it doesn't put too much burden on me but yet I am still lessening my impact on animals. Besides that I do have a cat and cats are obligate carnivores. I'm not about to deprive her of meat when she evolved to need it to live.
Seems like a good approach to me.

I am a vegetarian, btw, and I dont eat gelatin. But I suppose that if the doctor told me I needed vitamins then I would have to consider it (I am terribly inflexible, though... seriously, dont be like me :p).
 

Kerr

Well-Known Member
Or ... it might have some really positive side effects. I've always wondered why the meat-eaters are so worried about where vegetarians get their protein, yet vegetarians seem far less worried about where meat-eaters get their vitamins.
I once had a teacher asked me how I was alive, since according to him I shouldnt have gotten everything I needed from my diet :areyoucra.
 
Top