• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Personal Relationships with Others

Fool

ALL in all
Premium Member
Should a personal belief with a deity, or other, be practiced/forced upon another not in that relationship??

Why would someone want that?
 
Last edited:

David T

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
Should a personal belief with a deity, or other, be practiced/forced upon another not in that relationship??

Why would someone want that?
what we call ego.
Its most clearly played out by the extreme addict who has crashed, gotten god and now has a bullhorn on a street corner with signs button holing people It's a product of culture. Completely dysfunctional but a sober dysfunctional which is normal on spectrum.
 

PureX

Veteran Member
Should a personal belief with a deity, or other, be practiced/forced upon another not in that relationship??

Why would someone want (to do) that?
Ego. The ego dictates that they must be right, and anyone who does not agree with them must then be wrong. The ego also dictates that it is the responsibility of the righteous one (oneself) to "correct" the error of everyone else.

When people do not take control of their own egos, their egos take control of them. And they become toxic to others, because the ego is all about the 'self'. Protecting it, promoting it, and justifying it, no matter what.
 
Last edited:

Thief

Rogue Theologian
Should a personal belief with a deity, or other, be practiced/forced upon another not in that relationship??

Why would someone want that?
forced?

I suspect God and heaven will take a look......when I stand from this soon to be carcass
They will (might) have some interest what stands from the dust (me)

I do not think they will force themselves upon my will

They will ask me to follow.....(YEAH!)
or they will leave me wherever I fell......(oh, oh)
 

Kelly of the Phoenix

Well-Known Member
Should a personal belief with a deity, or other, be practiced/forced upon another not in that relationship??

Why would someone want that?
No. Let God call whom He wants. However, "no" is an answer good enough for God, and as we were made in His image, it can be good enough for us too. If God's not talking to them, that's between them.

Its most clearly played out by the extreme addict who has crashed, gotten god and now has a bullhorn on a street corner with signs button holing people
Yeah, it does seem to be the newbies doing this the most, doesn't it?

I mean, imagine being a newlywed and being so excited about it you are inviting the entire city to come have sex with your spouse because you enjoy having sex with your new spouse so much.
 

David T

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
No. Let God call whom He wants. However, "no" is an answer good enough for God, and as we were made in His image, it can be good enough for us too. If God's not talking to them, that's between them.


Yeah, it does seem to be the newbies doing this the most, doesn't it?

I mean, imagine being a newlywed and being so excited about it you are inviting the entire city to come have sex with your spouse because you enjoy having sex with your new spouse so much.
perfect. Besides bob dylan never has figured it out so how can we expect just average folks to get a handle it. Not easy stuff at all.
 
Last edited:

LuisDantas

Aura of atheification
Premium Member
Should a personal belief with a deity, or other, be practiced/forced upon another not in that relationship??

No, because deity-beliefs are extremely personal and rarely if ever a good fit for any other people.

Why would someone want that?

To a large extent, for that very reason.

It is too much to expect others to share of our own god-beliefs, but it is extremely tempting to hope that they might turn out that way if properly encouraged.
 

Fool

ALL in all
Premium Member
What relationship?

And what do you mean by "practiced upon?" Do you mean like praying for someone?
no like preying on someone to become this ism vs that ism vs any other ism.


forced conversion, or forcing one's belief onto the general public. a faction requiring its personal practices, holidays, forms of worship onto some other ism.

someone believing you got to do it in this form because it's this action.

example the belief that a bird is only one that flies and is black and white. no more birds are allowed to represent the true bird.

they believe penquins are unacceptable as a birds.
 
Last edited:

LuisDantas

Aura of atheification
Premium Member
@Fool , there is an element of practical need factoring in those situations.

To some extent, respect can only exist in the presence of mutual understanding. And that demands a modicum of common vocabulary and even common experiences, if not necessarily common values.

That is probably one reason why people so often make those demands and basically decide to pretend that other people can be made to share their beliefs. The pretense is wrong and destructive, but the achievement of a common language is very much useful. Even disagreements need some common ground of understanding.

People should be encouraged to understand other people's values and beliefs. The mistake is in expecting them to convert, be it due to that understanding or otherwise.
 

Akivah

Well-Known Member
Should a personal belief with a deity, or other, be practiced/forced upon another not in that relationship??

Why would someone want that?
I can think of two major reasons
1) They think that those that don't have their beliefs are at risk and want to help them.
2) It bolsters their faith the more they can get others to agree with them.
 

9-10ths_Penguin

1/10 Subway Stalinist
Premium Member
no like preying on someone to become this ism vs that ism vs any other ism.


forced conversion, or forcing one's belief onto the general public. a faction requiring its personal practices, holidays, forms of worship onto some other ism.

someone believing you got to do it in this form because it's this action.

example the belief that a bird is only one that flies and is black and white. no more birds are allowed to represent the true bird.

they believe penquins are unacceptable as a birds.
Ah... so it was a loaded question you were going for. Gotcha.
 

Fool

ALL in all
Premium Member
Ah... so it was a loaded question you were going for. Gotcha.

not necessarily, no.

some folks are genuinely doing it because they are attempting to save another from what they believe is an errant directions to a lost soul; when the person may be just wondering and/or wandering. not everyone who is wandering/wondering is lost.

akivah made me aware of this in his post. how we wish to project ourselves is personal.


not everyone and everything is ours to decorate. some things are beautiful as they are in their wildness, and polarity to us and still expressing in an outward and different appearance. they seem different but intrinsically they compliment each other.

love doesn't look at shallow surfaces. it looks deeper and never fathoms the exactness of why. it doesn't become familiar, nor sees this otherness as common. love is like that
 
Top