Question for anti-trans monotheists

[lostwanderingsoul]

If you need a special definition of "female" for humans to make your approach work, this is a good sign that your approach doesn't actually work.

Wonderful. So you see humans as the same as seahorses or cockroaches. I think there are differences.

 

[9-10ths_Penguin]

Wonderful. So you see humans as the same as seahorses or cockroaches. I think there are differences.

Should I respond as if:

- you didn't understand my post, or
- you deliberately misrepresented my post?

 

[TagliatelliMonster]

Many women have cancer and have their organs removed and can no longer have children. Does that make them males?

Hey, i'm just responding to what YOU said.

it's YOU who defined women as those humans that have those organs and are able to bear children.
it's also YOU who said that god is a male, because god himself identified him as such.

By the very logic and criteria YOU YOURSELF have provided, Sam Bettens is a male.

If you disagree, then you either have to reconsider your god's gender OR you have to engage in special pleading.

Choose your fallacy.

 

[lostwanderingsoul]

Hey, i'm just responding to what YOU said.

it's YOU who defined women as those humans that have those organs and are able to bear children.
it's also YOU who said that god is a male, because god himself identified him as such.

By the very logic and criteria YOU YOURSELF have provided, Sam Bettens is a male.

If you disagree, then you either have to reconsider your god's gender OR you have to engage in special pleading.

Choose your fallacy.

Women who have organs removed because they have a disease are still women because they were born with female organs. Women who have organs removed because they THINK that will make them males are still females regardless of what they think.

 

[TagliatelliMonster]

Women who have organs removed because they have a disease are still women because they were born with female organs. Women who have organs removed because they THINK that will make them males are still females regardless of what they think.

What about hermaphrodites, who have both organs?
And so what are then the criteria by which you assume god to be male?