Y’know, if I could say one last thing, dealing with
@Tumah, debating this topic and related topics....these help me. The more I think about these things, the more I'm beginning to see why so many people are quick to criticize Abrahamic religions. Why there are people who even despise these religions (at least, the three major ones).
To be fair, though, I never understood people who even threw Judaism into the fire. I used to believe that Judaism was a tolerant religion. To me, even though didn't say ‘all religions are legitimate’, at least Judaism didn't think less of you for having your religion, right? Jews didn't condemn people for following their religions. To me, it said,
‘If you're Jewish, then Judaism is your religion. If you're not....enh, you're fine. Follow your religion, but just be a righteous person. You don't have to convert to Judaism.’
They just left you alone. No problem.
Now, @Tumah has helped me understand that according to Orthodox Judaism, any non-Jewish religion is illegitimate. I accept this as his understanding. No issue. I wish him well. God bless him. He has also helped me finally see the irreconcilability between The Noahide Laws and The Bahá’í Faith, so thank you, brother. This, methinks, is a reflection of the difference between Judaism via The Laws and The Bahá’í Faith.
The very existence of a seperate set of laws for non-members of the religion, I think, points to an odd kind of situation for me.
You discourage me from converting to your religion, but then you say ‘you can't have your own’, just follow the Laws (which are, as @Tumah describes, ‘Judaism for non-Jews’).’
In my religion, we don't have this concept of a separate set of laws of non-Bahá’ís. Actually, I don't know of any other which does. We say, ‘we'd like you to turn on to Bahá’u’lláh, to declare faith in Him, but even if you decide not to, you're still OK. There's no pressure. It doesn't matter what religion you choose. If you're a Christian, be so. A Muslim? Be so. A Hindu, a Buddhist, be so. A Pagan. Be so. Even an Atheist, or Agnostic. Be so. A Jew? Be so.’
In light of this realization, I'm finished here. Tumah, you can keep your religion. You can keep your Laws, too. Both the 613 mitzvot AND the Noahide Laws. I desire no part in either one, because I have my own religion.
To be fair, though, I never understood people who even threw Judaism into the fire. I used to believe that Judaism was a tolerant religion. To me, even though didn't say ‘all religions are legitimate’, at least Judaism didn't think less of you for having your religion, right? Jews didn't condemn people for following their religions. To me, it said,
‘If you're Jewish, then Judaism is your religion. If you're not....enh, you're fine. Follow your religion, but just be a righteous person. You don't have to convert to Judaism.’
They just left you alone. No problem.
Now, @Tumah has helped me understand that according to Orthodox Judaism, any non-Jewish religion is illegitimate. I accept this as his understanding. No issue. I wish him well. God bless him. He has also helped me finally see the irreconcilability between The Noahide Laws and The Bahá’í Faith, so thank you, brother. This, methinks, is a reflection of the difference between Judaism via The Laws and The Bahá’í Faith.
The very existence of a seperate set of laws for non-members of the religion, I think, points to an odd kind of situation for me.
You discourage me from converting to your religion, but then you say ‘you can't have your own’, just follow the Laws (which are, as @Tumah describes, ‘Judaism for non-Jews’).’
In my religion, we don't have this concept of a separate set of laws of non-Bahá’ís. Actually, I don't know of any other which does. We say, ‘we'd like you to turn on to Bahá’u’lláh, to declare faith in Him, but even if you decide not to, you're still OK. There's no pressure. It doesn't matter what religion you choose. If you're a Christian, be so. A Muslim? Be so. A Hindu, a Buddhist, be so. A Pagan. Be so. Even an Atheist, or Agnostic. Be so. A Jew? Be so.’
In light of this realization, I'm finished here. Tumah, you can keep your religion. You can keep your Laws, too. Both the 613 mitzvot AND the Noahide Laws. I desire no part in either one, because I have my own religion.
Last edited: