• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

The Joys of Reading

Glaurung

Denizen of Niflheim
Last night I finished reading the Hobbit by J.R.R Tolkien. Hitherto I had not read any novels for quite some time nor had I read anything of Tolkien. (I attempted to read Lord of the Rings as a child but I never got far). It was only out of whim when I saw the book lying around that I started to read it as something to do before bed. This time I was immediately drawn into the world of Middle Earth and within a week I had finished the entire novel. I enjoyed the work so much that I went to a brick and mortar bookshop and purchased a nice box set containing the Hobbit and the three Lord of the Rings novels. Even though I already possessed a copy of the Hobbit I wanted the box set for my bookshelf. Next time I'm out I'll donate my old copy to Saint Vinnies and hopefully it will provide someone out there with the same joy it provided me.

In any case, sitting up in bed wrapped up in a blanket reading a novel was an experience I never realized I missed. Sure, e-books are neat and have their place but there's something about the experience of a physical book which e-books lack. Books are objects of beauty and they invite me to read them more than digital files on a laptop or a Kindle ever could. It also opened my eyes to the value of fiction which I had dismissed for quite some time. Most of my reading has been non-fiction but I now see that I ought to make more time for stories. Especially for works as in depth and expansive as Tolkien's.

Indeed the themes in the Hobbit left me contemplating the nature of ideas such as mercy and greed. In the Misty Mountains Bilbo stumbles upon the One Ring and as a result gains the upper hand in his conflict with Gollum. Bilbo gains the opportunity to slay Gollum but instead chooses to leap over him despite the risk of such an action. Gollum seeks to eat Bilbo and thus Bilbo would have been justified in slaying the vile creature. Yet Bilbo chooses the path of mercy. An act of mercy which would prove instrumental in the defeat of Sauron many decades later.

Likewise Smaug spends his time sitting upon his horde of treasure. He knows every piece of it down to the most insignificant coin and so he notices and flies into a murderous rage when Bilbo steals a goblet while he was sleeping. As a dragon Smaug has no use for his horded wealth. He cannot spend it (nor would he want to) rather it sits idle in a ruin serving no purpose other than Smaug's irrational obsession. Smaug seeks treasure for treasure's sake far beyond any tangible benefit for him. Likewise Thorin is overcome by the same obsession and alienates Bilbo and the people of Lake-Town, whom the Dwarves of the Lonely Mountain depend upon for food and whose town had been decimated by the Dwarves' awakening of Smaug. Indeed a portion of the treasure never belonged to the Dwarves to begin with, yet Thorin refuses to see reason until he is mortally wounded in the Battle of Five Armies.

Remember the Hobbit is a lighthearted children's book and yet in its themes there is much insight to be gained. I can only imagine the value I'll see in the Lord of the Rings when I begin to read it this evening. It has opened my eyes to the value of fiction and so even after I'm done with the trilogy I intend to make novel reading a regular part of my life going forward.

I would also encourage people to read more books. I have read news stories claiming that fewer adults than ever are regularly reading for pleasure. The prospect of book reading becoming a culturally niche activity would be a truly sad development.
 
Last edited:

Nimos

Well-Known Member
Last night I finished reading the Hobbit by J.R.R Tolkien. Hitherto I had not read any novels for quite some time nor had I read anything of Tolkien. (I attempted to read Lord of the Rings as a child but I never got far). It was only out of whim when I saw the book lying around that I started to read it as something to do before bed. This time I was immediately drawn into the world of Middle Earth and within a week I had finished the entire novel. I enjoyed the work so much that I went to a brick and mortar bookshop and purchased a nice box set containing the Hobbit and the three Lord of the Rings novels. Even though I already possessed a copy of the Hobbit I wanted the box set for my bookshelf. Next time I'm out I'll donate my old copy to Saint Vinnies and hopefully it will provide someone out there with the same joy it provided me.

In any case, sitting up in bed wrapped up in a blanket reading a novel was an experience I never realized I missed. Sure, e-books are neat and have their place but there's something about the experience of a physical book which e-books lack. Books are objects of beauty and they invite me to read them more than digital files on a laptop or a Kindle ever could. It also opened my eyes to the value of fiction which I had dismissed for quite some time. Most of my reading has been non-fiction but I now see that I ought to make more time for stories. Especially for works as in depth and expansive as Tolkien's.

Indeed the themes in the Hobbit left me contemplating the nature of ideas such as mercy and greed. In the Misty Mountains Bilbo stumbles upon the One Ring and as a result gains the upper hand in his conflict with Gollum. Bilbo gains the opportunity to slay Gollum but instead chooses to leap over him despite the risk of such an action. Gollum seeks to eat Bilbo and thus Bilbo would have been justified in slaying the vile creature. Yet Bilbo chooses the path of mercy. An act of mercy which would prove instrumental in the defeat of Sauron many decades later.

Likewise Smaug spends his time sitting upon his horde of treasure. He knows every piece of it down to the most insignificant coin and so he notices and flies into a murderous rage when Bilbo steals a goblet while he was sleeping. As a dragon Smaug has no use for his horded wealth. He cannot spend it (nor would he want to) rather it sits idle in a ruin serving no purpose other than Smaug's irrational obsession. Smaug seeks treasure for treasure's sake far beyond any tangible benefit for him. Likewise Thorin is overcome by the same obsession and alienates Bilbo and the people of Lake-Town, whom the Dwarves of the Lonely Mountain depend upon for food and whose town had been decimated by the Dwarves' awakening of Smaug. Indeed a portion of the treasure never belonged to the Dwarves to begin with, yet Thorin refuses to see reason until he is mortally wounded in the Battle of Five Armies.

Remember the Hobbit is a lighthearted children's book and yet in its themes there is much insight to gained. I can only imagine the value I'll see in the Lord of the Rings when I begin to read it this evening. It has opened my eyes to the value of fiction and so even after I'm done with the trilogy I intend to make novel reading a regular part of my life going forward.

I would also encourage people to read more books. I have read news stories claiming that fewer adults than ever are regularly reading for pleasure. The prospect of book reading becoming a culturally niche activity would be a truly sad development.
I like the Universe as well, except the Hobbit, have tried reading it both as book and as a comic, and I had to give up both times, it was so boring :D I finally manage to complete the story when it came as a movie, and even that weren't to good.
I did however read Lord of the Rings and that is very good I think and love the movies, except some of the characters which are portrayed a bit off, compared to the book I think, looking at you Gimli and Legolas :D. So I can only imagine that if you really enjoyed the Hobbit, you will love Lord of the Rings. So have fun :D
 

RestlessSoul

Well-Known Member
The joy of discovering a new writer, and deciding you are going to read everything he or she wrote, is like falling in love.

Of course, sometimes you discover that you lucked out with the first book (first date), and that writer might at times require effort and concentration, and still leave you baffled and bewildered.
 

Mock Turtle

Oh my, did I say that!
Premium Member
In a similar vein, the Gormenghast trilogy by Mervyn Peake is another enjoyable epic - not such a big reader of fiction although I have read quite a bit.
 

Glaurung

Denizen of Niflheim
I like the Universe as well, except the Hobbit, have tried reading it both as book and as a comic, and I had to give up both times, it was so boring :D I finally manage to complete the story when it came as a movie, and even that weren't to good.
I did however read Lord of the Rings and that is very good I think and love the movies, except some of the characters which are portrayed a bit off, compared to the book I think, looking at you Gimli and Legolas :D. So I can only imagine that if you really enjoyed the Hobbit, you will love Lord of the Rings. So have fun :D
I'm not saying you're wrong for having an opinion that differs from mine but I couldn't imagine finding the Hobbit boring. It does have a much lighter, less serious tone than Lord of the Rings and I could imagine that being off-putting for some. But appealing to my inner overgrown child isn't a bad thing in my opinion.

The joy of discovering a new writer, and deciding you are going to read everything he or she wrote, is like falling in love.

Of course, sometimes you discover that you lucked out with the first book (first date), and that writer might at times require effort and concentration, and still leave you baffled and bewildered.
This was the first time I've sat down to read Tolkien as an adult, but this was not the first time I've been exposed to Tolkien. I did read a chunk of the Fellowship of the Ring when I was much younger and I have seen the movies so it's not as if I don't know what I'm getting into. I'm almost certainly going to enjoy the Lord of the Rings so I'm not concerned with being baffled or bewildered.

In a similar vein, the Gormenghast trilogy by Mervyn Peake is another enjoyable epic - not such a big reader of fiction although I have read quite a bit.
I'll keep note of your suggestion and I'll have a look at it when I'm looking for new material to read.
 

Subduction Zone

Veteran Member
Muah ha ha!! You sound as if you are hooked on Tolkien. His Ring Series is one that I have read far too often. I couldn't fully enjoy the movies because of the differences from the written word. It was almost sacrilege to me. It is nice to hear of another fan.
 

Unveiled Artist

Veteran Member
Last night I finished reading the Hobbit by J.R.R Tolkien. Hitherto I had not read any novels for quite some time nor had I read anything of Tolkien. (I attempted to read Lord of the Rings as a child but I never got far). It was only out of whim when I saw the book lying around that I started to read it as something to do before bed. This time I was immediately drawn into the world of Middle Earth and within a week I had finished the entire novel. I enjoyed the work so much that I went to a brick and mortar bookshop and purchased a nice box set containing the Hobbit and the three Lord of the Rings novels. Even though I already possessed a copy of the Hobbit I wanted the box set for my bookshelf. Next time I'm out I'll donate my old copy to Saint Vinnies and hopefully it will provide someone out there with the same joy it provided me.

In any case, sitting up in bed wrapped up in a blanket reading a novel was an experience I never realized I missed. Sure, e-books are neat and have their place but there's something about the experience of a physical book which e-books lack. Books are objects of beauty and they invite me to read them more than digital files on a laptop or a Kindle ever could. It also opened my eyes to the value of fiction which I had dismissed for quite some time. Most of my reading has been non-fiction but I now see that I ought to make more time for stories. Especially for works as in depth and expansive as Tolkien's.

Indeed the themes in the Hobbit left me contemplating the nature of ideas such as mercy and greed. In the Misty Mountains Bilbo stumbles upon the One Ring and as a result gains the upper hand in his conflict with Gollum. Bilbo gains the opportunity to slay Gollum but instead chooses to leap over him despite the risk of such an action. Gollum seeks to eat Bilbo and thus Bilbo would have been justified in slaying the vile creature. Yet Bilbo chooses the path of mercy. An act of mercy which would prove instrumental in the defeat of Sauron many decades later.

Likewise Smaug spends his time sitting upon his horde of treasure. He knows every piece of it down to the most insignificant coin and so he notices and flies into a murderous rage when Bilbo steals a goblet while he was sleeping. As a dragon Smaug has no use for his horded wealth. He cannot spend it (nor would he want to) rather it sits idle in a ruin serving no purpose other than Smaug's irrational obsession. Smaug seeks treasure for treasure's sake far beyond any tangible benefit for him. Likewise Thorin is overcome by the same obsession and alienates Bilbo and the people of Lake-Town, whom the Dwarves of the Lonely Mountain depend upon for food and whose town had been decimated by the Dwarves' awakening of Smaug. Indeed a portion of the treasure never belonged to the Dwarves to begin with, yet Thorin refuses to see reason until he is mortally wounded in the Battle of Five Armies.

Remember the Hobbit is a lighthearted children's book and yet in its themes there is much insight to be gained. I can only imagine the value I'll see in the Lord of the Rings when I begin to read it this evening. It has opened my eyes to the value of fiction and so even after I'm done with the trilogy I intend to make novel reading a regular part of my life going forward.

I would also encourage people to read more books. I have read news stories claiming that fewer adults than ever are regularly reading for pleasure. The prospect of book reading becoming a culturally niche activity would be a truly sad development.

Great you journied to the dark side with us book nerds. I'm not really a fantasy person, but I have read the first two books of Harry Potter. Id suggest that too. I'm reading the boy who lived underground by Richard wright. The first book of his I read, Native, was excellent. The count of Monte Cristo....celestine prophecy.

To name a few. The book I reading is the opposite of fantasy but when I finish I'll look at hobbit. Books are better than many movies...

Oh. Neverending story is great both book and movie. Star trek many series books are good.

Ebooks are good for preview sample before you buy the book. I like the feel too. $25 cause it is a classic, but worth it

Ok. Ha. I'm done...happy reading.
 
Last edited:

Subduction Zone

Veteran Member
upload_2021-6-26_3-47-36.png

If you read this you will be busy for years.
 

Mock Turtle

Oh my, did I say that!
Premium Member
Muah ha ha!! You sound as if you are hooked on Tolkien. His Ring Series is one that I have read far too often. I couldn't fully enjoy the movies because of the differences from the written word. It was almost sacrilege to me. It is nice to hear of another fan.
Fortunately I had forgotten the book version (one fat volume, which I still have) when I viewed the film version. :D
 

RestlessSoul

Well-Known Member
Muah ha ha!! You sound as if you are hooked on Tolkien. His Ring Series is one that I have read far too often. I couldn't fully enjoy the movies because of the differences from the written word. It was almost sacrilege to me. It is nice to hear of another fan.


Funny, I thought those Peter Jackson movies did a fantastic job of transferring the page to the screen. Was disappointed that there was no room for Tom Bombadil in the first one though.
 

Subduction Zone

Veteran Member
Funny, I thought those Peter Jackson movies did a fantastic job of transferring the page to the screen. Was disappointed that there was no room for Tom Bombadil in the first one though.

I picked up a rather strong anti conservative vibe from him which ruined it a bit for me. Who knew that the U.S. was going to have our own rather incompetent version of Sauron?

I liked Tom Bombadil and missed him, and would have liked a bit more of the Ents as well. The addition of females to the combat roles did not sit well with me. There is a reason when it comes to old fashioned armed combat that it is so extremely male dominated. There is such a thing as sexual dimorphism.
 
Last edited:

Glaurung

Denizen of Niflheim
I thought the movies were great though the written word remains my preferred medium. I haven't seen the Hobbit movies as of yet so it will be interesting to see how they've translated it to film. I've learnt from reading Stephen King novels to not compare films to their books but to treat each as their own separate works.
 

sun rise

The world is on fire
Premium Member
but there's something about the experience of a physical book which e-books lack.
Amen.

And I also found and find depths in Tolkien.

And movies can only pick and choose what to include from a book. Books are so compact in that way that to include everything in a movie would make it hours upon hours long.
 

SomeRandom

Still learning to be wise
Staff member
Premium Member
Last night I finished reading the Hobbit by J.R.R Tolkien. Hitherto I had not read any novels for quite some time nor had I read anything of Tolkien. (I attempted to read Lord of the Rings as a child but I never got far). It was only out of whim when I saw the book lying around that I started to read it as something to do before bed. This time I was immediately drawn into the world of Middle Earth and within a week I had finished the entire novel. I enjoyed the work so much that I went to a brick and mortar bookshop and purchased a nice box set containing the Hobbit and the three Lord of the Rings novels. Even though I already possessed a copy of the Hobbit I wanted the box set for my bookshelf. Next time I'm out I'll donate my old copy to Saint Vinnies and hopefully it will provide someone out there with the same joy it provided me.

In any case, sitting up in bed wrapped up in a blanket reading a novel was an experience I never realized I missed. Sure, e-books are neat and have their place but there's something about the experience of a physical book which e-books lack. Books are objects of beauty and they invite me to read them more than digital files on a laptop or a Kindle ever could. It also opened my eyes to the value of fiction which I had dismissed for quite some time. Most of my reading has been non-fiction but I now see that I ought to make more time for stories. Especially for works as in depth and expansive as Tolkien's.

Indeed the themes in the Hobbit left me contemplating the nature of ideas such as mercy and greed. In the Misty Mountains Bilbo stumbles upon the One Ring and as a result gains the upper hand in his conflict with Gollum. Bilbo gains the opportunity to slay Gollum but instead chooses to leap over him despite the risk of such an action. Gollum seeks to eat Bilbo and thus Bilbo would have been justified in slaying the vile creature. Yet Bilbo chooses the path of mercy. An act of mercy which would prove instrumental in the defeat of Sauron many decades later.

Likewise Smaug spends his time sitting upon his horde of treasure. He knows every piece of it down to the most insignificant coin and so he notices and flies into a murderous rage when Bilbo steals a goblet while he was sleeping. As a dragon Smaug has no use for his horded wealth. He cannot spend it (nor would he want to) rather it sits idle in a ruin serving no purpose other than Smaug's irrational obsession. Smaug seeks treasure for treasure's sake far beyond any tangible benefit for him. Likewise Thorin is overcome by the same obsession and alienates Bilbo and the people of Lake-Town, whom the Dwarves of the Lonely Mountain depend upon for food and whose town had been decimated by the Dwarves' awakening of Smaug. Indeed a portion of the treasure never belonged to the Dwarves to begin with, yet Thorin refuses to see reason until he is mortally wounded in the Battle of Five Armies.

Remember the Hobbit is a lighthearted children's book and yet in its themes there is much insight to be gained. I can only imagine the value I'll see in the Lord of the Rings when I begin to read it this evening. It has opened my eyes to the value of fiction and so even after I'm done with the trilogy I intend to make novel reading a regular part of my life going forward.

I would also encourage people to read more books. I have read news stories claiming that fewer adults than ever are regularly reading for pleasure. The prospect of book reading becoming a culturally niche activity would be a truly sad development.
Ahh a newly converted Tolkien fan. The Hobbit is best for children (and us nerds.)
I can understand not liking the Lord of the Rings books as a child. I also tried to read them when I was a kid. Mostly because of the movies. I think they’re a bit dense for a child. Though at the time my geeky older cousin worshipped them. I think Harry Potter or Narnia is more the speed of children. But as an adult or older geek teen the Lord of the Rings trilogy are a wonderful read, imo
Make sure you pick up the Silmarillion. A must have for any Tolkien fan
 

Subduction Zone

Veteran Member
Amen.

And I also found and find depths in Tolkien.

And movies can only pick and choose what to include from a book. Books are so compact in that way that to include everything in a movie would make it hours upon hours long.
That is why an inordinate number of good science fiction movies are Phillip K. Dick stories. He wrote short stories that were well suited for movie scripts. A good novel has far too much going on in it to easily make that transition.
 
Top