The lady of heaven movie and Sunni protests

[stvdv]

A word called "False" is not some evidence.

Was not meant to be evidence

It's so simple:
I share my views on RF
You try to debate this
That's your game
Not my game

If I read something on RF I disagree with
I might give my view and then drop it
I feel no need to debate and defend
If others like it, fine, if not, also fine

I feel no need to prove myself
And no need to prove others are wrong

 

[firedragon]

I never said that, you might have interpreted it that way.

The only thing these Muslims do, is to exhibit their own ignorance and lack of common sense and extreme violent behavior. Totally forgetting that Islam is called "The Religion of Peace"

That's exactly what you said.

Was not meant to be evidence

It's so simple:
I share my views on RF
You try to debate this
That's your game
Not my game

If I read something on RF I disagree with
I might give my view and then drop it
I feel no need to debate and defend
If others like it, fine, if not, also fine

I feel no need to prove myself
And no need to prove others are wrong

But where are the videos or some evidence that in these protests there was violence? There could have been. I am not saying no, because I don't have evidence that there was no violence I am not saying "no". But your claim is right up there you could read.

If you don't have any evidence to your claim, you made a false claim. That was not your "view", that was a factual claim you made.

Your evidence so far has been "I speak the truth".

Don't demonise people mate. I don't know what kind of satisfaction people get by doing that so arbitrarily, but it's just showing some kind of serious weakness.

).

 

[England my lionheart]

If someone makes a documentary and put it on Youtube or other social media regarding your loved ones (your daughter, wife or mother) and makes them look vulgar or evil to the world - would you then protest?
It is easy to say no one should have a problem with this - when you don't feel any attachment to this religion or the historical personalities in question. Bring the issue to your personal level and see if it bothers you! I agree you may not protest like them but you will do whatever allowed by the law to take down that clip from the social media in question.
These people have a right to protest. They feel very closely attached to the matters surrounding their religion and consider it a matter of honor to defend. I agree that they should never be violent!

This is not due to the teaching of their religion. This is due to their sentiments. They need to realize that these protests are counter productive!

As I have already said,everybody has a right to protest but nobody has a right to not being offended.

The problem with these protests is the fear of violence that made 2 cinema chains cancel the movie,there hasn’t been any afaik but we know for sure there has been in the past because of depictions of their prophet,so protesting is fine but they should show the movie regardless.

 

[ajay0]

How is any of that relevant to the question I asked? Don't worry about dialogue because Sunni's and Shia's both are against this movie.

But this is a movie created by the Shia's themselves , which includes the shia cleric Yasser Al Habib. Shia's made the movie and both shias and sunnis condemn it as well as per you.

Why did the Shia's make the film in the first place !

 

[ajay0]

The UK government seems to have dismissed anti-Islamophobia adviser imam Qari Asim after he condemned the film as 'derogatory' .

UK government dismisses anti-Islamophobia adviser after condemning 'derogatory' film

Asim was terminated from his government appointment "with immediate effect," the Department of Levelling Up said in a letter to the imam published on Saturday.


"Your recent support for a campaign to limit free expression - a campaign which has itself encouraged communal tensions - means it is no longer appropriate for you to continue your work with Government in roles designed to promote community harmony," the letter said.

It added that it was "disappointed" that Asim had not condemned reports of "sectarian chanting and anti-Shia hatred" at the protests.

 

[firedragon]

But this is a movie created by the Shia's themselves , which includes the shia cleric Yasser Al Habib. Shia's made the movie and both shias and sunnis condemn it as well as per you.

If you don't know that, you don't know much at all. Just do some research.

Why did the Shia's make the film in the first place !

One Shii or a few making a movie does not mean "Shias made that movie". It's a habit of people who wish to jump through hoops to generalise at every turn.

Yep. Some Shii's made that movie. And most Shia's world over condemn it. Even Ayatullah's condemn the movie. Just do some googling because this is not some major scholarly subject to do years of studying about.

 

[stvdv]

Don't demonise people mate.

I don't mate. You read my reply wrong

 

[firedragon]

I don't mate. You read my reply wrong

Okay. If you say I misread your message, I apologise.

Have a great day.

 

[stvdv]

Okay. If you say I misread your message, I apologise.

Have a great day.

Thank you.

And I admit that my words could be interpreted in 3 ways (coincidentally), next time I better be even more precise to avoid misinterpretation

Have a great day too

 

[stevecanuck]

Yea. A Baptist website with such basic information on Arabic is a great source

Did it get anything wrong?

 

[firedragon]

Did it get anything wrong?

You? You didn't anything to get right or wrong.

 

[stevecanuck]

You? You don't know anything about it to get right or wrong. You just gave a link to a web page even you have no clue of, and you don't respond to anything be cause of the lack of very basic knowledge. So I can't answer that question since you didn't give anything to get it wrong or right.

Your faux 'responses' are getting weaker by the day.

 

[firedragon]

Your faux 'responses' are getting weaker by the day.

K