Whateverist
Active Member
For someone who doesn't come out of the sciences Phillip Ball's How Life Works: A User's Guide To The New Biology has done a great job of puling me in and along some pretty technical aspects of how life develops and persists. I'm finding the pay off as I cruise into Chapter 9: ‘Agency; How Life Gets Goals and Purposes’. From Kindle pages 333-34:
It is interesting to think of how all these individual cells come together to form metazoan creatures like ourselves whose purposes are served by the cooperation of so many simpler organisms at lower levels. It makes me wonder at the source of values which we experience as what draws and calls to us -not as blind causes which drive us unwittingly from behind. Perhaps just as our metazoan purposes are not known for what they are by the individual cells which make us up, so there may be a higher order metazoan whose being is made possible by the activity of creatures like ourselves. Could this be the reason people everywhere have intuited a god in some form or other?
… Even if we can begin to glimpse some of the principles that create robustness instead of fragility, there’s something unsettling about the way a structure, a creature, so literally single-minded emerges from all those details. How can it be that these many steps all work together in synchrony to fashion an organism like us? Why, for example, should the process of protein folding to make an enzyme cooperate with the migration of cells, at scales many thousands of times bigger, to make a tissue? All these processes operate as if in thrall to some overall plan, with us as the goal. Biology looks uncannily teleological. That thought disturbs some biologists no end.
Yet their discomfort cannot be allowed to deter us from taking the question seriously—which means asking what all this intricacy and ingenuity of life’s mechanisms is for. It might sound like a dangerously mystical question, or at best metaphysical. But rather than simply dismissing it as such, the goal should be to shape the question into a useful, tractable, testable form. That’s to say, one of the big challenges for biology is to develop a rational, productive framework for understanding concepts such as agency, information, meaning, and purpose. These are not optional add- ons for the philosophically inclined, once we have solved all the minutiae of how life works at the microscopic scale. Rather, they sit at the core of life itself. Without that big picture, we risk ending up with the equivalent of a detailed description of everything about a complex machine’s operation except for an understanding of what it actually does. What, after all, is the point of knowing how life works if we don’t know what it is working toward?
It is interesting to think of how all these individual cells come together to form metazoan creatures like ourselves whose purposes are served by the cooperation of so many simpler organisms at lower levels. It makes me wonder at the source of values which we experience as what draws and calls to us -not as blind causes which drive us unwittingly from behind. Perhaps just as our metazoan purposes are not known for what they are by the individual cells which make us up, so there may be a higher order metazoan whose being is made possible by the activity of creatures like ourselves. Could this be the reason people everywhere have intuited a god in some form or other?
Last edited: