• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

What would you do if you were this Father?

Spiderman

Veteran Member
So, you are a Father. You have two daughters and a son. You love your son because he likes to go fishing, hunting, play sports, go boating, white water rafting, wrestling, and do a lot of your hobbies, more so then your daughters.

After your son is 14 years old, your wife came forth with tears in her eyes and told you that your only son had a different father. Your wife sincerely apologized for cheating on you and keeping it a secret for so long.

Do you tell your son that you are not his biological father?

Do you treat your son just as well as you did when you thought you were his real biological dad?

Do you break up with your wife and very likely lose a custody battle for your kids?

Do you start to favor your daughters more than your son, because they are your flesh and blood, and he is the result of an unfaithful wife and immoral man (adulterery)?

Do you accept your wife's apology and forgive her? What would you say to her?

Every time you hang out with your son you are reminded that he isn't yours, and the heartache is just getting worse; and every time you see him, it's a reminder of what happened.

Your son is picking up on the new vibes from you, because you're very troubled about something. He asks you "what is wrong Dad?" Do you tell him?

Please answer honestly.

Honestly, I would try to not love my son or wife any less, but don't think things could go back to the way they were before. I would feel very sick I think.

So, my wife had poor judgement more than a decade prior. I can pardon her for falling in love and seeking happiness in the wrong places, but it would be very difficult to love her or my son as much as I did. I would be too troubled by it (I'm guessing).

Let's say you had an appetite for porn on occasion and you always fantasize about other women when you are having a good time with your wife. (We've all done something like that, manifesting in different ways.)

So, you come to realize that according to the Gospel, you were just as unfaithful to your wife, and you lied to her about your fantasy life.

Jesus said, " if you look at a woman with the desire to have intercourse with her, you have commited adultery in your heart".

So, you have the conviction that you are possibly even as guilty and more guilty of infidelity to her. She commited her acts 14 years ago afterall. Your lust is still a huge problem.

So, were that the case, and you had those convictions, would it make it easier to reconcile with your wife and trust her?

You don't catch her flirting with guys, yet you are checking out women all the time.

Would you recognize that any anger at your wife for being unfaithful isn't fair, and is hypocrictical of you?

Do you stay with your wife for the sake of what is best for the kids, and then you have plans of separating from her once the kids are grown up and out of the house?

What exactly would you do? I'm sure something like this happened before. Weirder things happen.

(Feel free to only answer one of the questions if you like. If you answer them all, you get an indulgence from the Pope :p )
 

Cacotopia

Let's go full Trottle
Not sure if I could stay with her, but would tell my son I'm not bio dad but still his dad. I wouldn't repeat the mistake of the maybe exwife.

PS: you are still alive, that's good.
 

stvdv

Veteran Member
This scenario crossed my mind when I was age 10. That is why I decided not to marry to a woman.
 

stvdv

Veteran Member
Let's say you had an appetite for porn on occasion and you always fantasize about other women when you are having a good time with your wife. (We've all done something like that, manifesting in different ways.)
I was never married. Better fix that habit before you marry.

So, you come to realize that according to the Gospel, you were just as unfaithful to your wife, and you lied to her about your fantasy life.
Jesus said, " if you look at a woman with the desire to have intercourse with her, you have commited adultery in your heart".
So, you have the conviction that you are possibly even as guilty and more guilty of infidelity to her. She commited her acts 14 years ago afterall. Your lust is still a huge problem.
So, were that the case, and you had those convictions, would it make it easier to reconcile with your wife and trust her?
You don't catch her flirting with guys, yet you are checking out women all the time.
Would you recognize that any anger at your wife for being unfaithful isn't fair, and is hypocrictical of you?

Nice graph showing less nice info "Who cheats most and at what age, man or woman"
https://ifstudies.org/ifs-admin/resources/cheating1new-w640.png

Big difference when the other cheats or dreams about it. I don't expect others to control their mind, esp. with Vid/Aud nowadays full of sex which will be processed in dreams.

If you confess to your wife you slept with another woman and she gets angry and you continue "in my dream" she will be less angry [she might restrict your smartphone]

IF 50-60 % divorce then 99.9% might have unfaithful thoughts and maybe >50% unfaithful actions [.jpg shows just 25% BUT that's the ones reported committing adultery]
Generally it takes 1 man + 1 woman to commit adultery. So women are not more faithful than men I think [see .jpg]. Big surprise, only young women commit more adultery.

If I would marry and she had sex with another she could leave. I would ask, before dating her, how she feels about this subject. And when she is easy going then I will be easy leaving.
 
Last edited:

SalixIncendium

अहं ब्रह्मास्मि
Staff member
Premium Member
So, you are a Father. You have two daughters and a son. You love your son because he likes to go fishing, hunting, play sports, go boating, white water rafting, wrestling, and do a lot of your hobbies, more so then your daughters.

After your son is 14 years old, your wife came forth with tears in her eyes and told you that your only son had a different father. Your wife sincerely apologized for cheating on you and keeping it a secret for so long.

Do you tell your son that you are not his biological father?

Yes. I'm for full disclosure. I took exception to not being told that the person I called Dad for the first 14 years of my life was not my biological father.

Do you treat your son just as well as you did when you thought you were his real biological dad?

Of course. Anyone with fertile sperm can be a father. It takes a love to be a dad. I don't think my love would change due to biology.

Do you break up with your wife and very likely lose a custody battle for your kids?

No. She made a mistake and ultimately admitted it without me finding out about it on my own.

Do you start to favor your daughters more than your son, because they are your flesh and blood, and he is the result of an unfaithful wife and immoral man (adulterery)?

I would not. But interestingly, being a child in a similar relationship, I felt that my step-father favored his biological sons over me.

Do you accept your wife's apology and forgive her? What would you say to her?

Yes. The indiscretion, although 14 years ago, would likely result in some trusts issues. I would simply communicate to her how I feel about the indiscretion and discuss how the trust issues might impact our relationship moving forward.

Every time you hang out with your son you are reminded that he isn't yours, and the heartache is just getting worse; and every time you see him, it's a reminder of what happened.

I disagree with this assessment completely.

Your son is picking up on the new vibes from you, because you're very troubled about something. He asks you "what is wrong Dad?" Do you tell him?

I can't really answer this question, because it assumes I haven't disclosed to him that I'm not his biological father. I already opened up to him about it in the first question.

You did leave out one part of the equation. How will my disclosure impact my son's relationship with his mother?
 

PureX

Veteran Member
I hope I would trust in the positive and healing power of love, honesty, humility, and forgiveness. But being human, I may not be able to see this goal as clearly as I would hope to, when in that actual circumstance.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
What happened to honesty, the wife has been deceiving her husband for 15 years. That is no basis for a marriage.

The boy is not at fault.
 
Top