• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Why do you dislike Islam?

Mohsen

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
It is indeed, and you won't get any remorse from me for that, since after all so much of it is not only self-inflicted but actually encouraged by the Qur'an.

Not to mention, prophesied in ahadeeth!



What did other Muslims?

rejoice at giving The Man the proverbial middle finger!

Qaddafi, not to put too fine a point on it, was a dangerous and insane leader, so I don't know why you even want to bring him up.

Subjective. Needs exploring.

For that matter, even your remark about Saudi Arabia ends up spotlighting that Islaam has failed itself even in its own motherland - and severely so at that. Is it because there are not enough Muslim there?

Actually, on the contrary, it only proved ahadeeth prophecy true.

Your sense of humor far surpasses mine, then.

Oh, let's not get too hung up on how long a donkeys pecker is eh? Pardon the pun.

That is the most significant factor, indeed, and the explanation for Islaam's survival to this day. People can and routinely transcend the limits that would be imposed by the Qur'an. In a very real sense, Islaam survives because it is protected by heretics conscious and otherwise that put themselves on the line everyday in order to protect its reputation at their own personal expense.

Nice narrative comrade, not convincing though. If we go by PEW, we can easily see that Islam would survive through the number of moderate Muslims who have led good honest lives, and spread throughout the world, integrating into socieities wherever they be, or the rate of new converts to Islam of which, the women converts outnumber the men by a ratio of 4/1... I didn't take you to be the type to paint a bogeyman Luis.

Nice narrative, comrade. Not a convincing one, though.

touché
 

Jedster

Flying through space
Nope. You are showing how you actually don't know much at all. Modern day Muslims have not forgotten the traditions they revived during the time Europeans had self termed "The Dark Ages". Who said the Muslim Golden Age is over?

Were you not aware of the likes of Pakistani Physicist and Nobel Prize winner, Abdus Salaam? Or how about Iranian Physicists, Ali Javan and Mahmoud Hessaby? or Munir Nafyeh - the Palestinian Particle Physicist?, or Mathematician Masatoshi Gunduz Ikeda? Cahit Arf? Anyone? damn... let's move to another field, like Muhammad Yunus, another Nobel Prize winner, and pioneering inventor of Micro-finance? how about Aktar Hameed Khan the Pioneer of Micro-Credit? you really think the mathematicians and scientists are done with in the Muslim world? I have a massively long list of names I can drop here to quell your ignorance on such matters.

peace

I am glad you mentioned Abdus Salaam who was an Ahmadi. Most Muslims I know would not have listed him as they don't consider Ahmadis as Muslims.
Peace & Kudos to you.
 

Mohsen

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Partially. I will simply note that this freedom of choosing your spouse from whatever religion is socially repressed on a lot of Muslim majority countries. You started this discussion with a you tube video about interfaith marriage, remember?
Anyways I have provided evidence showing a lot of Muslim majority countries have extremely low freedoms for their citizens while UK has far higher freedom index with comparable safety.

Supposedly, yet it is a subjective study and one which doesn't ask WHY as I demonstrated. And when I also presented to you the yang to your yin argument in the form of Christian majority nations wanting their children to marry Muslims - you became strangely silent.

Peace
 

sayak83

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
Supposedly, yet it is a subjective study and one which doesn't as WHY as I demonstrated. And when I also presented to you the yang to your yin argument in the form of Christian majority nations wanting their children to marry Muslims - you became strangely silent.

Peace
You did not quote any studies or data. There was nothing for me to reply to.
 

Laika

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
Peace be with you Laika, your response to this thread has warmed me to you. The irony you present isn't lost on me. Those who speak against Islam are the ones doing all the finger pointing here on RF. Meanwhile we Muslims, the silent minority, are rolling eyeballs. Turbo eyerolls.

As for Muslims with SSA (same sex attraction), A Muslim youtube channel didn't see a problem with filming an entire series with a Muslim man who has same sex attraction - of course the man himself is chaste. Here is one segment, of Paul (who has SSA) talking with Hussain. Both are Muslim. Filmed at the prestigious Regents Park Mosque:


Very calm, rational conversation. Quite endearing actually.



It's funny. When the very same posters who have an issue with Moozlums, wonder why the medical establishments are literally packed with Muslim Doctors, Physicians and Nurses etc. They can't work it out? Now you know why I stay silent. There is no reasoning with the "unreasonable" types. Just read through this thread. You'd think, after the number of years Muslims have posted rebuttals to commonly held misconceptions here on RF, there would be a change of wind... but no. Can't reason with them. They've shut their ears and blabbered their tongues ignorantly believing their islamophobic narrative is the only one which sticks.



I certainly am not here for that. If any of these members truly wanted to learn about Islam, they'd do so. But all they seem to do is feed their bias against it.



Here is one quote:

The Qur'an: 2nd Chapter, Al Baqarah (The Cow) [Heffer]

6. Verily, those who disbelieve, it is the same to them whether you (O Muhammad Peace be upon him ) warn them or do not warn them, they will not believe.

Which is why it is pointless attempting to reason with the unreasonable types

7. Allah has set a seal on their hearts and on their hearings, (i.e. they are closed from accepting Allah's Guidance), and on their eyes there is a covering. Theirs will be a great torment.

Sad as this is, it is what it is - but the non believers should't care about some "torment" they do not believe in. This is, after all, not their belief. So they have no right to cry about it.

8. And of mankind, there are some (hypocrites) who say: "We believe in Allah and the Last Day" while in fact they believe not.

9. They (think to) deceive Allah and those who believe, while they only deceive themselves, and perceive (it) not!

Many who are in for a penny and out for a pound. Including scholars for the dollars. God alone knows who is a true believer and who is not

10. In their hearts is a disease (of doubt and hypocrisy) and Allah has increased their disease. A painful torment is theirs because they used to tell lies.

Of the hypocrites and those whom are clear in disbelief, are you not reminded of any members on this forum ??? such as those who would feed each others bias to speak so vehemently opposed to Islam???

11. And when it is said to them: "Make not mischief on the earth," they say: "We are only peacemakers."

Ah, bingo... today we have the likes of Trump, and others who came before him - from the America's and Europe - these leaders who supposedly speak for their respective nations but in reality only speak for the powerhouses they represent. Did the Million Man March in London stop Tony Blair from invading Iraq on the pretense of "Weapons of Mass Destruction" ??? Will similar narratives stop Trump? Did they stop the two Bush's? I can carry on, and on.

12. Verily! They are the ones who make mischief, but they perceive not.

Clear as day to me, and to you! Unless you too "perceive it not"

Peace!

I remember that passage from the Qu'ran [admittedly because it is literally on page 2 and I haven't read the whole Qu'ran :oops: ] and I know what its getting at. I have experienced the sort of wall of pseudo-responses, where people are merely repeating half-remembered phases/excuses for not agreeing with or believing something. you get the responses that have been "programmed" and "conditioned" into people and it is very hard to get them to let their defences down and reconsider. They will stand by those positions forcefully, consistently and it makes absolutely no difference how much evidence you give them they are wrong. So the idea of "a seal has been set on their hearts and on their hearings" ..."and on their eyes a coverings" makes perfect sense to me. Its something I have grown use to on RF and am guilty of when I have feigned greater knowledge about a subject than I actually have. That has proven to be a strange benefit of being on RF as you quickly learn how we deceive ourselves if we are receptive to it.

Sadly, you are right that if people want to learn about Islam they will do it offline. It underlines a certain futility of participating in internet forums especially if we want to be understood, valued and to share our experiences. Putting Islamic theology aside for a moment (as I am in no position to tell a Muslim what to believe or think) my concern is really with the futility and defeatism of not fighting back. Truth and knowledge are something I would want to be regarded as sacred as our collective inheritance that transcends our individual selves. For someone to lie and to deliberately manipulate people is clearly wrong and is an attack on knowledge as our common property. What we typically deal with- both for Islam and other subjects- are generally not the deceivers and the manipulators, but the victims of the deception who believe the lie. I guess it is purely an emotional thing to want to believe that the truth will win and that "natural justice" will flow from that. Of course, its not that simple as the deceived often derive great satisfaction from the lie by believing they are superior to others even if their self-worth is fabricated.

You are probably aware of this site, but I thought it was worth sharing anyway if it makes your life any bit easier. :D
Muslims Condemn
 

sayak83

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
I'm running out of picard facepalms.

You missed the point of the question, sheesh.
Then clarify the point of the question. Are we not discussing how liberal UK is vs Egypt or Saudi Arabia regarding interfaith marriage? Then knowing the % of UK folks who are comfortable with interfaith marriage is needed for a comparative analysis.
 

Mohsen

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
I remember that passage from the Qu'ran [admittedly because it is literally on page 2 and I haven't read the whole Qu'ran :oops: ] and I know what its getting at. I have experienced the sort of wall of pseudo-responses, where people are merely repeating half-remembered phases/excuses for not agreeing with or believing something. you get the responses that have been "programmed" and "conditioned" into people and it is very hard to get them to let their defences down and reconsider. They will stand by those positions forcefully, consistently and it makes absolutely no difference how much evidence you give them they are wrong. So the idea of "a seal has been set on their hearts and on their hearings" ..."and on their eyes a coverings" makes perfect sense to me. Its something I have grown use to on RF and am guilty of when I have feigned greater knowledge about a subject than I actually have. That has proven to be a strange benefit of being on RF as you quickly learn how we deceive ourselves if we are receptive to it.

Sadly, you are right that if people want to learn about Islam they will do it offline. It underlines a certain futility of participating in internet forums especially if we want to be understood, valued and to share our experiences. Putting Islamic theology aside for a moment (as I am in no position to tell a Muslim what to believe or think) my concern is really with the futility and defeatism of not fighting back. Truth and knowledge are something I would want to be regarded as sacred as our collective inheritance that transcends our individual selves. For someone to lie and to deliberately manipulate people is clearly wrong and is an attack on knowledge as our common property. What we typically deal with- both for Islam and other subjects- are generally not the deceivers and the manipulators, but the victims of the deception who believe the lie. I guess it is purely an emotional thing to want to believe that the truth will win and that "natural justice" will flow from that. Of course, its not that simple as the deceived often derive great satisfaction from the lie by believing they are superior to others even if their self-worth is fabricated.

WOW... I'm genuinely speechless and truly warmed by your post. Thank you for understanding, it means more to me than I can rightfully express in words. I believe I will be reading this post of yours in my quiet moments so I can maybe learn what it is to be such an altruist. And I do mean that in the best of ways. God bless you Laika, you have made my day!

You are probably aware of this site, but I thought it was worth sharing anyway if it makes your life any bit easier. :D
Muslims Condemn

Truthfully, I had no idea about this site.


God bless you,
 

columbus

yawn <ignore> yawn
. So I'm curious and wanted to discuss/debate some of the personal issues some people have regarding Islam.
It occurs to me that I should point something out here. I don't dislike Islam simply because it's exotic. Nor do I dislike it because of it's obvious roots as a tool of conquest. Judaism and Christianity both have that all over them as well.
I have problems with religion in general, but Abrahamic in particular.

Partly because they are so dominant in my western world. But mainly because of much of the deleterious teachings and attitudes and cultures they support. From the "invincible ignorance" to the overbearing belief that one is smarter and better than everyone else who don't understand God as well as you do to dragging primitive science and ethics into the modern world. Lots of things.

Now, none of this is unique to Islam. Plenty of Christians are similar and some Jews. But most of that was burned out of Judaism by centuries of dispersion. Christianity largely had it's fangs pulled by the Enlightenment and subsequent improvement to science and ethics and governance.

It seems to me that Islam is more impervious to this sort of improvement. The teaching that one single book, from an ancient time in an ancient language, is all a person really needs to know and anything not found in it is "innovation" , like democracy and gender rights, is the fundamental problem. It results in an Islamic culture that isn't good for the adherents or the rest of the human family.
This has little to do with the news from the last couple of decades, nor from ignorance. It's my take on the big picture of Islam and how it relates to the modern world.
Tom
 

Mohsen

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Then clarify the point of the question. Are we not discussing how liberal UK is vs Egypt or Saudi Arabia regarding interfaith marriage? Then knowing the % of UK folks who are comfortable with interfaith marriage is needed for a comparative analysis.
The UK is not a Christian nation...not anymore, try Vatican city. That's a great starting point, and move from there. The point I was aiming to get through to you is obvious, but if you can't see it - then you must be illogically blinded by your own bias. And I wouldn't be able to help you,

Peace
 

sayak83

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
The UK is not a Christian nation...not anymore, try Vatican city. That's a great starting point, and move from there. The point I was aiming to get through to you is obvious, but if you can't see it - then you must be illogically blinded by your own bias. And I wouldn't be able to help you,

Peace
No I can't see it.
Did I say anywhere I liked the Catholic beurocracy or evangelical fundamentalist Christianity? Pots and Kettles.
 

Mohsen

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
No I can't see it.
Did I say anywhere I liked the Catholic beurocracy or evangelical fundamentalist Christianity? Pots and Kettles.
that's exactly my point - you presented a kettle, by calling it black, but the voice you gave it was a Christian one - the pot was hiding itself.

I just bought it out of hiding.

And now, you are beginning to see it!

peace
 

sayak83

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
that's exactly my point - you presented a kettle, by calling it black, but the voice you gave it was a Christian one - the pot was hiding itself.

I just bought it out of hiding.

And now, you are beginning to see it!

peace
Hold on right there. Hindu Indian here. Christian views have about zero effect on me.
Your defense of Islam is that its as bad as fundamentalist Christianity? Weak broth there bro.
 

Mohsen

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Hold on right there. Hindu Indian here. Christian views have about zero effect on me.
Your defense of Islam is that its as bad as fundamentalist Christianity? Weak broth there bro.

Oh you really wanna go there as an Indian Hindu?

You can't even marry outside of your caste lol.

Brahmin, marries Brahmin
Kshatriya marries Kshatriya
Vaishya marries Vaishya and
Shudya marries Shudya.

Pot calling kettle blacker than itself? Kaalimaa? mujhe bheja dey, meri khopri mai kuch screw loose hai LOL stay in your lane. :D
 
Last edited:

FearGod

Freedom Of Mind
I heard somewhere that the Islamic religion is "more about obedience than love".
I'd like to think that Christianity is the opposite.More about love than obedience. But I've met some Christians who tend to emphasise obedience over love. as well. Guess they are interconnected, or interdependent. But love comes first in my book even if that means not obeying some scripture verses.

Who loves whom and who obeys whom? what do you mean by love and obedience, and why one is good and the other is bad towards the creator of the universe?
 

Mohsen

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Oh you really wanna go there as an Indian Hindu?

You can't even marry outside of your caste lol.

Brahmin, marries Brahmin
Kshatriya marries Kshatriya
Vaishya marries Vaishya and
Shudya marries Shudya.

Pot calling kettle blacker than itself? Kaalimaa? mujhe bheja dey, meri khopri mai kuch screw loose hai LOL stay in your lane. :D
@sayak83 you gone strangely quiet...
 
Top