• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Will you condemn “Great Replacement Theory”?

Do you condemn Great Replacement Theory? (Votes will be visible)


  • Total voters
    33

fantome profane

Anti-Woke = Anti-Justice
Premium Member
I don't have a problem with trolls. Do you?

If you meant, how has that worked out in the bigger picture, I can't say because it hasn't been tried. Racists keep getting media attention rather than ignored.
When the troll starts killing people, yes, I have a problem with that.
 

pearl

Well-Known Member
And what should we do? Should politicians who promote white replacements theory be voted out of office? Should pundits who promote it be called out and criticized? Should there be protests?

Police say a white 18-year-old gunman livestreamed his attack on a Tops store in Buffalo, killing 10 and injuring three others. The suspect posted a so-called manifesto online detailing his plan to target a Black community and discussing his white supremacist ideology. The suspect wrote that he was motivated by the "Great Replacement" theory boosted by Republican lawmakers and Fox News hosts like Tucker Carlson, arguing that immigration is being used to replace and diminish the influence of white people.
Liz Cheney calls out GOP leaders for enabling “white supremacy” after Buffalo shooting (msn.com)
 

Stevicus

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
Buffalo shooting puts spotlight on GOP and Great Replacement Theory


It is time now for everyone to clearly and publicly denounce this dangerous rhetoric. Some of you may feel this is obvious and should “go without saying”, but the time for that is over. Some may not understand, it is time to get educated. Some of you might just want to be obstinate because you think this is “political”, the time for that nonsense is over.

Please vote in the poll.

Of course, I condemn it without reservation. But as noted by some posters, that may not be enough, in and of itself.

I've heard it said that the best way to fight an idea is with another idea. I think we were heading in the right direction when the Civil Rights Movement was in full swing, but I think where things started to go awry was around the late 80s/early 90s when the narrative started to change.

I mentioned in another thread earlier this morning that one of the early promoters of white nationalism back in those days was Geraldo Rivera. Once the racists made the talk show circuit, which was ostensibly to ridicule, mock, and make them look like a bunch of circus freaks, that's when we started heading in the wrong direction, which has brought us to where we are now. I knew then that it would eventually come to no good.

I saw it in the 1990s, with Ruby Ridge and the OKC bombing, the rise of the militia movement which is still around today. They also took to the internet. Around the same time, I attended a conference where they showed a short film called "The Color of Fear," which showed some men of different races discussing race, which I thought was quite moving and eye-opening for me at the time. At the time, I thought that if we could have more of these kinds of discussions in society, we might be able to head back in a more positive direction.

I tried to look for it, to see if I could find it posted somewhere, but it seems it's only available through this site: The Color of Fear (Part 1) (diversitytrainingfilms.com)

But of course, they can't just post it. Someone has to make money from it ($15 for a 24-hour rental), which sort of reveals where a large part of problem has been.
 

KW

Well-Known Member
Buffalo shooting puts spotlight on GOP and Great Replacement Theory


It is time now for everyone to clearly and publicly denounce this dangerous rhetoric. Some of you may feel this is obvious and should “go without saying”, but the time for that is over. Some may not understand, it is time to get educated. Some of you might just want to be obstinate because you think this is “political”, the time for that nonsense is over.

Please vote in the poll.


What is this theory?

Was it made up by leftists?
 

KW

Well-Known Member
Buffalo shooting puts spotlight on GOP and Great Replacement Theory


It is time now for everyone to clearly and publicly denounce this dangerous rhetoric. Some of you may feel this is obvious and should “go without saying”, but the time for that is over. Some may not understand, it is time to get educated. Some of you might just want to be obstinate because you think this is “political”, the time for that nonsense is over.

Please vote in the poll.


This killer was a leftist who hated Fox News.

Leftism is dangerous. Is that your point?
 

KW

Well-Known Member
I see - refuse to admit that your side has evil in it. Those who associate themselves with evil are tainted by it. Tucker Carlson for one is a promoter of that evil.

Your lies are boring and pointless. Feel free to debate with facts.
 

fantome profane

Anti-Woke = Anti-Justice
Premium Member
White supremacy is bad. Violent white supremacy is very bad. Few people will disagree with that.

That doesn't clarify what you mean by GRT though.

Opposition to excessive immigration is often because of cultural differences, not 'racial' differences. Is this GRT?

On the other hand, I've seen people complain about white people moving into traditionally minority areas and resulting gentrification. Is this GRT as it is a racial preference?
What “cultural differences” are you talking about? I have been told that I am misunderstanding your point.

To me, bigotry is bigotry. There is no difference if you are upset about someone moving into your neighbourhood because they are black, or your are upset because they speak with an accent, or follow a different religion. Same thing.

You understand I didn’t invent great replacement theory. If you want to understand it listen to those who promote it. Listen to what they are saying and look a what they are doing.
 

Brian2

Veteran Member
Buffalo shooting puts spotlight on GOP and Great Replacement Theory


It is time now for everyone to clearly and publicly denounce this dangerous rhetoric. Some of you may feel this is obvious and should “go without saying”, but the time for that is over. Some may not understand, it is time to get educated. Some of you might just want to be obstinate because you think this is “political”, the time for that nonsense is over.

Please vote in the poll.

The displaying of the Nazi swaztika in public has been banned in Victoria Australia.
People who want to come to Australia to preach on such ideologies have been refused entry.
 

fantome profane

Anti-Woke = Anti-Justice
Premium Member
Here's one. It's easy to google:

In parts of the manifesto, he claimed he was an “authoritarian left-wing[er],” said he hated Christianity and also said he was interested in “green nationalism.”

Confirmed: Buffalo Killer Wasn't Conservative, Also Despised Fox News, Greg Gutfeld, Ben Shapiro, Rupert Murdoch (westernjournal.com)
It doesn’t matter if this is a leftist white suprematist or a right wing white suprematist. Will you right now condemn white supremacy? Left right or middle.
 
Top