Subhan Allah.
Ali rady-Allah-anho is from Ahl-Albyt Prophet's family, he's one of the best 4 khalifa s in Islam, he's one of the 10 whom prophet Mohamed told them that they'll be in paradise, he's the first youth believed in Islam, he's the husband of Mohamed's daughter.
But has neither divine...
This is not they way we Sunni use to proof something in Islam.
Our way is that anything we say should have a from clear proof Quran or Hadeeth can be understood using Arabic language.
You jump to conclusions without Arabic language basis. You're acting like Christians who believe that the...
My friend don't mix representative with ruler.
There is no representative for Allah on Earth. God's representative is in Christianity not on Islam
Even prophet mohamed is not Allah's representative.
Also Hadeeth doesn't say "follow him" Hadeeth said "bayooh" accept/elect his a leader.
Revelation is for only Prophets and Messangers.
Your thoughts about almahdy has a message has no basis in neither Quran nor Hadeeth.
It's jus thoughts which are not true.
Not right. Totally wrong.
I'm khalifatullah. You're khalifatullah.
Almahdy judge no one.
Almahdy leads Moslems Not judge them.
It's not about denial or acceptance like Prophets.
Moslems will need a leader, moslems will select him. All Moslems will want/agree on his leadership.
He's one of us...
I've translated already review between quotes "---"
The verse translation is " Dawood, we've (Allah speaks" appointed you as khalifa on Earth"
For your info, Adam and all his descendents are meant to be khalifa on Earth.
Look, your way of exaggerating in Almahdy personality is very strange...
This Hadeeth is simple has no weight in your case.
Prophet Mohamed Said "If you see Almahdy, follow him. Allah appointed him as your leader"
Yes we Moslems should follow him and appoint him as leader.
What's the point ?
You're answering yourself my friend
In the beginning you said "guide (Al-Hadi) " ended saying " Imam Mahdi is described in Quran"
The difference is huge between guide and guided. ---- pure English.
Do you understand that "guide Alhady" is totally different from "guided Almahdy" ?
Think in...
Noway my friend.
Totally wrong from Arabic perspective and Quran study perspective.
Here is an example
Alrahman:55 "
There will be sent upon you a flame of fire and smoke, and you will not defend yourselves."
The word يرسل send means to send something, sometimes its connected to messangers.
I...
You came late my friend. Looks like you didn't read my previous posts.
Ok nope.
Bahaa,. Bab, Ahmady, Shiia, and so forth are misguided by wrong translation.
You're an obvious live example.
All above verses are describing "Alhady" man who guide people Prophets، Messangers, and good people.
This...
Are you native Arabic speaker ?
Are you speaking Arabic fluency?
With respect to you and to Sunni professor.
This is severely wrong Arabic language explanation of the word Elmahdy
There is a Hadeeth that Allah will guide him from a non-good Islam practicing to an excellent practicing Moslem in...
Allah directs (better even that guide) us all to do good.
Elmahdi is someone like Salah Eldeen who lead moslems to free Alaqsa from crossaid. He's like Sultan Qutoz who lead Moslems against Mongols.
He'll be the leader of Moslems in last days wars. That's all.
I didn't mean you're trying to persuade me or others.
I mean these wrong translations and assptions are not logically true, so moslems don't accept
Peace be with you too my friend.
My friend your words up there "the name Mahdi itself means he is guided and a guide."
The word Elmahdy can't by any means translated as "a guide".
You can consult any Arabic student.
A guide is Alhady الهادى
You can see my friend that you've been mislead, using wrong assumption.
Totally wrong...
I d
Even the translator is native Arabic speaker, the translation is wrong.
At the end of the day these claims don't persuade a Moslem. May be a few who are not well educated.
IBab, or Bahaa, or Ahmady, or so ever have built their thoughts on a fragile basis.
It can be noticed, majority of...