Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
I am not responsible for what you read into my statements.
alceste said:The "subject" of atheism is not "God". It's all the gods. It's not specifically the god of Abrahamic monotheism atheists don't believe in, it's every god and goddess humanity has ever come up with, and usually a host of angels, demons and spirit guides into the bargain. Whatever invisible entities anybody believes are interfering with our earthly lives, for better or worse, atheists do not believe in them.
I can't study all of the supernatural beings I don't believe in - it would take my whole life. Besides, no matter how hard I try there will always be some obscure dryad in some godforsaken jungle manipulating the fortunes of some tribe I've never even heard of, and I'll be back to square one.
storm said:Why did you assume she meant the Abrahamic God, Alceste?
It's not. The strawman is an argument. That's no more a strawman than this is:That's a straw man.
It sounds to me like you've fallen for the Christian trick of pretending atheism is all about them, and their god, but I can assure you Yahweh has no special significance for people who don't believe in anybody's gods.
Thats not a strawman.That's a straw man. It was a short-lived deviation from the subject matter, though, and a properly frustrating straw man has to be persistent IMO, so it wasn't such a bad one.
Exactly what is it you are not believing in? What is "God"?
Thats not a strawman.
It is merely an off topic question.
Fair enough, but you had as much a hand in the off topic discussion.Fair enough, but it actually did carry on from that point with more of the same in place of a rebuttal...
As an atheist, myself, I have no problem understanding various reasons why someone might be an atheist. That's not what this thread is for, though. An "exact defintion" is not what is called for in the OP --what is asked (of those atheists who define their atheism as "not believing in God") is "What is it you're not believing in?"I do not understand why Willamena wants to know the exact definition of what a God/ god/goddess is from those who do dot believe in such entities. Maybe she believes that by getting an Atheist to describe that in which they do not believe in, she can get a better understanding of why. Maybe that should have been the question in the first place.
Then why does the term "god" not work for you?An "exact defintion" is not what is called for in the OP --what is asked (of those atheists who define their atheism as "not believing in God") is "What is it you're not believing in?"
As I said earlier, I'm asking for their interpretation upon which they base their disbelief. Naturally, the question isn't for all atheists.Then why does the term "god" not work for you?
Seems that you are in fact asking for a more specific definition of the term "god" from them.
But surely if Joe is not believing in Martians, there is something he is not believing in? It could be an idea considered fallacious or mistaken. It could be a claim others have made for which its validity doesn't sit well.Sorry, just seems circuitous to me. As in....
Joe "I do not believe in Martians"
Steve " So Joe, describe to me these Martians you do not believe in."
Joe "But, I don't believe in Martians"
Steve "Describe them to me."
Joe "Huh!!!"
But surely if Joe is not believing in Martians, there is something he is not believing in? It could be an idea considered fallacious or mistaken. It could be a claim others have made for which its validity doesn't sit well.
What is a "Martian"?
the dictionary said:
- S: (n) God, Supreme Being (the supernatural being conceived as the perfect and omnipotent and omniscient originator and ruler of the universe; the object of worship in monotheistic religions)
- S: (n) deity, divinity, god, immortal (any supernatural being worshipped as controlling some part of the world or some aspect of life or who is the personification of a force)
S: (n) Martian (imaginary people who live on the planet Mars)
:bow:You know, you could always give some definitions and I'd be happy to tell you which of them I don't believe in. Otherwise I'm stuck with the dictionary:
I am a theist and I also do not believe in either of those definitions of "god".You know, you could always give some definitions and I'd be happy to tell you which of them I don't believe in. Otherwise I'm stuck with the dictionary:
I am a theist and I also do not believe in either of those definitions of "god".
That's the worst dictionary I've ever seen. (*hugs her Webster's*)You know, you could always give some definitions and I'd be happy to tell you which of them I don't believe in. Otherwise I'm stuck with the dictionary: