From
Considering becoming Noahide | Religious Forums
I've been tagged and I thought I may as well just answer anyone's questions in a dedicated thread.
Many questions and little time to write them down (because I am going to bed in a couple of hours.) Take your time answering, or skip if you'd rather.
Does it seem to you (as it does to me) that calling oneself a 'Noachide' implies that Noah is one's ancestor in a very familial and familiar sense? I mean isn't it like saying that all Noachides are in a special family as opposed to those who don't keep with Noachide laws? Does it not also imply that Noachide men should be like Noah, men of the soil, farmers?
Genesis 9:17 in most bibles seems to say that the rainbow is the 'Sign' of the covenant. What the heck does that non English usage mean? A sign? A sign is something that directs you upon a road, tells you what is behind a door, warns you about traffic etc. It makes no sense to say 'Sign of the covenant'. How do you make sense of this phrase?
Does calling one's self a Noachide make one into a 'Not really a Jew' sort of like a knock off shoe? The reason I ask is that the entire religion seems to be defined and constructed in the writings of another. It appears that a Noachide has no claim to interpret their own scripture.
So...Noah is a righteous man compared to killers, but he's got issues when it comes to his own family. He condemns one brother (Ham) to have no inheritance, no tents of his own. Are we to believe that Noah's decision is a wise one? What can we learn from this decision? Is it a foolish decision? What is the result of making Ham live in the tents of others? Does this remind you of a Noachide living by using the scripture and interpretation of the Jews?
Why does Noah have a drinking problem? Does he have any responsibility for his mistake -- the one that he punishes Ham for revealing? Does the scripture or any commentary state that Noah did or should have learned from the experience? Does he ever get over his drinking? Does Ham truly deserve to be tentless?