The Catholic Church tried removal of pedophile priests.I would bring everyone involved into court and flip a coin.
Heads:
Allow the victim to decide the fate of their rapist(s)
Tails:
Banish the rapist to some foreign country, to give them a chance to choose how to move forward with their life, for better or worse
They just committed the same crimes elsewhere.
One shouldn't take out the trash, only to dump it in the neighbor's yard.