• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Being Skinny is NOT OKAY...Deal with it!

beenherebeforeagain

Rogue Animist
Premium Member
Your entire post is passing the buck, can't say I am surprised that you are doing it again instead of answering the question/challenge. But here, this will get you started.

http://lmgtfy.com/?q=strategies+to+beat+obesity

Enjoy the rest of your thread.
Great! And just as soon as Congress and the States actually start devoting the resources necessary to help implement these strategies, we ought to see some results...until then, it's almost entirely up to the individual to fight against all the influences that may be making them overweight...so let's continue to blame them if they aren't succeeding...

By the way, obesity has always existed, and always will exist. The causes are still there, even if these strategies are fully and effectively implemented and help reduce the rates at which it occurs...
 

illykitty

RF's pet cat
The reason being is that many vegetables have a very low calorie count per ounce of food.


I don't buy it. There certainly is a level of experimentation to figure out what will and will not work for you. But, in the end if it is a genuine goal of an individual, they will make it happen.


That is an extreme limitation unless the person in question is naturally very small. There are fads out there that are not effective, it does not make the task at hand impossible.


Correct and if someone is unwilling to make that effort because of inconvenience or lack of drive you might call them... lazy. At least, I do. Remember, a simple definition of lazy is the unwillingness to work for something. Yes, there are other factors, but they can be overcome. It will be tough, no one is saying it is easy. Anyone can find 1000 reasons to not do something. But it really does boil down to one simple question: how important is this to me? If it isn't that important, fine. Give up, quit. Otherwise, saddle up and be willing to be uncomfortable for a while, in the mean time sacrifices for better health need to be made. I refuse to justify unhealthy habits because it's hard. Cowards whine about how hard it is to do something before they give up and if you find yourself in this situation you need to look in the mirror and say "That's not me, I am BETTER than that!"

Yes vegetables are less calorie dense, but some plant foods are higher than veggies (which I don't solely eat) like fruits, carbs, nuts and seeds, but I'm sure I'm eating more calories than I previously did. Also a lot of high carb plant-based people on YouTube, for example, promote eating at least 2000 calories. So even if plants contain less calories, technically speaking, someone is not necessarily eating less of it if they increase the amount (bulk) that they eat. It's also important for getting all nutrients, for good health.

1200 may be extreme limitation to you, but it's usually what the diet industry tells women to eat. We're used to hearing this as being normal. I now know better but previously I was convinced that it was the only thing I could do to lose weight.

No, this is where we're not going to agree. I have previously said that people close to me, and myself included, have yo-yo'd tremendously doing what is commonly said for losing weight. There's a phenomena that some people call metabolic damage, which if someone restricts calories too much and/or exercise too much, they cause damage to their metabolism. Look up a study done on The Biggest Looser contestants. One of the men, after having done it, has gained all of his weight back plus more and now, to MAINTAIN his weight, he has to eat a stupidly low 800 calories. His metabolism has been completely messed up.

So no, it's not always down to laziness, some people have damaged metabolism due to bad advice on how to lose weight, have a terrible environment and can't make heads or tails on how to sustain a healthy lifestyle. There's too much garbage advice out there. I don't solely blame the individual. It's wrong to say all fat people are lazy.
 

Ultimatum

Classical Liberal
Especially since the research shows that genetics and environmental factors are very important for both overweight AND underweight people.

For the extreme minority of people who can do nothing about their weight, like those with Cohen syndrome or certain allelic shuffles, there is no one with a scintilla of brain matter that would lay blame at them for being lazy.

But for the rest of the landwhales who use historical premise or self-congratulation, they should be launched at with information about obesity. Why would you want to be fat? Why would you put your body under conditions that are terrible physiologically?--for the spine is already ruined in the modern era. Why are you proud to be obese? Why do you want to die earlier?
 

beenherebeforeagain

Rogue Animist
Premium Member
For the extreme minority of people who can do nothing about their weight, like those with Cohen syndrome or certain allelic shuffles, there is no one with a scintilla of brain matter that would lay blame at them for being lazy.

But for the rest of the landwhales who use historical premise or self-congratulation, they should be launched at with information about obesity. Why would you want to be fat? Why would you put your body under conditions that are terrible physiologically?--for the spine is already ruined in the modern era. Why are you proud to be obese? Why do you want to die earlier?
And you know which are suffering from a disease, from genetic issues, from environmental factors, from social factors, and which ones are just plain lazy exactly how?:rolleyes:
 

Aštra’el

Aštara, Blade of Aštoreth
yudCd.jpg


What would you rather have in your body?

overweightvsnormalweight.jpg

i_vs_533040978d72f.jpg

9556754b84f32804389462be1149eee6.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:

idav

Being
Premium Member
Sorry for the posting bait, but I think some equal time is called for...

Some could say that there's no reason for anyone to be skinny (no matter what your genetics do with your metabolism). It's just a lifestyle choice. Especially if you suffer from negative self-image, anorexia, bulimia, or are hyperthyroid, or are too poor to afford enough food and/or only have access to high starch, high sugar, high fat foods, and go to sleep hungry most every night. You should just exercise less and eat more, because it's just a balance between calories in and calories out.

Okay, how does this sound, compared to "Being Fat is NOT OKAY?"

Especially since the research shows that genetics and environmental factors are very important for both overweight AND underweight people.
Yeah I get flack for being skinny cause its is out of the norm.
 

Kapalika

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
I think people use the term "fat shamming" and "thin shamming" to get around the fact that too many people are unhealthy due to habits and lifestyle choices.

Really, it disgusts me. You can give legit advice and be told you are "shamming" when just pointing out the obvious. How long before we tell doctors they are "fat shaming" to their obese patients who need to go out more and cut out soda pop and snacks? Or they need to stop throwing up and actually eat some more protein and food?
 

Kapalika

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
Because anorexia nervosa and bulimia are totally as simple as that to treat. :facepalm:

I was making an overly simplified example; clearly it's not so simple because it's psychological, but my point still stands that people sometimes take the idea of not wanting to shame people too far at times. I don't think a doctor can simply tell someone to eat more and it's magically fixed, but admitting there is a problem (if there really is one) is always the first step. I'm just saying there is an extreme to this is all, and unfortunately I've in the last few years seen some people hide behind fat/thin acceptance to avoid the fact that they are unhealthy and it's hurting them.

That isn't to say that other people don't take it too far; many people hide behind the idea of promoting health to really just hate on thin or fat people. It's like the concern trolls who claim they are "helping" fat people by harassing them and mocking them. So it cut both ways.

I just kind of think this subject is really touchy as there are many people on both sides who hide between ideas to either be okay with their unhealthy weight or harass and bully others for their weight. I don't think we should bully people or make them feel like less of people, but we also shouldn't lie to them and tell them that their weight is healthy if it really is impacting their health.

I'm sorry I didn't mean to offend you or anyone :s

edit: I think the reason I framed it how I did is because those who tend to be quick to accuse others of fat shamming are more on the side of mainstream acceptance than those who hide behind the idea of "helping" to just bully.
 

Penumbra

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Sorry for the posting bait, but I think some equal time is called for...

Some could say that there's no reason for anyone to be skinny (no matter what your genetics do with your metabolism). It's just a lifestyle choice. Especially if you suffer from negative self-image, anorexia, bulimia, or are hyperthyroid, or are too poor to afford enough food and/or only have access to high starch, high sugar, high fat foods, and go to sleep hungry most every night. You should just exercise less and eat more, because it's just a balance between calories in and calories out.

Okay, how does this sound, compared to "Being Fat is NOT OKAY?"

Especially since the research shows that genetics and environmental factors are very important for both overweight AND underweight people.
Genetics play a large role in how bodies respond to environmental impact (especially food, but also toxins and exercise and such), but genetics very rarely make someone unhealthily fat or skinny without an environmental catalyst.

This dramatic change in one generation was not from changing genetics:

Obesity_state_level_estimates_1985-2010.gif


(Nor was it from a mass-bodybuilding craze, for those that would point out that bmi is misleading.)

It was from changes in diet, for the most part.

Being thin is usually healthy unless a person has an eating disorder, or is skinny from some extreme thing like cancer, or if they live in the arctic, or if they have a reasonable chance of facing a famine in the near future. I've been self-conscious about being skinny for much of my life (my bmi is about 18, even with a lot of muscle tone and strength), but I accept that it's just where my body chooses to be when I eat as much whole, real food as I want. When I was younger and I drank a lot of sugar and ate an unhealthy diet, I didn't gain weight, but instead got excessive cavities and felt bad. Rather than having genes leading to weight gain, I likely have genes related to mineral issues in enamel. A change in diet has largely addressed that. Other people have genes that are more likely to manifest as obesity and related disorders.

Obesity, and in particular excess body fat around the abdomen, is strongly associated with disease, and usually only manifests due to a problem of some variety, rather than being one of the healthy, naturally-occurring body types. (In contrast, being big-boned or voluptuous due to a variety between ethnicities can still be quite healthy, in some cases even healthier than being thin, since the fat is not from metabolic disorder and is not placed around the abdomen). The global epidemic of diabetes and obesity is a complicated mix of economics (poor people have trouble affording healthy food), corporate interests (they influence government nutritional guidelines and even things like doctors' diabetes associations, they market to children, they put soda and Pizza Hut in schools), governments promoting incorrect and outdated nutritional science, people eating out and eating processed foods rather than cooking and eating whole foods, dramatic rises in sugar intake, etc.
 
Top