Subduction Zone
Veteran Member
You first error was in saying "there is no such thing as simple life". There is no simple life today. That is what you should have said. But even the simplest of life has a three and a half billion years of evolution behind it. The simplest of life can no longer compete.At a fundamental level, both are about the emergence of the living from the nonliving. One is proven false and the other was never proven true.
Spontaneous generation is about the emergence of complex life through a quick process. Aabiogenesis is about the emergence of a hypothesized simple life through an extremely slow process.
Now we know for a fact that there is no such thing as simple life, and we also know that there is no such thing as nonliving organic molecules that keep increasing in complexity slowly over a long period of time, without getting decomposed /disintegrated.
You think that the claim of slow/gradual process of abiogenesis is mainly what makes it possible/logical and ignore the undeniable fact that time is the enemy of such imagined slow process. No simple organic molecule of any kind would stay intact/persist for millions of years waiting to get more complex or for a chance to transform into macromolecules (such as proteins and nucleic acids). It will always disintegrate very quickly, always. Even if hypothetically speaking a simple nonliving organic molecule managed to transform into a complex macromolecule through some unknown means, it would quickly disintegrate (within few weeks) without any chance to increase further in complexity.
There is no route from nonliving matter to complex living system. That is why abiogenesis was never established as a scientific theory.
And your next mistake was to once again use today's environment. Prebiotic Earth was quite different. There was no molecular oxygen for example.
And you need to support your claims with recent papers about "tine being the enemy" The experts in the field that study this do not seem to think that this is the case. That is only unsupported claims by creationists.