Do you think infinite space is cyclic or has always existed?

[Jimmy]

.

 

[ChristineM]

Yes

 

[ChristineM]

Yes what

Impossible question to answer.

By infinite space, if you mean the everything, including other universes if they exist and whatever else there is out there. In that case i guess space has always existed.

If you mean this universe alone, some cosmologists conjecture that the universe creates its own space to expand into.

Some cosmologists consider the universe to be cyclic. Expanding and collapsing in on itself to start again.

Adding these two scenarios can mean space is cyclic

So takes ya choice

 

[Jimmy]

Impossible question to answer.

By infinite space, if you mean the everything, including other universes if they exist and whatever else there is out there. In that case i guess space has always existed.

If you mean this universe alone, some cosmologists conjecture that the universe creates its own space to expand into.

Some cosmologists consider the universe to be cyclic. Expanding and collapsing in on itself to start again.

Adding these two scenarios can mean space is cyclic

So takes ya choice

When I say infinite space I mean just that. If I meant universe, I would’ve said universe and if I meant finite universe, I would’ve said finite universe.

 

[ChristineM]

And if I meant finite universe, I would’ve said finite universe.

In past discussions i think you've confused the 2, so i don't really know what you mean

When I say infinite space I mean just that. If I meant universe, I would’ve said universe.

In that case take my first option.

 

[Jimmy]

In past discussions i think you've confused the 2, so i don't really know what you mean



In that case take my first option.

Nope, never confused the two ideas of an infinite universe and a finite universe.

 

[Jimmy]

In past discussions i think you've confused the 2, so i don't really know what you mean



In that case take my first option.

Actually infinite universe means the same as infinite space to me, but I chose infinite space because when I use the word universe, some people here get confused because not all people think the universe is infinite.

 

[Jimmy]

In past discussions i think you've confused the 2, so i don't really know what you mean



In that case take my first option.

Cast a vote

 

[SalixIncendium]

No.

 

[Jimmy]

No.

No what

 

[ChristineM]

Nope, never confused the two ideas of an infinite universe and a finite universe.

You have often said the universe is infinite. To see you now say its finite is confusing

 

[ChristineM]

Actually infinite universe means the same as infinite space to me, but I chose infinite space because when I use the word universe, some people here get confused because not all people think the universe is infinite.

See what i mean

 

[SalixIncendium]

No what

I don't think infinite space is cyclical or has always existed.

 

[ChristineM]

Cast a vote

No, you asked what i think, not what you think
I don't know so no vote

 

[Jimmy]

You have often said the universe is infinite. To see you now say its finite is confusing

Yeah, I’ve never said it was finite. I’m pointing out that other people think that.

 

[Jimmy]

See what i mean

See what I mean what? I don’t use the word universe here because some people think the universe is infinite and some think it’s finite so I just cut it to chase and say infinite space

 

[ChristineM]

Yeah, I’ve never said it was fine night. I’m pointing out that other people think that.

Mm, ok

 

[Jimmy]

No, you asked what i think, not what you think
I don't know so no vote

I think the universe is infinite and I call it infinite space when I talk about it here to avoid confusion.

 

[Jimmy]

No, you asked what i think, not what you think
I don't know so no vote

No worries as you already told me this earlier.

You said By infinite space, if you mean the everything, including other universes if they exist and whatever else there is out there. In that case i guess space has always existed.

 

[Jimmy]

I don't think infinite space is cyclical or has always existed.

So what do you think?