I'd go with Hinduism. Hinduism and Heathenism both developed from essentially the same culture and worldview, share similar mythologies and deities, values and beliefs. I actually looked into Hinduism, but decided that it was pretty much an cultural religion, like heathenism; and as my ancestors were Anglo-Saxon/Germanic, Heathenism just seems an easier fit. I must say though, that I have always been impressed with Mormons and while I don't know if I could ever really buy into the dogmas, they do share my values and passions and I'd love to worship the divine with people like that. So, I'll go with either Hinduism or Mormonism.