Do whatever you like. But if you and I are standing side by side (traveling the same speed) it is impossible for you to see a ship traveling at a different velocity than me.....
You know that, I know that, everyone knows that....
Only if you are traveling at a different velocity than I am can you ever see the ship traveling at a different speed than I do.....
You know that, I know that, everyone knows that.....
Deny it to your hearts content because you don't want to accept the simple science of reality.....
no it's not.
The first postulate is that the laws of physics will be the same in all initial frames.
The second postulate of SR is that all frames will see light travel at c regardless of your velocity.
You just don't know why this is so.... and so you don't know why the first postulate is so as well....
SR then predicts from those two postulates that you can not deduce your own velocity from your devices or from observation. You can easily deduce your velocity relative to two other observers, not one, but a minimum of two. This does not mean you can deduce your absolute velocity from those other two, because you can not deduce the absolute velocity of any object in space.....
But you fail to understand why the first two postulates hold true regardless of the motion of the frame as long as it is constant, because you don't have the faintest clue as to why light always travels at c regardless of each frames velocity... Not the faintest clue.... and you never will because your holy priests can't tell you and their box prohibits them from deducing the correct answer....
Only in your fantasy world where acceleration doesn't cause changes to clocks, even if it an experimental fact.....
Triplet A is the only one that is relevant. His clocks don't change.... He correctly sees the rate of change of both B and C. Neither B nor C can correctly deduce their own velocity (or have you forgot you just argued that) nor can they even see the change in their own clocks.... Their opinion is useless....
No, you just don't understand the subject in the slightest...
Time dilation - Wikipedia
"either due to a
velocity difference relative to each other, or by being differently situated relative to a gravitational field."
Einstein deduced that gravity was the same as acceleration, hence clocks slow in a gravitational well.... because they have energy added which offsets the rate of decay, just as an accelerating rocket has energy added which offsets the rate of decay.
But then that's why you never give your reason, because you don't have one.....
Agreed, you can say that as many times as you like and the only reason you and I will ever see a spacecraft moving at different velocities is if we are ourselves moving at different velocities... You'll still be wrong no matter how many times you make claims without being able to justify them. But that's because you can't, so all you can do is claim the other person wrong....
yes you did, but then that's why you just keep making claims of incorrectness while being unable to show it is incorrect.....
Standard tactic when one has lost the battle..... knows it and knows he has no scientific response to give.....
I'll state the truth again.....
If the ships clock (for analogy purposes) slowed 1 year compared to yours and 6 months compared to mine, that would just mean both the ships clock and my clock run slower than yours because I’m moving faster than you too..... and the ships clock runs slower than mine because he’s moving faster than me.... as you would see his clock 1 year slower and my clock 6 months slower as I see his clock 6 months slower. He’s moving approximately twice as fast as me.
There’s nothing magical about it, it’s all pure science.... your confused because you think it’s magical, it’s just the science of one moving faster than another and the other moving faster than either of those.....
Pure science, no magic involved. Magic is for those that fail to understand why light always travels at c regardless of each frames velocity.....