• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Hare Krishna Movement

groovyable

Member
Ok ive seen a few website here and there yet it just explains about, Mantras -chanting and vegetarianism. Yet who was Krishna? What was his teachings? What are the links between it and Hinduism.

It would be nice to hear from a Hare Krishna's' point of view :)

xx
 

Andal

resident hypnotist
Ok ive seen a few website here and there yet it just explains about, Mantras -chanting and vegetarianism. Yet who was Krishna? What was his teachings? What are the links between it and Hinduism.

It would be nice to hear from a Hare Krishna's' point of view :)

xx

Namaste :)

Mantra, chanting, and vegetarianism are important elements of the practice so it's no surprise that is what you found. There are a couple of members here who are members of ISKCON specifically so they may correct some points I make but here is my understanding.

Who is Krishna?

Simply put, Krishna is God. God has millions of names but Krishna, Rama, and Hare are the preferred ones of Hare Krishna movement. Krishna means the All Attractive One. Rama means Source of Pleasure and Hare is invocating the Energy of God.

Krishna is the Supreme Personality of God. He and Vishnu are one and the same. Krishna actively participates in the material world by taking birth during the different ages to help suols. He last incarnation was that of Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu in the 1500's. In that birth he brought to us the Mahamantra (Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare, Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare) This is the Dharma of this age.

Krishna also took birth as the Buddha, although this is a hotly debated topic within Vaishnav communities.

Before that Krishna took birth as Krishna about 5000 years ago. During that time he rescued people from demons, freed the kingdom of Mathura from the tyrant, Kansa. He had a role in the Mahabharata war. He gave the Bhagavad Gita to Arjuna. He showed humans how to have an appropriate relationship with God. Through his activities on earth we learn what being truly in love with God means through the Rasa Lila.

The teachings of Krishna include how we should act, how we should worship, what is moral conduct, etc Most importantly, Krishna teaches us how to be in relationship with him thus fullfilling the goal of every soul.

The relationship with Hinduism gets a little complicated. The worship and tradition of Krishna consciousness is a part of Vaishnavism (in particular Gaudiya Vaishnavism) which is branch of what is refered to as Hinduism. Within the Gaudiya tradition there are a number of different teachers and organizations, all of which could be termed Hare Krishnas. The most visible in the west is ISKCON (International Society of Krishna Consciousness) According to ISKCON founder, A.C. Bhaktivadanta Srila Prabhupada, this movement is not Hindu but beyond that. There are also some Hindus who do not accept ISKCON as Hindu although there seems to be many more who accept is as very orthodox Hinduism. Even within ISKCON there are some who will identify with Hinduism and others who won't.

I my self am a Hare Krishna, I do attend an ISKCON temple but also consider myself as a Gaudiya Vaishnav Hindu.

All of these names though are merely names and ultimately don't serve a purpose. The true purpose to developing a loving relationship with Krishna.

Hari Om :)
 

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
I don't know if you're aware, groovyable, but the "Hare Krishna's" take on Krishna isn't quite that of most Hindus. I've never understood the ISKCONi's claim that they aren't Hindu, though. Their theology is a bit eccentric, perhaps, but hardly outside the range of Vaishnavite Bhakti Yoga.
 

Andal

resident hypnotist
I don't know if you're aware, groovyable, but the "Hare Krishna's" take on Krishna isn't quite that of most Hindus. I've never understood the ISKCONi's claim that they aren't Hindu, though. Their theology is a bit eccentric, perhaps, but hardly outside the range of Vaishnavite Bhakti Yoga.

I agree that the theology fits within the parameters of Vaishnavism. Gaudiya Vaishnavism does appear a bit different compared to some other sects but my point of view is, bhakti is bhakti.

Not all Gaudiya Vaishnavas though affiliate with ISKCON or it's teachings. There are groups functioning under the auspicies of other Gaudiya teachers.

Hari Om!
 
I don't know if you're aware, groovyable, but the "Hare Krishna's" take on Krishna isn't quite that of most Hindus. I've never understood the ISKCONi's claim that they aren't Hindu, though. Their theology is a bit eccentric, perhaps, but hardly outside the range of Vaishnavite Bhakti Yoga.

Yes, in a world where compromise with claims of western materialistic "science" has become the order of the day among groups deriving from the Vedic heritage, i can understand how ISKCON's literalistic interpretation of shastra might appear "eccentric" to some.....(thank heavens we have the much more modern Europeanized jnanis to psychoanalyze us....:D).....

ys,
bmd.
 

Andal

resident hypnotist
Yes, in a world where compromise with claims of western materialistic "science" has become the order of the day among groups deriving from the Vedic heritage, i can understand how ISKCON's literalistic interpretation of shastra might appear "eccentric" to some.....(thank heavens we have the much more modern Europeanized jnanis to psychoanalyze us....:D).....

ys,
bmd.

Cheers Prabhu! :D

Hari Bol!
 

Andal

resident hypnotist
Hare Krsna, didi....:)...

Don't ya just love the all-knowing condescenscion of the impersonalists (who represent barely 10% of all Hindus)?

ys,
bmd.


Hare Krishna Prabhu! :)

I don't know what's worse, that or when I see my colleagues teaching college students this impersonalist point of view as being the core of Sanatana Dharma. :(

Hari Bol!
 

rcscwc

Member
ISKON is a Hindu mobement in the West.

They are missionary face of Hinduism.

They are rooted in Sanatana Dharma, with Krishna as the main deity.

They, in fact, are using the tactics the xian missionaries adopt elsewhere.

Xian churches, across the board, hate ISKON as the rapacious wolves, no matter they too are that.

There take on Krishna maybe a bit different, but not so radically different Krisghna looks like Christ, nor to make them non Hindus.

Of course they don't hesitate to call Krishna as Krista, but that is for mollifying the xians.
 
Last edited:

rcscwc

Member
Ok ive seen a few website here and there yet it just explains about, Mantras -chanting and vegetarianism. Yet who was Krishna? What was his teachings? What are the links between it and Hinduism.

It would be nice to hear from a Hare Krishna's' point of view :)

xx

Krishna's message is in Bhagavad Gits.
 

rcscwc

Member
thank heavens we have the much more modern Europeanized jnanis to psychoanalyze us....:D).....

...as well sermonise us about what our faith is, should be etc.
 

Devotee

Vaisnava
Hello.

This is what i believe about what some call Krishnaism or Gaudiya Vaishnava. now i dont speak for all here. But Krsna is the original, the True, the Supreme Personality of the Godhead. He is GOD. And Krsna has three main expansions, the three Vishnus. they are Maha-Vishnu. from Maha-Vishnu comes all the innumerable universes. then there is Garbhodakasayi Vishnu, who makes each universe unique, then ksirodakasayi Vishnu who is the Supersoul and the universal form or Virat Purusha. so you can think of Vishnu as an expansion of Sri Krsnas divine energy. and within each universe are the Demi-Gods or Brahma, Shiva, and the other ones. But over all Krsna is the Divine Godhead!

Thank you.
 

Nayana

Member
I would suggest reading the Bhagavad-gita!

Although, i suggest reading only the translations first, then going back and reading the entire thing. That is how i did it.
 

vishu121

New Member
hinduism is not just mantras and vegeterianism, its a way of living and dying. They all form a part of hinduism. Lord krishna came as gautam budhha that is 100% fact (to show that nirvana can be attained on this plane). But did krishna came as S.C.Mahaprabhu is doubt ( A divine soul no doubt) bcos the incarnation has a goal they dont just come to start an ashram preach people and give lectures they have a purpose to b fulfilled. A secret about incarnations - they will never die a natural death. The supreme does not write his death, an enemy kills him - he want give him that pleasure, he will always be betrayed or killed accidently by his on people, or in ancient times when the energy was more positive on earth they use to ascend straight to heaven.
 

Metempsychosis

Reincarnation of 'Anti-religion'
Yes, in a world where compromise with claims of western materialistic "science" has become the order of the day among groups deriving from the Vedic heritage, i can understand how ISKCON's literalistic interpretation of shastra might appear "eccentric" to some.....(thank heavens we have the much more modern Europeanized jnanis to psychoanalyze us....:D).....

ys,
bmd.

Prabupada creation called ISKCON is the most biased version of Hinduism ever.IMHO,Prabupada is a shame to the Great Chaitanya Mahaprabu lineage.

Prabupada is a so called Krishna Devotee with hatred towards fellow Hindus.LOL.

Throughout his book his condescension towards advaitins is amusing.At least Advaitins dont criticize about Prabupada and write them in books as commentries of Bhagavat Gita and Srimad Bhagavatham.

He says the First Indian President Jawaharlal Nehru was reborn as a dog in Sweden.:facepalm:Prabupada is drawing a self portrait by these activities.
Prabhupada And Nehru’s Incarnation | Hare Krishna Community
He quarrels like a child against Former Indian President Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan.It is quite shocking to consider him as a "Saint".

There is not surprising that some European Jnanis are pointing this out.There are many Vaishanava Indians who know what Prabupada is all about.BTW.I am not blaming the whole Gaudiya Vaishnava or its philosophy.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Madhuri

RF Goddess
Staff member
Premium Member
Prabupada creation called ISKCON is the most biased version of Hinduism ever.IMHO,Prabupada is a shame to the Great Chaitanya Mahaprabu lineage.

Prabupada is a so called Krishna Devotee with hatred towards fellow Hindus.LOL.

Throughout his book his condescension towards advaitins is amusing.At least Advaitins dont criticize about Prabupada and write them in books as commentries of Bhagavat Gita and Srimad Bhagavatham.

He says the First Indian President Jawaharlal Nehru was reborn as a dog in Sweden.:facepalm:Prabupada is drawing a self portrait by these activities.
Prabhupada And Nehru’s Incarnation | Hare Krishna Community
He quarrels like a child against Former Indian President Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan.It is quite shocking to consider him as a "Saint".

There is not surprising that some European Jnanis are pointing this out.There are many Vaishanava Indians who know what Prabupada is all about.BTW.I am not blaming the whole Gaudiya Vaishnava or its philosophy.

I was brought up in ISKON but have always had a problem with Prabhupada. It was hard to question his teachings in my family and community as he is considered to be a realised soul but...I never could buy into it. I just don't agree with many of the things he said and taught. Sometimes even really disliked what he said. Granted, it was impressive how he came to the west with next to nothing and spread his movement but and how dedicated he was to his religion and beliefs but that doesn't make him perfect by any means.
 

Metempsychosis

Reincarnation of 'Anti-religion'
I was brought up in ISKON but have always had a problem with Prabhupada. It was hard to question his teachings in my family and community as he is considered to be a realised soul but...I never could buy into it. I just don't agree with many of the things he said and taught. Sometimes even really disliked what he said. Granted, it was impressive how he came to the west with next to nothing and spread his movement but and how dedicated he was to his religion and beliefs but that doesn't make him perfect by any means.

You have taken the right decision!!We cannot believe in something just because some tradition tells us so.I agree that he has good belief in Lord Krishna. But he is calling out names of fellow philosophers in his commentary and deriding them .This is a great disservice to the scriptures themselves.He is a dust particle in front of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu.:(.There is lack of BASIC values.And this is only form of Hinduism which seeks converts and fights against evolutionists.:facepalm:.

I was not knowing about advaita when I first read his books.:eek:

You dont find non-dualists like Ramakrishna or Ramana Maharishi getting into such useless propaganda against the personalists.IMHO,Prabupada lacks spiritual realisation,
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Top