• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Heaven and hell

cbartlett16

New Member
In Christianity the concepts of heaven and hell are core beliefs. The believers of the religion are thrown into heaven, a place of eternal bliss, while the nonbelievers are throw into the fiery pits of hell to exist forever in perpetual agony. This is a vacuous concept and it entirely immoral. One can be the "best" person in the world and burn in hell due to your lack of belief in the christian god while the mass murderer, who asks forgiveness from god at the last second, can sit above you and gloat in heaven. Gullibility is the a main factor in determining your fate. After all, his believers will be forgiven all they must do is ask.

There are two options obviously, heaven and hell. That is it. You can either have bliss forever or an eternity of pain. Do you not see anything wrong with this? Then you are there forever. Nobody deserves eternal torment. Maybe a timed punishment but not forever. On the flip side no one deserves everlasting pleasure.

Now about those in heaven. It would take a twisted person to enjoy heaven. Billions will be burning below you, many for petty crimes or just non belief, while you are enjoying heaven. I mean seriously? It is amazing how many Christians don't even think about the reality of their heaven and hell. Think don't just accept.
 

Breathe

Hostis humani generis
Just ftr, a sizeable chunk of Christians don't believe in a literal "lake of fire" hell. For many, Hell is separation from God, Hell is being surrounded by God's Love for one who has not loved Him, or Hell is the grave, and some believe everyone goes to Heaven.
 

seeking4truth

Active Member
Ever heard of allegory, metaphor, symbolism?

You don't have to take every word literally.
These descriptions in religious writings are warnings, advice to help guide us to the right, beneficial path in our temporary physical life in order that we may develop spiritually in preparation for a longer life in the future.
As this life is physical, physical descriptions are given for what is spiritual. It is all we can appreciate at the moment.
Don't forget most religious teachers have taught that heaven and hell begin in this life. ie. Not only the causes of suffering and benefit are here but also a taste of the spiritual side too. eg. the peace that passes all understanding or depression.
 

Sha'irullah

رسول الآلهة
Making heaven and especially hell metaphorical ruins the fun for me. If I ever do a sin it is like doing something illegal and hoping you don't get caught by the police and go to jail.

With Yahweh though, Hell is perpetual and this just increases the thrill rush :D.
 

FranklinMichaelV.3

Well-Known Member
Making heaven and especially hell metaphorical ruins the fun for me. If I ever do a sin it is like doing something illegal and hoping you don't get caught by the police and go to jail.

With Yahweh though, Hell is perpetual and this just increases the thrill rush :D.

Yahweh (as in the old testament) was more keen on just killing you then and there. Plenty of the Israelite kings turned from Yahweh, they just got killed and their nation ransacked. Oh and cursing your family for like 3 generations.

Eternal damnation wasn't much of a thing. If you Sin..you died. Makes sense given the story of Genesis.
 

Shiranui117

Pronounced Shee-ra-noo-ee
Premium Member
In Christianity the concepts of heaven and hell are core beliefs. The believers of the religion are thrown into heaven, a place of eternal bliss, while the nonbelievers are throw into the fiery pits of hell to exist forever in perpetual agony. This is a vacuous concept and it entirely immoral. One can be the "best" person in the world and burn in hell due to your lack of belief in the christian god while the mass murderer, who asks forgiveness from god at the last second, can sit above you and gloat in heaven. Gullibility is the a main factor in determining your fate. After all, his believers will be forgiven all they must do is ask.
Who says that people will be in Hell merely for unbelief? Or who says that all we have to do to be forgiven is ask for it, and not need to repent, or undergo metanoia (change of heart) at all?

There are two options obviously, heaven and hell. That is it. You can either have bliss forever or an eternity of pain. Do you not see anything wrong with this? Then you are there forever. Nobody deserves eternal torment. Maybe a timed punishment but not forever. On the flip side no one deserves everlasting pleasure.
The only people who experience Hell are those who willfully choose to reject God forever. And those who experience Heaven are those who choose to love God forever.

Now about those in heaven. It would take a twisted person to enjoy heaven. Billions will be burning below you, many for petty crimes or just non belief, while you are enjoying heaven. I mean seriously? It is amazing how many Christians don't even think about the reality of their heaven and hell. Think don't just accept.
It depends on what version of Heaven and Hell you accept, and what criterion you think determine who goes where. Your personal beliefs may not match up with what the Bible and the rest of Tradition say.
 
Hi cbartlett16
I don't believe you can find anywhere in the Bible that even mention a hell existing. If there is id like to know where. The closest thing is maybe Luke 16: 22 and forth. But that is clearly not to be taken litterally. Because it says 'good' peaple go to the bossom position of Abraham in the heavens. If that was litterally there won't be room for many good peaple. Also the rich man in these verses call for a drop of water to soothe him in the fires where he is suffering. A drop of water would soothe no one and would also disperse in the fires very quickly. So this is not to be taken litterally. When fire is mentioned in the Bible its not about a tormenting hell but a symbol of everlasting annihilation or the grave but NOT everlasting torment.
You will also have a hard time to find in the Bible that all 'good' peaple go to Heaven. The Bibel mention only a very SPECIFIC number of people going to heaven. Revalation 5:9, 10 and Revalation 14:1. How about the rest of the 'good' peaple then. The Bible clearly states where they are going to be. Psalms 37: 9,10 and Matt 5:5. Theese verses explain that most people shall live on the Earth in peace and prosperty.
So its not just heaven and hell, bliss and torment. Its a bit more nuanced than that. The Bibel says 144.000 go to Heavens to be kings with Jesus and rule over thoose peaple that God deems good and derserving to inherit the Earth forever. The evil or ungodly peaple will be annihilated but not tormented in a burning hell forever.
Also the concept of a loving God that allows people to suffer forever is just plain wrong.
Hope this help you a little bit.
 

Pegg

Jehovah our God is One
In Christianity the concepts of heaven and hell are core beliefs. The believers of the religion are thrown into heaven, a place of eternal bliss, while the nonbelievers are throw into the fiery pits of hell to exist forever in perpetual agony. This is a vacuous concept and it entirely immoral. One can be the "best" person in the world and burn in hell due to your lack of belief in the christian god while the mass murderer, who asks forgiveness from god at the last second, can sit above you and gloat in heaven. Gullibility is the a main factor in determining your fate. After all, his believers will be forgiven all they must do is ask.

There are two options obviously, heaven and hell. That is it. You can either have bliss forever or an eternity of pain. Do you not see anything wrong with this? Then you are there forever. Nobody deserves eternal torment. Maybe a timed punishment but not forever. On the flip side no one deserves everlasting pleasure.

Now about those in heaven. It would take a twisted person to enjoy heaven. Billions will be burning below you, many for petty crimes or just non belief, while you are enjoying heaven. I mean seriously? It is amazing how many Christians don't even think about the reality of their heaven and hell. Think don't just accept.

not all christians accept the notion of heaven and hell as you've described above ;)
 

sojourner

Annoyingly Progressive Since 2006
Bartholomæus;3414949 said:
Hi cbartlett16
I don't believe you can find anywhere in the Bible that even mention a hell existing. If there is id like to know where. The closest thing is maybe Luke 16: 22 and forth. But that is clearly not to be taken litterally. Because it says 'good' peaple go to the bossom position of Abraham in the heavens. If that was litterally there won't be room for many good peaple. Also the rich man in these verses call for a drop of water to soothe him in the fires where he is suffering. A drop of water would soothe no one and would also disperse in the fires very quickly. So this is not to be taken litterally. When fire is mentioned in the Bible its not about a tormenting hell but a symbol of everlasting annihilation or the grave but NOT everlasting torment.
You will also have a hard time to find in the Bible that all 'good' peaple go to Heaven. The Bibel mention only a very SPECIFIC number of people going to heaven. Revalation 5:9, 10 and Revalation 14:1. How about the rest of the 'good' peaple then. The Bible clearly states where they are going to be. Psalms 37: 9,10 and Matt 5:5. Theese verses explain that most people shall live on the Earth in peace and prosperty.
So its not just heaven and hell, bliss and torment. Its a bit more nuanced than that. The Bibel says 144.000 go to Heavens to be kings with Jesus and rule over thoose peaple that God deems good and derserving to inherit the Earth forever. The evil or ungodly peaple will be annihilated but not tormented in a burning hell forever.
Also the concept of a loving God that allows people to suffer forever is just plain wrong.
Hope this help you a little bit.
"God annihilating part of what God created is wholly incongruent with the concept of God as Creator. God is not "reconstructor." God created us good. Therefore, evil is a "mask" we wear. God waits until the mask comes off.
 

JayJayDee

Avid JW Bible Student
Bartholomæus;3414949 said:
I don't believe you can find anywhere in the Bible that even mention a hell existing. If there is id like to know where.

Me too. :)

The closest thing is maybe Luke 16: 22 and forth. But that is clearly not to be taken literally.
This is clearly a parable that is conveyed in symbolisms.

If you read it carefully you can see plainly that it cannot be literal.

"The context and the wording of the story show clearly that it is a parable and not an actual historical account. Poverty is not being extolled, nor are riches being condemned. Rather, conduct, final rewards, and a reversal in the spiritual status, or condition, of those represented by Lazarus and by the rich man are evidently indicated. The fact that the rich man’s brothers rejected Moses and the prophets also shows that the illustration had a deeper meaning and purpose than that of contrasting poverty and the possession of riches.

In the parable, the ulcerous beggar, Lazarus, was put at the gate of the rich man, desiring to be fed with the things that fell from the rich man’s sumptuous table. Lazarus subsequently died and was carried off by angels to the bosom position of Abraham (a place comparable to that occupied by a person in ancient times when he reclined in front of another on the same couch during a meal). Abraham had a conversation with the rich man, who had also died, was buried, and was in Hades, existing in torments. “A great chasm” that could not be crossed separated the rich man from Abraham and Lazarus. The rich man’s request that Abraham send Lazarus to his five brothers to “give them a thorough witness,” in the hope of sparing them the same experience, met with rejection on the grounds that these had “Moses and the Prophets,” and, if unwilling to listen to them, “neither will they be persuaded if someone rises from the dead.” (Insight Volumes WTS)

The rich man represented the Pharisees and the beggar represented the common Jewish people whom the Pharisees despised. Their "deaths" represented a change in their status. The Jewish leaders had the "bosom" position of Abraham as teachers and leaders of God's people, but when Christ came a change took place. These ones lost their favored position because of rejecting the Christ. The common folk accepted Jesus and gained the favored position with God.

The torment came from Jesus teachings. He exposed the Pharisees for the hypocrites they were. They hated him enough to kill him.

Do we imagine that heaven and hell are within speaking distance of each other?
Do we imagine that a drop of water on someone's finger would be enough to cool the tongue of someone in a fire? :confused:

You will also have a hard time to find in the Bible that all 'good' people go to Heaven. The Bible mention only a very SPECIFIC number of people going to heaven. Revelation 5:9, 10 and Revelation 14:1.
Since the ones who go to heaven will be "kings and priests", (Rev 20:6) they will need subjects to rule, and sinners for whom to perform their priestly duties. Those who go to heaven are no longer imperfect humans but perfect spirit creatures who are now immortal and incorruptible. They will not be ruling each other and acting as priests for each other. They don't need to.(1 Cor 15:50-53) So their subjects will be humans here on a cleansed earth. (Rev 21:3, 4)

How about the rest of the 'good' people then. The Bible clearly states where they are going to be. Psalms 37: 9,10 and Matt 5:5. These verses explain that most people shall live on the Earth in peace and property.
The restoration prophesies in Isaiah describe how wonderful life will be in the "new earth" under the rulership of the "new heavens". (Isa 65:17-24: 2 Pet 3:13; Rev 21:1-4)

So its not just heaven and hell, bliss and torment. Its a bit more nuanced than that.
Yes, Israel was never promised heaven or hell...just life or death. (Deut 30:9, 20)
Adam was not told that he would go to hell for his disobedience, just that he would go back to the dust.

The Bible says 144.000 go to Heavens to be kings with Jesus and rule over those people that God deems good and deserving to inherit the Earth forever. The evil or ungodly people will be annihilated but not tormented in a burning hell forever.
Also the concept of a loving God that allows people to suffer forever is just plain wrong.
How many people are so hung up about going to heaven that they don't stop to ask..."who are the meek who will inherit the earth"? (Matt 5:5; Psalm 37:9-12)

Hell (hades) is not a place of eternal torment.....it is a place of rest in sleep. (John 11:11) For the ones in hades (the common grave) a resurrection is promised. (John 5:28, 29)

For those whom Jesus consigned to "gehenna" there is no resurrection. Their lives have been terminated. They will never see the light of day again.

What possible purpose is served by keeping the wicked alive only to torment them forever? That is fiendish. :eek:
Punishment served a purpose in God's law. It was to lead the wrongdoer to repentance and forgiveness and act as a deterrent for future wrongdoing.. Those in Christendom's hell have no way to repent and no way to gain God's forgiveness. That goes against everything Jehovah reveals about himself and his perfect justice.
 

seeking4truth

Active Member
Heaven and Hell can also be experienced mentally, and spiritually.
Haven't you ever had an experience that tears at you and makes you feel totally wretched, despairing and hopeless at that moment?
Haven't you experienced the opposite, such happiness and complete joy that you can hardly believe how wonderful it feels?

As a believer I also think that after death when you are in a position to know whether what you believed and did in this physical part of was correct then you will experience something like the above feelings again.
That's one of my understandings of Heaven and Hell.
 
Top