• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Hell would not teach us anything

michel

Administrator Emeritus
Staff member
Wow not unreasonable at all! :facepalm:

Why is it so? If the world just "happened to come together" by sheer hapenstance - the right "ingredients being in the right place at the right time" - surely the chances of the monkey writing the works of Shakespeare are no lesser than what you believe in.

OK, let's make it less "difficult" - show me a man who can create a living creature from scatch he would have to amanufacture every single component of life without using anything that already exists.
 

Skwim

Veteran Member
Why is it so? If the world just "happened to come together" by sheer hapenstance - the right "ingredients being in the right place at the right time" - surely the chances of the monkey writing the works of Shakespeare are no lesser than what you believe in.

OK, let's make it less "difficult" - show me a man who can create a living creature from scatch he would have to amanufacture every single component of life without using anything that already exists.
I know idav can speak for himself, but just to fill you in until he does; it's "unreasonable :facepalm:" because it's asinine. And it's asinine because you've arbitrarily selected a goal you know is impossible, yet expect us to accept it as reasonable. We're not as dumb as you sound here. In any case, go ahead and believe whatever you like, just don't try to get it into the public school systems.
 

Vendetta

"Oscar the grouch"
Man of Faith I find any Christian who meets a non-Christian ask "are you saved?" To me, not only is it presumptuous of any person to proclaim they are saved but it does amount to as being self-righteous.

First off hell to me is living homeless with bacteria, stress, drugs, and STD. Or having a schizophrenic episode where you hear voices to kill people. I don't see the point of any god punishing a good human being who just doesn't believe in religion, or someone who is an apostate who just didn't find any spiritual clarity in that religion. There is no reason why Jesus should punish me for all eternity all because I don't believe in his religion when, Crusaders and KKK have done more harm against humanity than I der could. Muslims believe similarly if I do not proclaim believe in one God, Allah and his prophet.

I mean, if I live my life and be kind to humans and just be myself and be respectful to the laws of the land (even to small creatures) are you, man of faith, saying according to your faith that, me going to hell is just?
 

PolyHedral

Superabacus Mystic
I don't think that hell is necessarily there to teach people things, but to punish them. Is jail to teach or to punish? We might learn something from going to jail but it is for punishment or should be IMO. And I think we would also learn something from going to hell, albeit a little late.
Jail is there, in theory, to deter and to reform. Anything else would merely be revenge, a crude, emotional goal.

Justice does not rely on emotion. The ideal judicial process purges emotion, and is left with pure, objective logic.

And that logic, in turn, renders punishment of any sort nonsensical. That is because there is always a "because;" People do things for a reason, and eventually you trace the reasons back to something they do not control. People are not responsible for their own personalities or circumstances, and those two factors alone lead to their decisions.
 

Adonis65

Active Member
i thought i'd make my first post today! been browsing these forums for a little while and love it! but here goes-

The idea of an eternal torture chamber for a finite life would not teach us a single thing. All it would prove is that an "all loving", "all merciful" and "all forgiving" god is definitely not living in the upstairs paradise.Why should anyone be tortured forever for something so minuscule such as lack of belief or wrong belief system. There is no justification for it whatsoever other than it's a tool for keeping people in a certain belief system and acting "moral" out of fear and in hopes of reward. I can not fathom how people try to justify it. There would be more good people in hell than good people in heaven anyway (minus the murderers,rapists,etc). And on the opposite side, If a girl was raped and got into heaven but her rapist accepted jesus or whatever it took to get into heaven, wouldn't that be hell for her and heaven for him? And i know people are gonna say well heaven is perfect and whatever else but sorry the irrationality of it all is just ridiculous. I don't mean to offend anyone that holds beliefs on an afterlife, i'm just stating my opinion. :faint:

I suppose if God shared your views on this matter, then it would make perfect sense to all believers. The question is, does He?
 

839311

Well-Known Member
The idea of an eternal torture chamber for a finite life would not teach us a single thing. All it would prove is that an "all loving", "all merciful" and "all forgiving" god is definitely not living in the upstairs paradise.Why should anyone be tortured forever for something so minuscule such as lack of belief or wrong belief system.

Indeed. Such a monster would not be worthy of our acceptance, and should be opposed by everyone, stripped of his power if possible, and killed if necessary.

There is no justification for it whatsoever other than it's a tool for keeping people in a certain belief system and acting "moral" out of fear and in hopes of reward.

Bingo.
 

Kilgore Trout

Misanthropic Humanist
I suppose if God shared your views on this matter, then it would make perfect sense to all believers. The question is, does He?

Good point. There is an apparent absence of evidence in many religious teachings, and in life itself, of the existence of a forgiving, loving, or just god.
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
So, it's kind of like much of life.
But the punishment is eternal & more severe.
Hmmmm.....doesn't make sense, does it?
I just can't believe that a supreme being would think that way....let alone even care what we pissantic humans are up to.
 

Willamena

Just me
Premium Member
But the punishment is eternal & more severe.
Hmmmm.....doesn't make sense, does it?
I just can't believe that a supreme being would think that way....let alone even care what we pissantic humans are up to.
Come on... I'm tired of hearing people put us down so. If not us pissantic humans, then who?
 
Top