• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Human supremacy

Saw11_2000

Well-Known Member
Ceridwen018 said:
I remember when we talked about this in my 8th grade theology class. Our priest came in to teach us, as he did from time to time. I really respected this priest, for he was very intelligent and down-to-earth, as well as being genuinely devout. Anyhow, we were talking about the Catholic Church's teachings on human supremecy. He brought up this scenario: "If a 90 year old man who was confined to his bed with a respirator and a feeding tube was hanging off of a cliff, and the every member of the panda bear species was also hanging off of a cliff, and if you only had time to save one group, (keeping in mind that the entire panda species would become completely extinct if you didn't save them), which would you save?"

"The pandas!" We all cried.

"Wrong!" Said our priest.

He then went on to explain that the Church teaches us that human life must be valued above everything else, no matter what, and I went on to think that that was the most ridiculous and impractical thing I had ever heard.
I would save the human, but that's just me.

There's no wrong answer though, it's an opinion. I don't agree with needlessly killing things, like hunting and such. And I do NOT hate animals!

I just purchased a fish at Wal-Mart!!! I'm very excited and I named it Harry!!!!
 

michel

Administrator Emeritus
Staff member
Ceridwen018 said:
I remember when we talked about this in my 8th grade theology class. Our priest came in to teach us, as he did from time to time. I really respected this priest, for he was very intelligent and down-to-earth, as well as being genuinely devout. Anyhow, we were talking about the Catholic Church's teachings on human supremecy. He brought up this scenario: "If a 90 year old man who was confined to his bed with a respirator and a feeding tube was hanging off of a cliff, and the every member of the panda bear species was also hanging off of a cliff, and if you only had time to save one group, (keeping in mind that the entire panda species would become completely extinct if you didn't save them), which would you save?"

"The pandas!" We all cried.

"Wrong!" Said our priest.

He then went on to explain that the Church teaches us that human life must be valued above everything else, no matter what, and I went on to think that that was the most ridiculous and impractical thing I had ever heard.
I'd have gone with the pandas too......I was going to say 'animals don't sin' but that is a presumption. Any ideas anyone?
:confused:
 

Stormygale

Member
Yea...new thead....
"Do animals sin?"
-
With that said. Who cares if an animal sins. Animals may have their own gods and praises. We do not know. We are animals. Mammals. We have just evolved to a higher level than, say, a panda....lol. At least I have anyway.
 
Top