• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

I don't know if I can call myself a Christian after reading this.

.lava

Veteran Member
'Child-witches' of Nigeria seek refuge - ExChristian.Net - News and Opinion

This is absolute madness. I am disgusted with what some people do in the name of Christ, and to children no less. I don't even know if I can call myself a Christian while atrocities of this magnitude are being performed in the world.

Discuss.

yes madness thanks to ignorance of men. if a father is able to kick his daughter out on the streets, that only proves he is uneducated and blinded by ignorance. this is very disturbing.


.
 

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
first, the bible says that wherever two or more are gathered in gods name, that is a church or congregation, so no large group is necessary to form or be considered a "religion"

That's an ancient Biblical definition of a CHURCH or CONGREGATION. Those words are not quite the same as a religion, although they can be the start.

My definition of religion is based on a broader view of the world which the ancients did not have.

second religion is superstition, and vice versa. when GOD COMMANDS "Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live" in exodus 22:18 how the heck can you not take that literally? its a fact. it is a command. GODS COMMAND. there is no interpreting around it.

by choosing to ignore this command, youre ignoring god himself. and ignoring the judao christian god pretty much excludes you from the judao or christian religion.

now, if you want to be part of this religion, you best go out and kill witches, and dont forget, "dont cook a young goat in its mothers milk" LOL

Who said I wanted to be Jewish? I have no intention of converting.

Why don't we take a look at the JPS commentary on that verse.

"Sorceress, a practitioner of malevolent magic (usually a woman but males are banned in Deut. 18.10), which is punished severely because it was deemed dangerous and antisocial. The Bible does not deny the efficacy of magic, but bans it as rebellion against God. (Deut. 18.9-15)" ("The Jewish Study Bible")

Also, Judaism is but ONE of MANY religions. As is Christianity. Or Islam. Or Vedanta. Or Buddhism. Or Taoism. Or Baha'i. Or Sikhism. Or many, many others that I don't know about.

May I suggest you pick up a study Bible so you can read it with some help? Some good ones are:

"The Jewish Study Bible" from the Jewish Publication Society (JPS)
"Commentary on the Torah" by Richard Elliot Friedman
"The Five Books of Moses- Translation and Commentary" by Robert Alter

These commentaries are based on scholarly research and, from what I can tell, do not have any bias. I'm not even sure if Friedman or Alter are Jewish.
 

Little Joe Gould

Seeking God
I did a little bit of thinking about this, and I'm still going to consider myself a Christian and am going to make an attempt to spread more awareness about this absurd behavior. A conclusion I have came to is that religion is very similar to technology in the respect that they are both double edged swords. Technology in the hands of the righteous produces righteousness; such as modern medicine, global communications, and advanced transportation. But in the hands of the unrighteous it produces things like nuclear weapons and bio-terrorism. Religion, as well, in the hands of the righteous will produce righteousness; it can produce things like homeless shelters, food pantries, free counseling, and fine, upstanding citizens. But this is definitely a case of religion being held in the hands of the unrighteous, which in this case produces nothing short of evil.
 

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
I did a little bit of thinking about this, and I'm still going to consider myself a Christian and am going to make an attempt to spread more awareness about this absurd behavior. A conclusion I have came to is that religion is very similar to technology in the respect that they are both double edged swords. Technology in the hands of the righteous produces righteousness; such as modern medicine, global communications, and advanced transportation. But in the hands of the unrighteous it produces things like nuclear weapons and bio-terrorism. Religion, as well, in the hands of the righteous will produce righteousness; it can produce things like homeless shelters, food pantries, free counseling, and fine, upstanding citizens. But this is definitely a case of religion being held in the hands of the unrighteous, which in this case produces nothing short of evil.

Probably the best analogy of religion I've ever seen.

FRUBALS!!!!
 

The Neo Nerd

Well-Known Member
A conclusion I have came to is that religion is very similar to technology in the respect that they are both double edged swords. Technology in the hands of the righteous produces righteousness; such as modern medicine, global communications, and advanced transportation. But in the hands of the unrighteous it produces things like nuclear weapons and bio-terrorism. Religion, as well, in the hands of the righteous will produce righteousness; it can produce things like homeless shelters, food pantries, free counseling, and fine, upstanding citizens. But this is definitely a case of religion being held in the hands of the unrighteous, which in this case produces nothing short of evil.

Very wise Joe,

-Q
 

Little Joe Gould

Seeking God
first, the bible says that wherever two or more are gathered in gods name, that is a church or congregation, so no large group is necessary to form or be considered a "religion"

second religion is superstition, and vice versa. when GOD COMMANDS "Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live" in exodus 22:18 how the heck can you not take that literally? its a fact. it is a command. GODS COMMAND. there is no interpreting around it.

by choosing to ignore this command, youre ignoring god himself. and ignoring the judao christian god pretty much excludes you from the judao or christian religion.

now, if you want to be part of this religion, you best go out and kill witches, and dont forget, "dont cook a young goat in its mothers milk" LOL

No offense, but it seems your understanding of what modern Christianity should be is relatively immature. The Old Testament was a different time period, it was when the Jewish people were under the law of God; it wasn't the period of grace that we live in today. Christ was, as well as the Messiah imo, a social reformer who's divine duty it was to reset people's understanding of what Yahweh expected from his people. The Pentateuch was written to give primitive people a law to abide by for the sake of moral advancement. However, we live in a new age and those laws are now blatantly archaic to be adhered to literally. Surely, witchcraft is bad, but it shouldn't be considered a punishable offensive. Christianity, unlike other religions, is primarily what I've heard referred to as a "historical religion". Many of the books in the Old Testament are more for historical reflection; it isn't like the Qu'ran. The Bible is meant to be interpretted by itself, in full context, with the righteousness and love that Christ displayed for His people as the main focus.
 

Hospitaller

Seminarian
'Child-witches' of Nigeria seek refuge - ExChristian.Net - News and Opinion

This is absolute madness. I am disgusted with what some people do in the name of Christ, and to children no less. I don't even know if I can call myself a Christian while atrocities of this magnitude are being performed in the world.

Discuss.


Another example of what can happen when priests are poorly educated and developed in poorer countries.

Still, just because theres a few bad doctors I'm not going to reject medicine...

Besides what specific denomination are these Christians? or is it all of them???
 

Little Joe Gould

Seeking God
Besides what specific denomination are these Christians? or is it all of them???

It appears to be a very primitive understanding of Christianity, masquerading as a Pentacostal sect, intermingling with the equally primitive animism of that region. It is a bad combination due to the fanatical aspect of Pentacostals as well as the obsession of animism with the occult and demonic presences.
 

Falvlun

Earthbending Lemur
Premium Member
Outdated superstition is defined as taking old mythologies and superstitions too literally, and applying them, such as witch-hunting.

A religion is an organized spiritual journey carried out by a large group.

Though I agree with you that not all religions take old mythologies and superstitions too literally, I think it a bit naiive to say that no religion does so.

A religion could very well be an organized spiritual journey that also takes old mythologies and superstitions as the Truth, as given by God, and therefore any deviation from it would be to forsake the one True path.

Really, I don't see how you can characterize some beliefs as "supersitions" or "old mythologies" or even "too literal" and others as not; and those that are "not" get to be called religion.
 

logician

Well-Known Member
It appears to be a very primitive understanding of Christianity, masquerading as a Pentacostal sect, intermingling with the equally primitive animism of that region. It is a bad combination due to the fanatical aspect of Pentacostals as well as the obsession of animism with the occult and demonic presences.

I would say the marjority of denominations of Christianity in the U.S. have a "primitive" understanding of it.
 

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
Though I agree with you that not all religions take old mythologies and superstitions too literally, I think it a bit naiive to say that no religion does so.

I don't think I ever said that.

A religion could very well be an organized spiritual journey that also takes old mythologies and superstitions as the Truth, as given by God, and therefore any deviation from it would be to forsake the one True path.

Really, I don't see how you can characterize some beliefs as "supersitions" or "old mythologies" or even "too literal" and others as not; and those that are "not" get to be called religion.

Many religions DO take old superstitions too literally. We have an example in the OP. That's very much a religion, but it's mired by old superstition.
 

Falvlun

Earthbending Lemur
Premium Member
"Please demonstrate the objective distinction between religion and outdated superstition.:shrug:

Riverwolf said:
I believe I already have to you. Nevertheless, I shall repeat it.

Outdated superstition is defined as taking old mythologies and superstitions too literally, and applying them, such as witch-hunting.

A religion is an organized spiritual journey carried out by a large group.

This was how you distinguished between religion and out-dated superstition. If out-dated superstition is a part of many religions, then I don't see how your distinction is meaningful. :shrug:
 

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
This was how you distinguished between religion and out-dated superstition. If out-dated superstition is a part of many religions, then I don't see how your distinction is meaningful. :shrug:

Some religions have integrated outdated superstitions into their practices and viewpoints. Some versions of Christianity have done this, other versions have not.

Christianity doesn't rely on outdated superstition to be Christianity. But some followers of the faith have adapted it anyway for whatever reason.
 
Top