Oh we would get along great. This is a Great beer conversation in a pub with my ADHD moments "did you see that she is, magical"...I am looking at it just from energy itself and of course you are the mechanical engineer, there is no disagreement between us at all.
Entropy does not allow for any perpetual motion machine to ever exist. EVER and that I hold to be absolute. None has ever been built none will never be built impossible no where in nature does it, exist. A closed system is the machine and forever ot will just sit there. But if we run an extension cord, or a battery viola it runs. In a sense we,raise the energy, and the energy drops through mechanical action.
Now in modern cosmology lala land many say there is no such thing as a free lunch except the cosmos. I say prove it build, a perpetual motion machine, I want proof. Since no proof will ever be presented it's nonsense.
We might as well believe that Michelangelos cistene chapel ceiling paintings are photographs logging historical events. Of course I find that insulting to art!!!! Thus often times religion insulting itself right smack there in dumminess. But hey that's normal!!