dybmh
דניאל יוסף בן מאיר הירש
I did.
If there is a Jew who is atheists and not atheist at then same time, then Scotland is in Canada.
Where do you miss the "if" and ""then" in it?
Do you need help reading English too?
No. That's not what you originally said. You originally said "All the jews I know are atheists." Period. End of statement. End of post. Post#16 ---> Link. I know it's been a long debate, but since you have a pattern of misrepresenting, cherry picking, and lying by omission. I think you're being dishonest here. I think you know what you said, and you're trying to weasel out of it.
How?
Do you think Jews who are atheists are not Jews, anymore?
Ciao
- viole
No one can be both an atheist and not an atheist simultaneously.
all the Jews I know are atheists AND not atheists is TRUE (if and only if I know no Jew). So, TRUE. as per premise.
1) you did not declare all the premises. As you were shown earlier, to use the "logic" you want to use you would need to declare the assumptions, and include the vacuity of your knowledge. Both need to be included.
2) no one can be both atheist and not atheist simultaneously. This is false per the definition of both atheist and jew.