1/2- This is gonna take 2 posts.
The first great commandment of all eternity is to love God with all of our heart, might, mind, and strength—that's the first great commandment. But the first great truth of all eternity is that that God loves us with all of His heart, might, mind and strength."
The question was, is the LDS church a Christian church. This is another proof it isn't. In the Christian church there is one greatest or first Commandment or responsibility, to love the Lord our God with all of our heart, mind, strength and soul. The 2nd is, to love our neighbor as we love our self.
But in the LDS church, it appears to me, there are a bunch of 'firsts', 'greatest', 'grandest' , and 'most important' responsibility. I did a look-see and found some but to explain is a bit long. Here they are with a comment or two, (notice that there are numerous LDS printed and published books used)
What does the LDS church teach is man’s ‘greatest responsibility’?
1. Speaking about Baptism for the Dead (B4D) Joseph Smith (1st LDS prophet) taught,
“
The greatest responsibility in this world that God has laid upon us is to seek after our dead.” (The Teachings of the Prophet JS (TPJS) 356, History of the Church (HoC) 6:313).
2. Joseph Fielding Smith (10th LDS prophet) reiterated that teaching by quoting JS,
"
It is the greatest responsibility in this world that God has laid upon us- to seek after our dead
(B4D)." (Doctrines of Salvation (DoS) 1:268, 2:149).
3. Joseph Fielding Smith (10 LDS prophet) taught,
“But
the greatest and grandest duty of all is to labor for the dead
(B4D).” (DoS 2:149, Gospel Principles (GP) 248).
4. Brigham Young (2nd LDS prophet) taught,
“This doctrine of baptism for the dead
(B4D) is a great doctrine,
one of the most glorious doctrines that was revealed to the human family.” (Discourse of Brigham Young (DBY) 399)
5. Joseph Fielding Smith wrote (and the LDS church published) ‘The Way to Perfection’ (W2P). In this book the LDS church teaches,
“But greater than all this, so far as our individual responsibilities are concerned,
the greatest is to become saviors.” (W2P 153). He goes on to quote JS statement. (see #1).
6. Joseph F. Smith (6th LDS prophet) taught in ‘Gospel Doctrine’ (GD) under the heading “The Truest Greatness”,
“Our
first care, after all, brings us back to that beautiful admonition of our Savior: “
Seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness; and all these things shall be added unto you (Matt. 6:33).” (GD 285).
7. Joseph Smith taught,
“After all that has been said,
the greatest and most important duty is to
preach the Gospel.” (TPJS 113).
8. Joseph Smith also taught (
God is a man),
“
The first principle of the Gospel [is] to know for a certainty the Character of God…he was once a man like us. (TPJS 345/6, GP 293).
9. The LDS publication (for their Sunday Schools) ‘Messages for Exaltation’ (M4E) states,
“
The first principle of the gospel is…
faith in the Lord Jesus Christ.” (M4E 150)
10. From the ‘Lectures on Faith’ (LoF), which was in all D&Cs from the first edition (1835) to 1920, this is taught:
“
Faith, being
the first principle in revealed religion, and the foundation of all righteousness.” (LoF 1:1)
11. “
The very first principle was
faith in the Messiah.” (Teachings of Presidents of the Church- Wilford Woodruff (TPC-WW) 71). [WW was the 4th LDS prophet)
12. The LDS publication ‘Search These Commandments’ (StC) quotes Charles W. Penrose when he “chided a bishop for placing a sign in the chapel that said: “Order is the first law of heaven.” President Penrose said this was incorrect because
obedience is that first law.” (StC 122/23, Mormon Doctrine (MD) 539).
13. David O. McKay (9th LDS prophet) wrote (and the LDS church published) ‘Gospel Ideals’ (GI). It states,
“Third, let us never lose sight of the principles of obedience.
Obedience is heaven’s first law.” (GI 484).
14. Joseph Fielding Smith taught,
"They taught the people two basic principles: faith in the Lord Jesus Christ and repentance. After new converts had faith in Jesus Christ as the Son of God and their redeemer and had repented of their sins, they received two basic ordinances:
baptism by immersion and the
laying on of hands for the gift of the Holy Ghost. These were the first principles and ordinances of the gospel.” (GP 99).
15. John Taylor (3rd LDS prophet) taught, (
Eternal Marriage)
“It was necessary that
one grand truth should be unlocked. (JoD 11:221).
16. John Taylor taught,
Polygamy “is one of the greatest principles that was ever taught revealed to man.” (JoD 11:222).
Notes and comments (my personal opinions):
Now let’s take a closer look at these LDS teachings and see what we find about the LDS church. First, I take it to mean that the words “the greatest responsibility in the world”, “greatest and grandest duty of all”, “first care”, “first principle of the gospel”, “the very first principle”, “first law” all refer to the greatest duty or responsibility. First and greatest as used here must be synonymous.
Second, it is impossible for the LDS god to have different beliefs (doctrines) as his first law, grandest duty and greatest responsibility? I’m confident everyone sees the futility of saying otherwise. That would be preposterous If it’s God’s
first law to man then it must be man’s greatest responsibility to God (to obey or observe). That only stands to reason to reasonable people and certainly to an all-powerful and all-knowing god. Why would the LDS god give his
first ‘principle’ (principle means= a foundational doctrine) that wasn’t also the greatest to be obeyed? That would be silly, even ridiculous. So first also must mean greatest.
What I mean is this, is Baptism for the Dead (B4D) “the greatest responsibility in the world” (1-5) or is our “greatest and most important responsibility to preach the gospel” (7).
The LDS church doesn’t stop there. They toss out yet another doctrine as their “greatest responsibility”. The Mormon Church teaches their “first care” (grandest duty, greatest responsibility) is now to “seek ye
first the kingdom of God” (6).
Are they aware of what they are teaching?
The LDS church goes on to teach “the first principle of the Gospel… is to know that God is a man”. (8)
The LDS church wasn’t finished, the first principle of the gospel changed to having “faith in Jesus”. (9, 10, 11)
Brigham Young turned around and taught baptism for the dead (B4D) is only
one of the greatest doctrines. (4) Is it the greatest or not? Surely someone like BY- the prophet, seer and revelator of the LDS god, church and people who spoke to his god all the time- knew how important this ‘eternal’ doctrine was.
Surprisingly, the LDS church didn’t stop there, either.
Joseph Fielding Smith taught the “greatest responsibility is to become saviors” (5).
But LDS scripture teaches there is only one Savior.
“HEAR, O ye heavens, and give ear, O earth, and rejoice ye inhabitants thereof, for the Lord is God and
besides him there is no Savior.” (D&C 76:1).
So how can the LDS people be saviors when Jesus is the only one? As if that wasn’t enough the Church then taught,
“Obedience is the first law of heaven” (13).
How many 'firsts' can any church have? Surely, every principle can’t be the first or greatest. Isn’t that a hopeless contradiction in terminology?
Next the LDS church taught the first two principles were faith and repentance. But in that same paragraph they teach the first two ordinances were baptism by immersion and the laying on of hands for the gift of the Holy Ghost. And they ended it by stating, “These were the first principles and ordinances of the gospel.” (14).
Aren't ordinances and principles the same?
or·di·nance; Noun:
1. A piece of legislation enacted by a municipal authority.
2. An authoritative order; a decree.
prin·ci·ple; Noun:
1. A fundamental truth or proposition that serves as the foundation for a system of belief or behavior or for a chain of reasoning.
2. A rule or belief governing one's personal behavior.
So, all four can’t be the ‘first’. But, the LDS church teaches that all 4 of these are, in one form or another, its greatest responsibility:
Baptism for the Dead B4D (1-5),
Seek ye first the kingdom of God (6),
Preaching the Gospel (7),
The knowledge that God is a man (8),
Having faith in Jesus (9-11),
Obedience is heaven’s first law (12, 13),
Faith in Jesus, repentance, Baptism by immersion and Laying on of the hands (14)