So how is it any different than something that is completely made-up?
Mainly, by taking due responsibility for what is proposed.
You are the one not using the English definition of an English word.
I don't think English has become quite that confused, personally.
I was trying to show how that behavior can be used to justify extreme positions.
I guess you failed then.
Duly noted. It matters little, but noted.
Judaism, Christianity, and Islam all have holybooks that profess to be true through the same sort of rhetoric and make similar claims about reality.
The Abrahamics are admittedly a weird bunch. The degrees to which they manage to overcome the drawbacks of their self-imposed weirdness varies greatly. Islaam is entirely crippled, even degenerated by them. Judaism and to a lesser degree Christianity learned better.
Yet you consider some of those religions religions and some not based on how you seem to like those claims.
Of course I do. I expect everyone to make their own decisions on such matters, and I am no exception.
So the way a religion becomes a religion is by ignoring most of it's religious texts? Again I think you need to justify your arbitrary definition.
Any honest examination will show the obvious: texts are just words on paper. They can hardly be expected to carry a whole religion even in the best circunstances.
They are not entirely useless, but it is a poor religion that which fails to transcend (not "ignore") its own texts.
If you want to have a word that conveys your definition then make one up, don't try to hijack another word.
My point exactly, son.
The word "religion" is does not mean and has never meant what you mean it to mean.
Well, I guess you stopped me. Or something.
This is the same thing people who redefine atheists as misotheists or Wiccans as Satanists and then act like every atheists they meet is a misotheist or Wiccan is a Satanist do.
Because you say so?
Really?
I don't think you have thought your way through that claim very well.
If you are going to use a different definition of religion then the rest of the English speaking world then you should realize that when we use the word, we are not meaning your definition.
I will keep that in mind in case it ever becomes an issue, then.