• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Killing innocent people is a crime in Islam.

Astounded

Member
Ummah is One? Hahaha. Either you're highly ignorant, highly misinformed or have been smoking something funny. "The Ummah is One" sounds nice but it's not reality. The Ummah has been divided since Aisha (the Prophets wife) and Ali (his nephew) went to war against each other soon after Prophet Muhammad's death. This created the Sunni-Shia split and the Ummah hasn't been one since. Now there are MANY divisions. Sunnis and Shias still don't like each other. Most Muslims don't agree with Saudi Arabia and Wahhabi Islam (which is where all the extremism comes from). Then there are Quranist Muslims such as myself who are considered apostates by many other members of the "Ummah". Let's not forget Sufi Muslims and several offshoot sects such as Ahmadi, Deobandi, Ismaili, Mahdavi, Khariji, Ibadi, Submitters, Barelvi, Zaydi, etc. And you say the UMMAH IS ONE??? Obviously you need to go educate yourself before you start acting like an expert on the history and beliefs of Islam.

Yah, I keep forgetting that you are the only true Muslim on the board...the Sunnis, Shias, Wahhabis,etc aren't really Muslims in your opinion... but they claim to be anyway..Maybe you would want to tell the forum who are the true Muslims so we can eliminate the confusion?? Or actually, in reference to my building a church post in Saudi Arabia, I would accept proposals from your 'Ummah," the Sunni 'Ummah,' the Shia 'Ummah,' etc or whatever 'Ummah' petitioning for a church to be built there.

And poor FOuad, your fellow 'Muslim' poster on the board..he must be more confused than me with his signature tag line:
The Muslim is a unique Ummah among the whole of mankind: Their land is ONE, their War is ONE, their Peace is ONE, their Honour is ONE and there Trust is ONE - Prophet Mohammed (sallallahou alayhi wasallam)

 

Astounded

Member
So do Irish terrorists, as a matter of fact. "The True Irishman speaks Gaelic, plays Gaelic Games, and is Catholic." That was a major factor of Irish National Identity. FTR, I am of Irish decent.

BTW, they just shout "God is Great" for the same psychological reasons that kids recently kept shouting about how they used to be such and such until they took an arrow to the knee.

Yep, I know about it. A very crazy bigotted bunch. My wife is Irish and she had the bright idea to sponsor an Irish kid for the summer about 20-25 years ago. It was one of those programs to get them out of Belfast or whatever during the summer violence.

The kid was Catholic. And boy did he hate Protestants. My friend is Irish but was an Orangeman/Protestant. He had no problem with him until I toid the kid he was Protestant, then he was rude to my friend. My neighbor next door was a Baptist youth minister. As soon as he found out, he was rude to him also. When he found out I rented my investment condo to a Baptist youth minister, his comment was, raise the rent....

I finally sent him packing because no matter how many times I told him he was wrong as per his 'book', it didn't matter. BTW, even though he was supposedly Catholic, I couldn't get him to go to Mass on Sunday..so you have to wonder..what the hell was he?? I probably would have done better with a Protestant kid......
 

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
Yep, I know about it. A very crazy bigotted bunch. My wife is Irish and she had the bright idea to sponsor an Irish kid for the summer about 20-25 years ago. It was one of those programs to get them out of Belfast or whatever during the summer violence.

The kid was Catholic. And boy did he hate Protestants. My friend is Irish but was an Orangeman/Protestant. He had no problem with him until I toid the kid he was Protestant, then he was rude to my friend. My neighbor next door was a Baptist youth minister. As soon as he found out, he was rude to him also. When he found out I rented my investment condo to a Baptist youth minister, his comment was, raise the rent....

I finally sent him packing because no matter how many times I told him he was wrong as per his 'book', it didn't matter. BTW, even though he was supposedly Catholic, I couldn't get him to go to Mass on Sunday..so you have to wonder..what the hell was he?? I probably would have done better with a Protestant kid......

And this kid was the Irish Catholic equivalent to Muslim terrorists.

Spiritually, there is no important difference.
 

Astounded

Member
And this kid was the Irish Catholic equivalent to Muslim terrorists.

Spiritually, there is no important difference.

The difference is in what their 'book's allow/permit.....

There is a difference between what is right and wrong and what is permited and forbidden..
 

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
The difference is in what their 'book's allow/permit.....

There is a difference between what is right and wrong and what is permited and forbidden..

The difference is insignificant.

Besides, you should know as well as I do that there's plenty of passages in the Bible that can be interpreted to condone mass killing.

For crying out loud, I actually worship Othin King, who is a God of War and makes no pretenses of "peace", yet I don't condone terrorist actions, and neither do most Asatru.
 

Astounded

Member
The difference is insignificant.

Besides, you should know as well as I do that there's plenty of passages in the Bible that can be interpreted to condone mass killing.

For crying out loud, I actually worship Othin King, who is a God of War and makes no pretenses of "peace", yet I don't condone terrorist actions, and neither do most Asatru.

I don't remember any passages that condone murder in the bible.

And I don't know enough about Othin King. Does he condone murder in your 'book??'
 

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
I don't remember any passages that condone murder in the bible.

Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live doesn't ring a bell?

And I don't know enough about Othin King. Does he condone murder in your 'book??'
We have no "book", just stories and lessons from Skalds and Bards. You know him as Odin (or Wotan if you're German).

But it was said of old that in any combat situation, Othin is the one who determines the winner.
 
Last edited:

Astounded

Member
Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live doesn't ring a bell?

We have no "book", just stories and lessons from Skalds and Bards. You know him as Odin (or Wotan if you're German).

But it was said of old that in any combat situation, Othin is the one who determines the winner.

I'm not a Jew but I would assume that there was some sort of process to determine if one was a witch rather than a bomb next to them that went boom...
 

Riverwolf

Amateur Rambler / Proud Ergi
Premium Member
I'm not a Jew but I would assume that there was some sort of process to determine if one was a witch rather than a bomb next to them that went boom...

Doesn't matter much, does it? That passage was used during the Reformation to burn witches.

Besides, go reread the Book of Joshua. Probably the most disgusting book I've ever read. Ever.
 

F0uad

Well-Known Member
Yah, I keep forgetting that you are the only true Muslim on the board...the Sunnis, Shias, Wahhabis,etc aren't really Muslims in your opinion... but they claim to be anyway..Maybe you would want to tell the forum who are the true Muslims so we can eliminate the confusion?? Or actually, in reference to my building a church post in Saudi Arabia, I would accept proposals from your 'Ummah," the Sunni 'Ummah,' the Shia 'Ummah,' etc or whatever 'Ummah' petitioning for a church to be built there.

And poor FOuad, your fellow 'Muslim' poster on the board..he must be more confused than me with his signature tag line:
The Muslim is a unique Ummah among the whole of mankind: Their land is ONE, their War is ONE, their Peace is ONE, their Honour is ONE and there Trust is ONE - Prophet Mohammed (sallallahou alayhi wasallam)

What has this to do with me you "poor" guy?

I advice you to learn Arabic and while your at it learn the true meaning of Ummah since a Ummah doesn't necessarily mean Muslim community but a COMMUNITY.
 
Last edited:

Astounded

Member
What has this to do with me you "poor" guy?

I advice you to learn Arabic and while your at it learn the true meaning of Ummah since a Ummah doesn't necessarily mean Muslim community but a COMMUNITY.

Ah yes....as stated in your tag line...one 'community....' that's at war...with itself????

I know about dhimmis in your ummah....
 

F0uad

Well-Known Member
Ah yes....as stated in your tag line...one 'community....' that's at war...with itself????

I know about dhimmis in your ummah....
Lol what are you trying to suggest, qouting something out of its full sentence is pretty silly.
Do you have a point that you want to make or are you just trolling, its strange that all your posts only have been on this thread..
 
Last edited:

beenie

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
**Staff Advisory**

Please keep Rule 1 in mind when posting:
1. Personal comments about Members and Staff
Personal attacks, and/or name-calling are strictly prohibited on the forums. Speaking or referring to a member in the third person, ie "calling them out" will also be considered a personal attack. Critique each other's ideas all you want, but under no circumstances personally attack each other or the staff.
 

FearGod

Freedom Of Mind
And BTW, since you like to post examples..I'll give you one that I would bet you won't respond to..

I understand that on the ceiling in the mosque on the temple mount..which I can't verify..cause I'm not allowed to go there either..that there is an inscription which is offensive to Christians that states- God has no Son.

What would happen if a statement such as- Jesus is the last true prophet and there ae no others to come.. appeared on a ceiling in a Coptic Church in Egypt???

Tell us.

What the difference if it'll be writtin on a ceiling or a book.

it is known that christians believe Jesus PBUH as the final prophet and it is written in Arabic books and taught by their priests,christians lived during the Islamic Empire and they were always free to do so except that they were ordered to pay the Jizya whereas muslims were paying the Zakat.
 

Aamer

Truth Seeker
Yah, I keep forgetting that you are the only true Muslim on the board...the Sunnis, Shias, Wahhabis,etc aren't really Muslims in your opinion... but they claim to be anyway..Maybe you would want to tell the forum who are the true Muslims so we can eliminate the confusion?? Or actually, in reference to my building a church post in Saudi Arabia, I would accept proposals from your 'Ummah," the Sunni 'Ummah,' the Shia 'Ummah,' etc or whatever 'Ummah' petitioning for a church to be built there.

And poor FOuad, your fellow 'Muslim' poster on the board..he must be more confused than me with his signature tag line:
The Muslim is a unique Ummah among the whole of mankind: Their land is ONE, their War is ONE, their Peace is ONE, their Honour is ONE and there Trust is ONE - Prophet Mohammed (sallallahou alayhi wasallam)


There are many Muslim countries that are tolerant of other religions such as Lebanon or Malaysia. I like how you use Saudi Arabia and Egypt, two of the most extreme Muslim countries. There are many Christians in Egypt btw. But on the flip side, what if I wanted to build a Mosque in Serbia or Armenia? How well would that be received? Or even GROUND ZERO? It goes both ways.
 

Sha'irullah

رسول الآلهة

Sha'irullah

رسول الآلهة
There are many Muslim countries that are tolerant of other religions such as Lebanon or Malaysia. I like how you use Saudi Arabia and Egypt, two of the most extreme Muslim countries. There are many Christians in Egypt btw. But on the flip side, what if I wanted to build a Mosque in Serbia or Armenia? How well would that be received? Or even GROUND ZERO? It goes both ways.

You should add Turkey, Indonesia, India(mostly) and Morocco to the tolerant nations as well. They are so nice people vacation there :beach:.
 
Top