Hmm.... This is perhaps not useful for you, but it's just a forum post you are free to ignore so here goes...
What I read in your posts was a focus on your relationship with other people, church members, your husband, fellow forum members etc. What do they think, what will they say, do they agree or disagree and so on.
We all have social lives and so such concerns about others inevitably come up. But I'm not sure such concerns need to be part of one's spirituality. I'm not even sure that beliefs need to be a significant part of one's spirituality.
Do you have children? If yes, does your love for them require beliefs or the agreement and support of other people? Don't you still love your kids whatever your husband might say about anything, or what church you attend, or what flavor of Christian you might be? It seems one's relationship with God could be of that nature.
You said you were inclined towards open minded Protestantism. An important part of Protestantism, much of what distinguishes it from Catholicism, is the notion that you can create and manage your own personal relationship with God without the need of experts or intermediaries. Just you and God, doing whatever you do together, nobody else's business really.
Just another angle to toss on the table.