Starsoul
Truth
Islam is not a matter of progeny and political affiliation through bloodlines, Allaah swt and the Prophet saww were very clear on that. The Prophet saww lived 3 days after asking for stuff (which shias insist that he asked to write his successors names )when he was nearing his final time, the evidence that shias accuse with in their stance's support is that " people around him did not want him to hand over khilafah to Ali (R.A),they became hypocrites". And then they also claim that Prophet knew all ghaib ilm (knowledge of the unseen, while it is the said in the Quran that the Prophet was only given certain news beforehand, like the shadah of the Imam Hussain and some more.) All this doesnt add up together, or in the Honor of either the Prophet or his progeny..
If Allaah swt willed it to happen, the Khilafah could NEVER have taken away from the Imams, full stop. Are the hypocrites more powerful than Allaah (nauzubillah) to snatch khilafah from the Prophet ,who is named the Prophet of All the Universes, was it So EASY to dupe him (Nauzubillah) and change Allaah's decree just because munafiqs are more powerful? and have more say in what happens next? They could just do whatever they wanted and Allaah would watch it silently, and helplessly without exposing them?is that how shias perceive the power and decree of Allaah swt?
I'm really concerned if these views are held by any muslim let alone a shia.. That kind of thinking actually gives more power to the munafiqs, when people actually think , that Allaah swt has No hand in the events of History, and only Munafiqs do? Munafiqs did this and did that, lets just stop being so obsessed about other munafiqs and lets just please focus on our Aqeeda and deeds, we are not half as pious or noble as the companions of the Prophet saww or his progeny of Imams, and we can Never be, then why feel jealous and create misguided false fitnah and hate propaganda over both of them and cry over the wrong essence of shahdah?
I'm aware all shia sects aren't alike and there are few very misguided who even say that Ali (R.A) is the image of God on Earth , and lives forever, never died; as If Allaah is not there for them , as If Allaah does not watch over them, as if Allaah is not capable of helping them, the way only those people could? They say maula ALi istead of Ya Allaah, very very damaging false concepts, truly sad and unbelievable for anyone who seeks righteous guidance always, is it not utter disrespect to Allaah swt to assign partners with Him, even if its with a Prophet or an Imam, truly fail to understand how a righteous person can convince himself to believe that..
May Allaah swt guide us all, aameen. As muslims we should seek only righteous guidance from Allaah swt everyday, directly, If we are sincere to accept that guidance.. One of my shia friend's husband read history and books in detail, and left some of his shia beliefs which he thought were based on shirk , his family was in chaos and called him kaafir..poor guy..
If Allaah swt willed it to happen, the Khilafah could NEVER have taken away from the Imams, full stop. Are the hypocrites more powerful than Allaah (nauzubillah) to snatch khilafah from the Prophet ,who is named the Prophet of All the Universes, was it So EASY to dupe him (Nauzubillah) and change Allaah's decree just because munafiqs are more powerful? and have more say in what happens next? They could just do whatever they wanted and Allaah would watch it silently, and helplessly without exposing them?is that how shias perceive the power and decree of Allaah swt?
I'm really concerned if these views are held by any muslim let alone a shia.. That kind of thinking actually gives more power to the munafiqs, when people actually think , that Allaah swt has No hand in the events of History, and only Munafiqs do? Munafiqs did this and did that, lets just stop being so obsessed about other munafiqs and lets just please focus on our Aqeeda and deeds, we are not half as pious or noble as the companions of the Prophet saww or his progeny of Imams, and we can Never be, then why feel jealous and create misguided false fitnah and hate propaganda over both of them and cry over the wrong essence of shahdah?
I'm aware all shia sects aren't alike and there are few very misguided who even say that Ali (R.A) is the image of God on Earth , and lives forever, never died; as If Allaah is not there for them , as If Allaah does not watch over them, as if Allaah is not capable of helping them, the way only those people could? They say maula ALi istead of Ya Allaah, very very damaging false concepts, truly sad and unbelievable for anyone who seeks righteous guidance always, is it not utter disrespect to Allaah swt to assign partners with Him, even if its with a Prophet or an Imam, truly fail to understand how a righteous person can convince himself to believe that..
May Allaah swt guide us all, aameen. As muslims we should seek only righteous guidance from Allaah swt everyday, directly, If we are sincere to accept that guidance.. One of my shia friend's husband read history and books in detail, and left some of his shia beliefs which he thought were based on shirk , his family was in chaos and called him kaafir..poor guy..
Last edited:
