Bennettresearch said:
[...] take for granted that we even have a planet to live on that is hospitable enough for us to create our own world.
That is absurd. If the planet was not hospitable enough, we would not be here. That is the natural order of the Universe. Life simply will not develope if the conditions are inhospitable. And we would not develope the capabilities of manipulating our world if the world was not hospitable enough to allow it. It is cause and effect. Not a coincdence. Not a miracle.
Bennettresearch said:
It is important to know everything you can about what has been written before deciding to accept or reject it. This is the logical (sneaked that in) approach. The question that can be asked of scipture or religious writings is how far removed the author was from the inspiration or word they were receiving. Meaning to say that the author's thoughts or understanding could still have a great influence over what was written down. There is the political aspect also. This is why someone can gain a highly advanced spiritual perpective through the study of these materials.
I never said that nothing can be gained from analyzing something that we have rejected. A perfect example of what I mean is Hitler. People have rejected him so thoroughly that they tend to deny that anything can be learned from him. Consequently, the only thing most people (or maybe this is specifically a US issue) really know about him is the monsterous things he did to the Jews. How about the gays, communists, and Atheists? What about the social engineering? What about the economy?
But this is not what you mean. You want us to consider "how far removed the author was from the inspiration or word they were receiving." But if we deny that any inspration or word would have been given, then this consideration would be meaningless. It is much more feasible, and historically popular, that a leader would invoke the name of the god of the masses in order to gain their unquestioning obedience. This should be obvious in situations like Moses, who found it appropriate to kill anyone who questioned his authority.