Even infinite kindness doesn't make up for torturing someone infinitely or knowingly allowing them to be tortured infinitely. That's just insane to say that anyone deserves infinite misery, let alone that the one inflicting the torture or allowing it to be inflicted could be "just," "good," or "merciful" in any respect.
No-one deserves to be tortured, or go through infinite misery, to even relate misery as an infliction from God is the most childish thing one can agree with.
For those who think that the Prophets had a flashy, luxurious life, just go through an independent biography of the Messengers of God , you'd be surprised how most of them lived in extremely low life circumstances, some did not have parents, people ridiculed them, they got stones thrown at them and pestered in every way beyond imagination. Why ,then did they not choose to disbelieve?
They could easily say, 'Lord I'm your best man, give me all the comfort that I deserve, ' but no, they never asked because they were told by God that, 'All men of God are tested and his best men will be tested the most.' And there was huge relief after every test , and his men were thankful to Him instead of walking away proud, pompous, and complaining. All people of this world have fairly better lives than the Messengers of Allah, cant be thankful enough for that..
When we buy a cloth, even we have expectations for it to run atleast for the price that it cost and the usual run time, why do we think that God would not test our capabilities as a creation? It's only to increase our ranks in Heaven. If there was a free huge mansion and plenty of beautiful women/men and 24 hr help around, being gifted to someone for a life time, we all would really be ready to do 'Anything' for that, but when God promises all this for the little miseries which We should KNOW ,never last for long, we just abandon the whole idea and of heaven to something even more depressing.
I agree we all go through very exhaustive experiences physically,mentally or emotionally in our lives but you have no right to think that Muslims lead a very comfortable and misery-free life, Whats happening in the Muslim world must give you an idea that they are being killed left right and centre ,their women being raped and children being blown up, should make us say' Oh, God is not helping us, 'He' is killing us so He does not exist!'
Nobody among the Muslims says that, why? because they know that no matter how trying the conditions would be for them in this world, the reward will be so huge that a man who went through the most miseries in life will THANK God that he was miserable in this world, for the huge rewards he'd receive in the afterlife.( mansions, women ,family everything he could not even dream of possessing in this world, would be all his and this is just a limited list, the rewards of heaven are huge!).Not only that, He'll forget all his pain at even the slightest glimpse of Heaven.
And when he will be asked 'How long did you stay in the world being miserable, he'd be like, ' just a day or a part of it maybe?" That is the true reality and time frame of our existence as compared to the afterlife, and we, owing to our lack of knowledge feel that we have lived an eternity here and nothing good would come out of it, well why not?
I'd want every reward for the slightest discomfort that i have endured, nobody can re-pay me in a way that I can forget the pain, Only God. So instead of directing my pain into aggression over disbelieve, I direct it towards patience in belief, honestly believing that there are people in this world living in worst conditions that I am, and that really is the truth, and the fact that all this will be over soon and all the misery will be gone.
I'm not impressed by such tricks.
You don't have to be, Its just a choice anyway, nobody's forcing you. I know Heaven is an idea so un-perceive-ably, beautifully, massively refreshing and prosperous that we want to continue feeling miserable in our existence rather than grasp the idea and get a grip on our life.
All miseries have made people stronger, its only those who deny themselves a chance to heaven who don't see the loving arms of God when they return from this world to the real one..Although a few definitions exist throughout the divine books, stealing a glimpse of heaven or hell before the test is complete, would be cheating really . It is just fair to keep the idea in a vivid imagination because there's different things different people want in heaven and there's no limit to how good they want it to be, an accurate description would just limit it's magnificence.