Hi, Mike,
First of all, let me tell you that if that's really you in those pictures (heh!) then you not only look fine - you look FINE. I am assuming that your challenge has something to do with your left eye, which I can't see well in the pictures. Even so, there's nothing grotesque or weird at all about the way you look. In fact, there are many downright attractive things about your looks.
I almost hate to use this as an example, because I've been accused of using my kids to establish "street cred" or seem cool (weird but now I'm self conscious about it) - but as you may know, I have four bi racial kids, very close together in age. When I was a young mom and would take my kids out in public, people would often stare at us.
Pretty early on, I figured out that most people were probably not staring out of hatefulness. There were many reasons for them to stare - first of all, that's a lot of kids. Secondly, they were very cute kids - but they sure didn't look like they belonged with me. I think people often were trying to figure out "Are those kids HERS? Biologically?"
I could either just assume that they were all prejudiced (which would be prejudiced and judgmental on my part), or I could give people the benefit of the doubt.
I began to see a positive challenge in this situation. I determined that IF people were prejudiced, then I would challenge their preconceived ideas, by being exactly what they did not expect me to be. And I would be gracious with them rather than defensive.
In other words, I began to look at people's surprise and sometimes probably negative reaction as an opportunity to prove their prejudices WRONG.
In the long run, this made me a better person.
Smile. Look them straight in the eye. Strike up a conversation on a positive note. Surprise the hell out of them.
Everyone will be better off! Seriously, you will feel better - and empowered.